Home | Ancient History Sourcebook | Medieval Sourcebook | Modern History Sourcebook | Byzantine Studies Page
by Abbot Francis Aidan Gasquet
"A VERITABLE MONK OF BURY ST. EDMUND'S IS WORTH ATTENDING
TO, IF BY CHANCE MADE VISIBLE AND AUDIBLE. HERE HE IS; AND IN
HIS HAND A MAGICAL SPECULUM, MUCH GONE TO RUST, INDEED, YET IN
FRAGMENTS STILL CLEAR; WHEREIN THE MARVELLOUS IMAGE OF
HIS EXISTENCE DOES STILL SHADOW ITSELF, THOUGH FITFULLY,
AND AS WITH AN INTERMITTENT LIGHT "
FEW medieval documents have exercised a greater fascination over men's minds in these latter days than " The Chronicle of Jocelin of Brakelond." More than sixty years ago the publication of the Latin text of this history, by the Camden Society, attracted the attention of the great Thomas Carlyle, and furnished him with material for sketching his picture of " The Ancient Monk," which occupied the entire second book of his Past and Present. Although the modern sage in his own rugged way affected no little contempt for what he called this " extremely foreign book," and for " the monk-Latin " in which it was written, it is evident that Jocelin's simple story of the wise, firm, yet withal gentle rule of a medieval abbot over a great English monastery cast a spell over him the influence of which can be detected in every page of his delightful and almost surprisingly sympathetic account of Abbot Samson and of Edmundsbury.
In this case the Past, as Carlyle read it in the "Chronicle," was so entirely different from the Present, as he knew it in his day, that the wonder is not that he was fascinated by it, but that he was able with its help to paint so true and living a picture and to fashion so fitting a frame in which to set it. For to him, without doubt, the story dealt with what he regarded as "vanished existences"-" ideas, life-furniture, whole workings and ways," which were not only Past, but gone beyond recall, and " covered deeper than Pompeii with the lava-ashes and inarticulate wreck of seven hundred years!"
And indeed it cannot be denied that the ideals and aspirations, as revealed to us in the history of Abbot Samson and, so far as we know, in the life story of his biographer Jocelin, arc of a higher and almost a different order to those of our modern world. To men of their calling in those far-off times, the natural and the supernatural were united and intermingled in the simplest and most ordinary way. Their very notions of the unseen world are almost sufficient to take away the breath of those whose lots have been cast in this more material and prosaic age of doubts and disbelief's. To Samson, and Jocelin, and their fellow-monks at Edmundsbury in the twelfth century, heaven, as a great writer has said of earlier English monasticism, was hardly even " next door." The future life was merely the present continued, and each man went forth to his task as it came and laboured at it day by day, not with any idea of finishing it, but only of carrying on for the span of his allotted existence. They built, and planted, and wrote till the end came, and then they went to heaven and others stepped into their places and took up the common work. It was indeed a "simple life": it was almost Arcadian in its picturesque simplicity, and, as Cardinal Newman says of the same life in the days of our Venerable Bede, it reminds us of those times in the dayspring of the world, when Adam delved and Abel watched the flocks, and Noah tended his vines, and angels visited them.
This living belief in the nearness and all-importance of the supernatural is the key-note of Jocelin's charming story of a few brief years in the long history of an old English abbey, a new translation of which is here given to the public. As a story, however, Brakelond's " Chronicle " is not wholly, nor indeed mostly, either mysterious or incredible " there are troubles, and trials, and difficulties enough recounted by the writer; and at every turn we may see evidences of human nature and even of human struggles and passions, which are sufficient, and as some may perhaps think, more than sufficient, to show us that it is a history of men, and not of angels, which the old monk is setting forth so naturally and so truthfully. At any rate, there is quite sufficient of the human element in the narrative to give most of us a human interest in the story.
And this itself is proof that Jocelin is a true chronicler of what really took place, and no mere romancer tempted to edit or suppress entirely what might not be unto " edification." He manifests no desire to make himself or his brethren appear other than what they were in reality that is, thorough Englishmen, with strong wills and human passions, which, though these same passions might occasionally appear to gain the mastery, they were at all times endeavouring to subdue unto God's service by the help of His grace and through the broad-minded provisions of St. Benedict's Rule. The actors who appear in this living drama, though they are for the most part monks, are obviously men, natural and human enough in all their works and words; but these men are at the same time also monks, endeavouring to raise their minds and hearts to supernatural ideals, and striving to attain to that personal communion with God which is the aim and object of all true religion and of all religious observance and practice. This is "another world truly," writes Carlyle, " and this present poor distressed world might get some profit by looking wisely into it, instead of foolishly. But at lowest, O dilettante friend, let us know always that it was a world, and not a void infinite of grey haze with phantasms swimming in it. These old St. Edmundsbury walls, I say, were not peopled with phantasms, but with men of flesh and blood, made altogether as we are. Had thou- and 1 then been, who knows but we ourselves had taken refuge from an evil Time and fled to dwell here, and meditate on an Eternity, in such fashion as we could " Alas, how like an old osseous fragment, a broken blackened shinbone of the old dead Ages, this black ruin looks out, not yet covered by the soil; still indicating what a once gigantic Life lies buried there " It is dead now, and dumb " but was alive once and spake For twenty generations, here was the earthly arena where painful living men worked out their life-wrestle, looked at by Earth, by Heaven and Hell. Bells tolled to prayers " and men of many humours, various thoughts, chanted Vespers and Matins; -- and round the little islet of their life rolled for ever (as round ours still rolls, though we are blind and deaf) the illimitable Ocean, tinting all things with its eternal hues and reflexes, making strange prophetic music! How silent now! "
The Author.-Jocelin de Brakelond, the writer of the Chronicle called by his name, was a monk of Edmundsbury. The date of his birth is uncertain, but as he became a novice in that abbey in 1173, we may suppose that he was born not later than 1156. It has been conjectured that he was a native of Bury St. Edmunds, and that his name Brakelond was derived from that of an ancient street of the city, in accordance with the common practice of calling monks by the name of the place from which they came to religion. Little more is known about him than he tells us incidentally in the course of his narrative, but one of his contemporaries in the monastery speaks of him as "a man of excellent religious observance, as well as a power both in word and work "-eximiae religionis, potens sermone et otere. Carlyle sees him in his writing as a man of a "patient, peaceable, loving, clear- smiling nature." A "wise simplicity," he adds, "is in him; much natural sense; a veracity that goes deeper than words." What more can we desire in a writer, especially when we may add that he shows himself to have been a cultured man, acquainted with the ancient authors, quoting Virgil and Horace and Ovid? His knowledge of the Bible is naturally extensive, and, as was common in those days, his very phraseology is obviously founded upon the sacred text. He once likewise cites, with acknowledgment, a short passage from the more modern Ralph de Diceto's Imagines Historiaruin. Our latter-day philosopher praises him also because he shows himself to have "a pleasant wit; and to love a timely joke, though in a mild subdued manner; very amiable to see."
In AD . 1173, as just noted, Jocelin entered the community and passed under the care of Samson of Tottington, who subsequently became abbot, but who was then Master of novices. The then abbot, Hugh, was old, and although a high standard of the religious exercises and of the monastic life inside the cloister was maintained, the temporalities were in a sad state, and year by year tended to get from bad to worse, so that Jocelin's early experiences of monastic life were connected with anxieties about the load of debt to moneylenders under which Edmundsbury groaned.
He tells us that he had himself seen bonds for repayment made out to the Jews, under which, for failure to meet the sums falling due, the original loan had grown in eight years from £100 to £800. No wonder that the youthful religious questioned his Master of novices as to why some remedy was not found by those in authority for a state of things which meant temporal ruin and disgrace for the community of Edmundsbury.
In 1180 Abbot Hugh met with an accident and died. After a period of a year and three months the former Master of novices, Samson, then the provident Sacrist, was chosen in his place. It was during this period of vacancy that, in recording something which happened in the monastery, Jocelin incidentally makes mention of another literary work of his own, namely, the Book of the Miracles of St. Robert, a boy supposed to have been martyred by the Jews in 1118, who was entombed in the church at Edmundsbury.
On the election of Samson, Jocelin was appointed his chaplain, and this brought him into the closest connection with the abbot for six years. In 1198 and 1200 he was Guest-master, and in 1212 he held the office of Almoner. In all these offices the future chronicler had exceptional means of acquiring information, and these he utilised in writing the story of Abbot Samson's administration, which is introduced by a vivid sketch of the temporal disorder of the house in the closing years of Abbot Hugh. His Chronicle covers the period of the history of Edmundsbury from 1173 to 1190 , and, as he says in the beginning, "he took care to write only what he himself saw and heard." The date of his death is uncertain.
The "Chronicle." -The Latin text of Cronica Joceline is found complete only in one manuscript - Harl. MS. 1005 - in the British Museum. It was printed for the first time by the Camden Society in 1840 under the editorship of I. G. Gage Rokewood, who supplied a valuable Introduction and notes, of which subsequent editors have availed themselves. The text was likewise printed in Mr. Thomas Arnold's Memorials of St. Edmund's Abbey (Rolls Series) I., pp. 209-336
In 1844, under the title Monastic and Social Life in the Twelfth century, as exemplified in the Chronicle of Jocelin of Brakelond, .AD. 1173-1202 , the work was translated by Thomas Edlyne Tomlins. Carlyle's work, Past and Present, published in 1843 had already drawn attention to the " Chronicle of Jocelin," and another edition of Mr. Tomlins' work was called for in 1849. This translation has since appeared at least once, but for the present edition a new English version has been carefully prepared from the original Latin text of the Chronicle.
Abbot Samson.-The central figure and, as we may say, " the hero" of Jocelin's story is, of course, Abbot Samson. He was born in 1135 at Tottington, near Thetford, in Norfolk. His father appears to have died when Samson was young, and a pretty legend of a boyish dream in which St. Edmund extended his protection to the child against the assaults of the devil, and the recognition of the place seen in the dream as the gate of the monastery of St. Edmundsbury, when his mother had taken him with her on a pilgrimage to the shrine of the saint, led to his taking refuge in the cloister. He had received his early instruction from a schoolmaster named William of Diss, and he attained the degree of Master of Arts in the University of Paris. In this place we are not concerned with the events of his life " these may be read for the most part in the Chronicle of Jocelin of Brakelond. What alone seems to be called for in this brief Introduction is some account of his person and character as it is manifested in the scattered evidences of his acts.
If we want a picture of the man let us take Carlyle's, who sketches " the substantial figure of a man with eminent nose, bushy brows, and clear-flashing eyes, his russet beard growing daily greyer," and his hair which, before his elevation to the abbot's chair, had been black, becoming daily more and more silvered with his many cares. We know something of the task that was before him when he gathered up the reins of office, and we may be sure he knew more. But as we see him in the pages of Jocelin, he was not the man to flinch from his duty, or to seek to let difficulties mend themselves by pretending that he did not see them. From the time that he walked barefooted into his church to be installed in the abbatial chair, he let all see that he was abbot and had come to rule. He had set his whole strength to accomplish a great task and his shoulders to sustain an almost overwhelming burden, when in the hour of his election he walked to the altar singing the Miserere mei with his brethren. " His head was held erect," says the faithful Jocelin, " and his face showed no change," a portent which called from the king the remark "This abbot-elect seems to think himself capable of governing an abbey."
"It is beautiful" -writes Carlyle in a philosophical appreciation of the principles of monastic government -- "it is beautiful how the chrysalis governing-soul, shaking off its dusty slough and prison, starts forth winged, a true royal soul! Our new abbot has a right honest, unconscious feeling, without insolence as without fear or flutter, of what he is and what others are. A courage to quell the proudest, an honest pity to encourage the humblest. Withal there is a noble reticence in this Lord Abbot: much vain unreason he hears ; lays up without response. He is not there to expect reason and nobleness of others, he is there to give them of his own reason and nobleness. Is he not their servant, who can suffer from them and for them ; bear the burden their poor spindle-limbs totter and stagger under ; and in virtue of being their servant, govern them, lead them out of weakness to strength, out of defeat into victory?"
Abbot Samson ruled over his house for thirty years, and when in 1212 , ten years after the end of Jocelin's Chronicle, he died, he was followed to the grave by a sorrowing community whose unstinted reverence and affection he had won. An unknown monk of Edmundsbury, the author of another Chronicle of the house, thus wrote of him: ---Onthe 30th December, at St. Edmund's, died Samson, of pious memory, the venerable abbot of that place ; after he had prosperously ruled the abbey committed to him for thirty years and had freed it from a load of debt, had enriched it with privileges, liberties, possessions and spacious buildings and had restored the worship of the church both internally and externally, in the most ample manner. Then bidding his last farewell to his sons, by whom the blessed man deserved to be blest for evermore, whilst they were all standing ;by and gazing with awe at a death which was a cause for admiration, not for regret, in the fourth year of the interdict he rested in peace."
The first business to which Abbot Samson applied himself after his election was the task of understanding and grappling with the deplorable financial state of his house. He insisted upon the immediate production of every claim against the monastery, and by personally visiting each of its many manors he gained a correct knowledge of its resources. Within twelve months he had formed his plans and had quieted every creditor : within twelve years the entire debt had been paid off, and he could turn his attention to building and adorning the house of St. Edmund. It is impossible to read the pages of Jocelin without seeing that the ruling idea of the abbot's life was his devotion to his great patron, St. Edmund. He was the servant, after God, of the saint, his representative and the upholder of his honour and privileges, the champion of his rights, the guardian of his property. Inspired by this thought he worked to make Edmundsbury worthy of its patron, and in his success he saw the result of the saint's intercession and protection.
"Apart from this special devotion to St. Edmund, it is easy to see," writes Mr. Thomas Arnold, " that Samson was an earnestly religious man, and not a Christian by halves. After the news had come of the capture of Jerusalem by the Saracens Samson took the loss of the Holy Places so much to heart, that from that time he wore undergarments of hair-cloth and abstained from the use of meat."
He was, too, a thorough Englishman, and read admirably - elegantissmie - the Bible in English scripturam anglice scriptam - and "he was wont to preach to the people in English-but in the dialect of Norfolk where he had been born and bred." On one occasion he gives as a reason, and as some may think, a somewhat strange reason, for appointing a monk to an office, that " he did not know French." He was no doubt anxious to secure that St. Edmundsbury should be truly national, with its roots deep in the soil of his country, to teach it to build up its own traditions, and to let People see that it was, a great English house.
But Samson's work was not accomplished without grave anxiety, none the less because it was unseen by others. Though he walked upright with a smiling face, and had ever the courage to battle for the rights of his house when there was need, in a way that might make people regard him as a man of iron nerve possessed of a soul that never felt any trouble, nevertheless in the first fourteen years of his administration his black hair was blanched as white as snow, and Jocelin speaks of hearing his beloved master walking about when all were in bed and relieving his pent-up feelings with sighs and groans. Once the chronicler took courage to tell his master that he had thus heard him in his night vigil, and to this the abbot replied: "'Tis no wonder. you (as my chaplain) share in the streets of my office, in tile meat and drink, in the journeys and the like, but you little think what I have to do to provide for my house and family, or of the many and difficult matters of my pastoral office, which are always pressing upon me " these are the things which make my soul anxious and cause me to sigh."
And so when Abbot Samson came to die, the
thin veil which to him and his monks of Edmundsbury alone hid
the world to come from their vision was parted, and the supernatural
life eternal was revealed to him in the most natural of ways.
He passed from labour for God and St. Edmundsbury, to rest in
God and with his loved patron, carrying with him the full sheaves
of his good works. Carlyle has only partially caught the idea
when he writes: "Genuine work alone, what thou workest faithfully,
that is eternal." " Yes," he concludes, "
a noble Abbot Samson resigns himself to oblivion " feels
it no hardship, but a comfort " counts it as a still resting-place,
for much sick fret, and fever, and stupidity, which in the night-watches
often made his strong heart sigh."
THE AUTHOR'S PREFACE
I HAVE undertaken to write of those things which I have seen and
heard, and which have occurred in the church of Saint Edmund,
from the year in which the Flemings were taken without the town,
in which year also I assumed the religious habit, and in which
Prior Hugh was deposed and Robert made Prior in his room. And
I have related the evil as a warning, and the good for an example.
THE AUTHOR'S PREFACE
THE CHRONICLE OF JOCELIN OF BRAKELOND
How abbot Hugh ruled the church of St. Edmund
How the monastery was freed from legatine visitation
Concerning master Dennis the cellarer
How abbot Hugh strove to win the favour of master Samson
How abbot Hugh came by his death
How the death of abbot Hugh was told to the king, and of those things which the servants of the king did .
How the prior ruled the monastery, while there was no abbot
How the cellarer and the sacristan behaved during the vacancy
Concerning the conduct of Samson the sub-sacristan during the vacancy
How the enemies of Samson prevailed against him, but only for a time
How the monks disputed amongst themselves which of them should be abbot
How Samson the subsacristan bore himself while others discussed the vacancy .
How the author spoke his mind too hastily
How the archbishop of Norway dwelt in the abbot's lodgings while the abbacy was vacant
Of the martyrdom of Saint Robert
How thirteen men were chosen, by command of the king, to elect an abbot in the presence of the king
How Samson suggested that the monastery should appoint men to make a secret choice of an abbot, and how this was done.
How, on the advice of Samson, it was decided what should be done if the king would not grant freedom of election
How the chosen thirteen journeyed to the king
Of the dreams which the brothers dreamed concerning the election of a new abbot .
How the thirteen came to the king and showed to him the names of those whom the confessors had selected
How the thirteen, by command of the king, chose three other names from the monastery and three strangers
How the list of names was reduced from nine to two
How Samson was elected abbot
How the news of the election came to the monastery, and how Samson was blessed.
How Samson, having been made abbot, returned and was received at the monastery
How abbot Samson began to rule the monastery
How the abbot met the demand of Thomas de Hastings that his nephew should be steward
How the abbot dealt with the lands of his house
Of that which was done at the abbot's first chapter
How certain men wished to conspire against the abbot
How the abbot journeyed through the lands
of Saint Edmund, and how lie escaped death at Warkton
How the creditors of the abbey demanded payment, and how the abbot took his manors into his own hand
How the abbot did not then take Harlow into his own hand
How the abbot managed the lands which he farmed himself
How abbot Samson was made a justice, and how he bore himself in this office
How some men made complaint against the abbot How the author talked with the abbot concerning the sadness of his manner . Concerning a dream which the abbot had when a boy
How the abbot restrained his temper that he might not offend
How the abbot forbade secret accusations, and how he ordered the restoration of all private seals
Concerning further regulations which the abbot made
Concerning the appearance and private character of the abbot
How abbot Samson dealt with flatterers
How abbot Samson managed his household
How the abbot treated those monks with whom he had been intimate before he became abbot
How the abbot treated his relations
How the abbot was mindful of those who had shown kindness to him in the past, and how he treated those who had been harsh
Concerning other good acts of abbot Samson
How the Jews were driven from Saint Edmund's
How the abbot secured the manor of Mildenhall, and endowed the hospital at Babwell
Concerning the church of Woolpit, and how it was secured for the abbey .
How the abbot disputed with the archbishop concerning the manor of Eleigh
How the abbot wished to take the cross, and how he offered to seek king Richard in Germany
How the abbot resisted the authority of the legate
Of the conduct of the abbot while king Richard was in captivity
Concerning that which befel certain knights who desired to hold a tournament contrary to the wish of the abbot
Concerning the missions of the abbot to the papal court
How the abbot met the claim of Earl de Clare to bear the standard of Saint Edmund
Concerning the case of Adam de Cokefield
How the mill which Herbert the dean had built was overturned
How the right of the abbot to present to certain churches was disputed, and what befel in the matter
How abbot Samson disputed with Jordan de Ros
How the author made a list of the abbot's churches as a gift to the abbot, and the names of those churches
How the abbot freed his church from contribution to the fine inflicted on Norfolk and Suffolk
How the abbot disputed with his knights
Concerning Henry of Essex
How the abbot deceived the bishop of Ely for the good of his church .
How there were disputes concerning the appointment of bailiffs for the town
How abbot Samson disputed with the men of London about the payment of tolls
How there was a dispute with the burghers is to dues from the town
Concerning the charter granted to the town by the abbot
How the monastery was troubled with in competent cellarers
How the abbot resisted Hubert Walter when he claimed legatine authority over the abbey
How the abbot contended with his knights as to service across the sea
How the abbot took charge of the cellar, and how for that cause murmuring arose in the monastery
Concerning the will of Hamo Blund
How there were riots in the cemetery, and concerning that which was done in the matter
Whether it is better to have an abbot from one's own house
How there was a quarrel with the monks of Ely
How the abbot disputed with the bishop of Ely
How king John summoned the abbot to him, and of that which was done thereupon
How the abbot left the monastery in peace with all men
TABLE OF DATES
LIST OF THE ABBOTS OF ST. EDMUND'S
OF JOCELIN OF BRAKELOND
HOW ABBOT HUGH RULED THE CHURCH OF ST. EDMUND
In those days Abbot Hugh grew old, and his eyes were dim. He was a good and kindly man, a godfearing and pious monk, but in temporal matters he was unskilful and improvident. He relied too much on his own intimates and believed too readily in them, rather trusting to a stranger's advice than using his own judgment. It is true that discipline and the service of God, and all that pertained to the rule, flourished greatly within the cloister, but without the walls all-things were mismanaged. For every man, seeing that he served a simple and ageing lord, did not that which was right, but that which was pleasing in his own eyes. The townships and all the hundreds of the abbot were given to firm ; the woods were destroyed, and the houses on the manors were on the verge of ruin ; from day to day all things grew worse. The abbot's sole resource and means of relief was in borrowing money, that so it might at least be possible to maintain the dignity of his house. For eight years before his death, there was never an Easter or Michaelmas which did not see at least one or two hundred pounds added to the debt. The bonds were ever renewed, and the growing interest was converted into principal.
This disease spread from the head to the members, from the ruler to his subjects. So it came to pass that if any official had a seal of his own, he also bound himself in debt as he listed, both to Jews and Christians. Silken caps, and golden vessels, and the other ornaments of the church, were often placed in pledge without the assent of the monastery. I have seen a bond made to William Fitzlsabel for a thousand and two score pounads ,but know not the why nor wherefore. And I have seen another bond to Isaac, son of Rabbi Joce, for four hundred pounds, but know not wherefore it was made. I have seen also a third bond to Benedict, the Jew of Norwich, for eight hundred and fourscore pounds, and this was the origin and cause of that debt.
Our buttery was destroyed, and the sacristan William received it to restore whether he would or no. He secretly borrowed forty marks at interest from Benedict the Jew, and made him a bond, scaled with a certain seal which was wont to hang at the shrine of St. Edmund. With this the gilds and brotherhoods used to be sealed ; afterwards, but in no great haste, it was destroyed by order of the monastery. Now when that debt increased to one hundred pounds, the Jew came, bearing letters of the lord king concerning the sacristan's debt, and then at last that which had been hidden from the abbot and the monks appeared. So the abbot in anger would have deposed the sacristan, alleging a privilege of the lord pope that enabled him to remove William his sacristan when he would. However, there came one to the abbot, who pleaded for the sacristan, and so won over the abbot that he suffered a bond to be made to Benedict the Jews for four hundred pounds, payable at the end of four years, that is, a bond for the hundred pounds to which the interest had increased, and for another hundred pounds which the same Jew had lent to the sacristan for the use of the abbot. And in full chapter the sacristan obtained that all this debt should be paid, and a bond was made and sealed with the seal of the monastery. For the abbot pretended that the debt was no concern of his, and did not affix his seal. However, at the end of the four years there was nothing wherewith the debt might be discharged, and a new bond was made for eight hundred and fourscore pounds, which was to be repaid at stated times, every year fourscore pounds.
And the same Jew had many other bonds for smaller debts, and one bond which was for fourteen years, so that the sum of the debt owing to that Jew was a thousand and two hundred pounds, over and above the amount by which usury had increased it.
Then came the almoner of the lord king and told the lord abbot that many rumours concerning these great debts had come to the king. And when counsel had been taken with the prior and a few others, the almoner was brought into the chapter. Then, when we were seated and were silent, the abbot said: " Behold the almoner of the king, our lord and friend and yours, who, moved by love of God and Saint Edmund, has shown to us that the lord king has heard some evil report of us and you, and that the affairs of the church are illmanaged within and without the walls. And therefore I will, and command you upon your vow of obedience, that you say and make known openly how our affairs stand." So the prior arose, and speaking as it were one for all, said that the church was in good order, and that the rule was well and strictly kept within, and matters outside the walls carefully and discreetly managed; and that though we, like others round us, were slightly involved in debt, there was no debt which might give us cause for anxiety. When he heard this, the almoner said that he rejoiced greatly to hear this witness of the monastcry, by which he meant these words of the prior. And the prior, and Master Geoffrey of Coutances, answered in these same words on another occasion, when they spoke in defence of the abbot at the time when Archbishop Richard, by virtue of his legatine power, came into our chapter, in the days before we possessed that exemption which we now enjoy.
Now I was then in my novitiate, and on a convenient occasion talked
of these things to my master, who was teaching me the Rule, and
in whose care I was placed ; he was Master Samson, who was afterwards
abbot. "What is this," I said, "that I hear? And
why do you keep silence when you see and hear such things
you, who are a cloistered monk, and desire not offices, and fear
God rather than man? " But he answered and said, "My
son, the newly burnt child feareth the fire, and so is it with
me and with many another. Prior Hugh has been lately deposed and
sent into exile; Dennis, and Hugo, and Roger de Hingham have but
lately returned to the house from exile. I was in like manner
imprisoned, and afterwards was sent to Acre, for that we spoke
to the common good of our church against the will of the abbot.
This is the hour of darkness ; this is the hour in the which flatterers
triumph and arc believed ; their might is increased, nor can we
prevail against them. These things must be endured for a while
the Lord see and judge! "
HOW THE MONASTERY WAS FREED FROM LEGATINE VISITATION
THERE came a rumour to Abbot Hugh that Richard, Archbishop of
Canterbury, purposed to come and to hold a visitation of our church
by virtue of his legatine authority. And having taken advice,
the abbot sent to Rome and obtained exemption from the power of
the said legate. But when the messenger returned to us frorn Rome,
there was not found means of paying that which he had promised
to the lord pope and to the cardinals, unless in the circumstances
use might be made of the cross which was above the high altar,
and of a Mary, and a John, which images Archbishop Stigand had
adorned with much weight of gold and silver, and had given to
the blessed Edmund. Then some among our number, who were very
intimate with the abbot, said that the very shrine of Saint Edmund
itself ought to be stripped in order to win so notable a privilege.
But they considered not the great danger that might ensue from
so great liberty. For if by chance we should have an abbot who
wished to waste the goods of the church and evilly entreat his
monastery, then there would be no one to whom the monastery might
make complaint of the evil deeds of the abbot, who would fear
neither bishop, nor archbishop, nor legate, and whose impunity
would give him boldness in wrongdoing.
CONCERNING MASTER DENNIS THE CELLARER
Now in those days the cellarer, like the rest of the officers of the monastery, borrowed money from Jurnet the Jew, without the knowledge of the monastery, on a bond sealed with the seal mentioned above. But when the debt had grown to three score pounds, the monastery was called upon to discharge the debt of the cellarer. He was deposed, though he defended himself by saying that for three years he, by command of the abbot, had received all guests in the guesthouse, whether the abbot were at home or no, whom the abbot ought to have received according to the constitution of the house.
In his stead Master Dennis was appointed, and by his economy and care reduced that debt of sixty pounds to thirty. Towards the extinction of that debt we paid the thirty marks which Benedict de Blakeham gave to the monastery for the manors of Newton and Whepstead. But the Jew's bond remains with the Jew to this day, and in it twenty-six pounds are written down as principal and for the debt of the cellarer.
On the third day after Master Dennis was made cellarer, three
knights with their squires were brought into the guesthouse
to be entertained there, the abbot being at home and sitting in
his chamber. Now when that greathearted Achilles heard this,
not wishing to fail in his office as did the others, he arose
and took the keys of the cellar, and bearing the knights with
him to the hall of the abbot, came himself into the abbot's presence.
And he said to him, " Lord, you know well that the custom
of the abbey is that knights and laymen be received in your hall,
if the abbot be at home. 1 neither wish, nor am I able, to receive
guests whose entertainment is your care. But if it be otherwise,
take the keys of your cellar, and appoint another cellarer at
your pleasure." When the abbot heard this, he received those
knights perforce and ever after he received knights and laymen
in accordance with ancient custom. And they are still so received
when the abbot is at home.
HOW ABBOT HUGH STROVE TO WIN THE FAVOUR OF MASTER SAMSON
AT one time Abbot Hugh desired to win the favour Of Master Samson,
and made him his subsacristan. He was often accused, often transferred
from one office to another. For he was made guest-master, and
then pittincemaster, then third prior and finally again
subsacristan. Then many strove against him who afterwards were
his flatterers. But Samson did not bear himself as did the other
officials, nor could he ever be brought to flatter. Wherefore
the abbot said to his intimates that never had he seen a man whom
he could not bend to his will, save Samson the subsacristan.
HOW ABBOT HUGH CAME BY HIS DEATH
AD 1180, 9th September
IN the twentythird year of his being abbot, it came into the mind of Abbot Hugh to journey to the shrine of the blessed Thomas to pray there. And when he was almost at his journey's end, and was near unto Rochester on the morrow of the Nativity of the Blessed Mary, he most unhappily fell, so that his kneepan was put out and lodged in the ham of his leg. Physicians hastened to him, and put him to pain in many ways, but they healed him not. So he was borne back to us in a horselitter, and received with great concern, as was fitting. To put it shortly, his leg mortified and the sickness spread to his heart. Pain brought on a tertian fever, and in the fourth fit he died, rendering his soul to God on the morrow of Saint Brice's day.
Ere he was dead, all things were thrown into disorder by his servants,
so that in the abbot's houses there was nothing at all left, except
stools and tables which could not be carried away. There hardly
remained to the abbot a coverlet and quilts which were old and
torn, and which someone who had taken away those which were sound,
had left in their place. There was not even some thing of a penny's
value which might be given to the poor for the good of his Soul.
The sacristan said that it was not his affair to do this, declaring
that he had found the money for the expenses of the abbot and
his household for a full month, since neither would those who
farmed the townships pay anything before the appointed time, nor
would the creditors give any grace, as they saw the abbot to be
sick unto death. However the tenant of Palegrave found fifty shillings
for distribution to the poor, because he entered upon his tenancy
of Palegrave on that day. But those fifty shillings were afterwards
again paid to the king's officers, who exacted the full rent for
the use of the king.
HOW THE DEATH OF ABBOT HUGH WAS TOLD TO THE KING, AND OF THOSE THINGS WHICH THE SERVANTS OF THE KING DID
WHEN Abbot Hugh had been laid to rest, it was decreed in the chapter
that one should tell the death of the abbot to Ranulf de GlanvIll,
Justiciar of England. Master Samson and Master Robert Ruffus hastened
across the sea, bearing this same news to the lord King, and obtained
from him letters directing that the possessions and revenues of
the monastery, which were distinct from those of the abbot, should
remain entirely in the hands of the prior and of the monastery,
and that the rest of the abbey's property should be in the hands
of the King. The wardship of the abbey was given to Robert de
Cokefield and to Robert de Flainvill the seneschal, who at once
placed under surety and pledges those of the servants and relatives
of the abbot to whom the abbot had given anything after he fell
ill, or who had taken anything from the property of the abbot.
And they also treated the chaplain of the abbot in the same way,
for whom the prior became surety. And entering our vestry, they
made a double inventory of all the ornaments of the church.
HOW THE PRIOR RULED THE MONASTERY, WHILE THERE WAS NO ABBOT
THERE being no abbot, the prior took care, above all things, to
preserve peace in the monastery and to maintain the repute of
the house in the matter of receiving guests. He wished to disturb
no one, to provoke no one to anger, that he might keep all men
and all things in quiet. But he overlooked some acts of our officials
which should have been corrected ; and especially in the case
of the sacristan, as if he cared not how that office was performed.
Now the sacristan, while the abbey was vacant, neither paid any
debt nor erected any building, but the offerings and accidental
receipts were foolishly wasted. Wherefore the prior, who was head
of the monastery, seemed to many to be blameworthy, and was called
slack. And our brothers reminded each other of this when the time
came for electing an abbot.
HOW THE CELLARER AND THE SACRISTAN BEHAVED DURING THE VACANCY
OUR cellarer entertained all guests of whatever condition, at
the expense of the monastery. William the sacristan, for his part
gave and spent. Kind man! he spent indiscriminately, and blinded
the eyes of all with gifts.
CONCERNING THE CONDUCT OF SAMSON THE SUBSACRISTAN DURING THE VACANCY
SAMSON the subsacristan, who was master over the workmen, did
his utmost that nothing which was broken, and no chink or crack,
should remain unrepaired. In this way lie won the favour of the
monastery, and more especially of the cloistered monks. At that
time, and under Samson's direction, was our choir built. He determined
the subjects . the paintings, and composed elegiac verses for
them. He made a great store of stone and sand for building the
great tower of the church. And when he was asked where he found
the money for this work, he answered that some of the townsfolk
had given him money secretly for the building and completing of
the tower. But some of our brothers said that Warin our monk and
custodian of the shrine, had agreed to take, or as it were to
steal, some part of the offerings of the shrine, and to spend
it for the necessary purposes of the church, especially for the
building of the tower. They were led to this opinion by the fact
that they saw the strange uses to which these offerings were put
by others, who, to speak the truth, did steal them. And in order
to remove from themselves the suspicion of so happy a theft, Samson
and Warin made a hollow chest, in the middle of the cover of which
there was a hole, and which was secured with an iron bar. This
chest they caused to be placed in the great church near the door
outside the choir, where all the people passed by, that men might
place therein gifts for the building of the tower.
HOW THE ENEMIES OF SAMSON PREVAILED AGAINST HIM, BUT ONLY FOR A TIME
BUT William the sacristan mistrusted his colleague Samson, as did many others, both Christians and Jews, who favoured the opinion of the same William. The Jews, I say, to whom the sacristan was said to be a father and a patron. And they did rejoice in his protection, having freedom to enter and to leave the monastery, and wandering all over it. For they walked by the altars and round the shrine while high mass was being celebrated ; their money was lodged in our treasury under the care of the sacristan ; and, a thing still more foolish, their wives and little ones were entertained in our pittancy during time of war.
Therefore, having taken counsel together how they might attack
Samson, his enemies and adversaries went to Robert de Cokefield
and to his colleague, who had the wardship of the abbey, and persuaded
them to forbid in the name of the king that any one should do
any work or build anything while the abbacy was vacant, but rather
should the money from he offerings be collected and saved for
the payment of some part of the debt. Thus was Samson mocked,
and his strength went from him, and he could not from that time
do any work as he desired. But though his enemies could delay
his work, they could not finaly interrupt it. For he regained
his strength and overthrew the two middle pillars, that is, he
removed the two wardens in whom the malice of the others trusted.
And afterwards in course of time, the Lord gave him power to perform
his vow that he would build the said tower, and to finish it according
to his wish. And so it came to pass as though a voice from Heaven
had said to him, " Well done, thou good and faithful servant
; thou hast been faithful over a few things; I will make thee
ruler over many things."
HOW THE MONKS DISPUTED AMONG THEMSELVES WHICH OF THEM SHOULD BE ABBOT
THE abbacy being vacant, we often, as was right, made supplication unto the Lord and to the blessed martyr Edmund that they would give us and our church a fit pastor. Three times in each week, after leaving the chapter, did we prostrate ourselves in the choir and sing seven penitential psalms. And there were some who would not'. have been so earnest in their prayers if they had known who was to become abbot. , As to the choice of an abbot, if the king should grant us free election, there was much difference of opinion, some of it openly expressed, some of it privately ; and every man had his own ideas.
One said of a certain brother, " He, that brother, is a good monk, a likely person. He knows much of the rule and of the customs of the church. It is true that he is not so profoundly wise as are some others, but he is quite capable of being abbot. Abbot Ording Was illiterate, and yet he was a good abbot and ruled this house wisely ; and one reads in the fable that the frogs did better to elect a log to be their king than a serpent, who hissed venomously, and when he had hissed, devoured his subjects." Another answered, "How could this thing be? How could one who does not know letters preach in the chapter, or to the people on feast days? How could one who does not know the scriptures have the knowledge of binding and loosing? For the rule of souls is the art of arts, the highest form of knowledge. God forbid that a dumb idol be set up in the church of Saint Edmund, where many men are to be found who are learned and industrious."
Again, one said of another, "That brother is a literate man, eloquent and prudent, and strict in his observance of the rule. He loves the monastery greatly, and has suffered many ills for the good of the church. He is worthy to be made abbot." Another answered, "From good clerks deliver us, oh Lord! That it may please Thee to preserve us from the cheats of Norfolk; we beseech Thee to hear us! "
And again, one said of one," That brother is a good husbandman ; this is proved by the state of his office, and from the posts in which he has served well, and from the buildings and repairs which he has effected. He is well able to work and to defend the house, and he is something of a scholar, though too much learning has not made him mad. He is worthy of the abbacy." Another answered, "God forbid that a man who can neither read nor sing, nor celebrate the holy office, a man who is dishonest and unjust, and who evil intreats the poor men, should be made abbot."
Again, one said of another, "That brother is a kindly man, friendly and amiable, peaceful and calm, generous and liberal, a learned and eloquent man, and proper enough In face and gait. He is beloved of many within and without the walls, and such an one might become abbot to the great honour of the church, if God wills." Another answered, 1' It is no credit, but rather a disgrace, in a man to be too particular as to what he cats and drinks, to think it a virtue to sleep much, to know well how to spend and to know little how to gain, to snore while others keep vigil, to wish ever to have abundance, and not to trouble when debts daily increase, or when money spent brings no return; to be one who hates anxiety and toil, caring nothing while one day passes and another dawns ; to be one who loves and cherishes flatterers and liars ; to be one man in word and another in deed. From such a prelate the Lord defend us."
And again, one said of his friend, 'I That man is almost wiser than all of us, and that both in secular and in ecclesiastical matters. He is a man skilled in counsel, strict in the rule, learned and eloquent, and noble in stature; such a prelate would become our church." Another answered, "That would be true ' if he were a man of good and approved repute. But his character has been questioned, perhaps falsely, perhaps rightly. And though the man is wise, humble in the chapter, devoted to the singing of psalms, strict in his conduct in the cloister while he is a cloistered monk, this is only from force of habit. For if he have authority in any office, he is too scornful, holding monks of no account, and being on familiar terms with secular men, and if he be angry, he will scarce say a word willingly to any brother, even in answer to a question."
I heard in truth another brother abused by some because he had
an impediment in his speech, and it was said of him that he had
pastry or draff [pig food?] in his mouth when he should have spoken.
And I myself, as I was then young, understood as a child, spake
as a child; and I said that I would not consent that any one should
be made abbot unless he knew something of dialectic, and knew
how to distinguish the true from the false. One, moreover, who
was wise in his own eyes, said, " May Almighty God give us
a foolish and stupid pastor, that he may be driven to use our
help." And I heard, forsooth, that one man who was industrious,
learned, and pre-eminent for his high birth, was abused by some
of the older men because he was a novice. The novices said of
their elders that they were invalid old men, and little capable
of ruling an abbey. And so many men said many things, and every
man was fully persuaded in his own mind.
HOW SAMSON THE SUBSACRISTAN BORE HIMSELF WHILE OTHERS DISCUSSED THE VACANCY
THEN I saw Samson the subsacristan sitting by, for the time of
this little council was a season of bloodletting, when the cloistered
monks were wont to reveal the secrets of their hearts in turn,
and to discuss matters one with another. I saw him sitting by
and laughing to himself, while he kept silence and marked that
which each one said, so that at the end of twenty years lie was
able to remember some part of the various opinions which I have
set forth above.
HOW THE AUTHOR SPOKE HIS MIND TOO HASTILY
AND when I heard these things, I was wont to answer to those who so judged, and to say that if we had to wait to choose an abbot until we found one without spot or flaw, we should never find such an one, since there is none living without fault, and nothing altogether good. At one time I could not refrain my spirit, but put forward my own opinion only too readily, thinking that I was speaking to faithful ears. And I said that one was not worthy of the abbacy who had before loved me dearly and done much good to me. And I put forward another as worthy and named him, a man whom I loved but little. I spoke according to my conscience, thinking rather of the general wellbeing of the church than of my own promotion ; and I spoke the truth, as subsequent events proved. And behold, one of the sons of Belial revealed my saying to my benefactor and friend, wherefore to this very day I have never been able, by prayer or present, to regain his full favour. What I have said, I have said. And the word once uttered flies beyond recall.
One thing remains for me, that I take care henceforth ;
and if I should live long enough to see the abbey once more vacant,
I will see what, and to whom, and when I speak of so weighty a
matter, that I offend not God by lying or man by hasty talk. Then
it will be my care, if I live, that we elect one who is neither
a very good monk, nor a very wise clerk, nor too foolish, nor
too dissolute ; lest, if he know too much, he have also too much
confidence in himself and in his own opinion, and hold others
of small account; or if he be too foolish, he be abused by others.
I know that one has said, "You will walk most safely in the
middle," and that " Blessed are those who steer a middle
course." And perchance it is wiser counsel to be silent altogether,
so that I say in my heart, " He that is able to receive it,
let him receive it."
HOW THE ARCHBISHOP OF NORWAY DWELT IN THE ABBOT'S LODGINGS WHILE THE ABBACY WAS VACANT
WHILE the abbacy was vacant, Augustine, Archbishop of Norway,
dwelt with us in the abbot's lodgings, and by command of the king
received ten shillings every day from the revenues of the abbot.
He assisted us greatly to gain freedom of election, bearing witness
of the good, and publicly declaring in the Presence of the king
that which he had seen and heard.
OF THE MARTYRDOM OF SAINT ROBERT
AD 1181, 10th June
IN those days was the holy child Robert martyred, and was buried
in our church. And many signs and wonders were wrought among thepeople, as we have related in another place.
HOW THIRTEEN MEN WERE CHOSEN, BY COMMAND OF THE KING, TO ELECT AN ABBOT IN THE PRESENCE OF THE KING
AD 1182, February
Now when a year and three months had passed since the death of Abbot Hugh, the lord king commanded by his letters that our prior and twelve members of the monastery, by whose lips the opinion of the whole community might be expressed unanimously, should appear before him on a stated day to elect an abbot.
On the morrow after receiving the letters, we gathered in the chapter for the purpose of performing so important a task. And first the letters of the lord king were read in the assembly of the monastery; then we offered prayers, and bound the prior on the peril of his soul that he should conscientiously nominate to go with him twelve men, from %,hose life and manners he knew well that they would riot stray from the right path.
Then he, by inspiration of the Holy Spirit, gave ear to these prayers, and named six from one side of the choir and six from the other, and he gave us satisfaction without any dispute arising. From the righthand side of the choir he named Geoffrey de Fordham, Benedict, Master Dennis, Master Samson the subsacristan, Hugh the third prior, and Master Hermer, who was then a novice. From the left side he named William the sacristan, Andrew, Peter de Broc, Roger the cellarer, Master Ambrose, and Master Walter the physician.
But one said, "What shall be done if these thirteen cannot
agree on the choice of an abbot in the presence of the king?"
One answered, "That would be a perpetual shame to us and
our church." For that cause many wished that the election
might be made at home before the departure of the rest, so that
by this means there might be no dissension in the presence of
the king. But it seemed to us foolish and unbecoming to do this
without the royal assent, since as yet we had no certain knowledge
that we should obtain freedom of election from the lord king.
HOW SAMSON SUGGESTED THAT THE MONASTERY SHOULD APPOINT MEN TO MAKE A SECRET CHOICE OF AN ABBOT, AND HOW THIS WAS DONE
THEN Samson the subsacristan, speaking by the Spirit of God, said, " Let a middle course be taken, that so danger may be avoided on either side. Let four confessors be chosen from the monastery, and two of the older priors, men of repute, and let them look upon and take in their hands the most holy gospels, and choose among themselves three members of the monastery, men especially fitted according to the rule of the holy Benedict for this purpose. Then let them write down the names and seal that which is written, and let them give the writing thus secured to us on the eve of our departure for the court. And when we are come to the court, if it shall be determined that we have free election, then and not till then let the seal be broken, and so shall we know certainly the three who must be named in the presence of the king. Let it also be resolved that if the lord king will not grant us one of our own number, then the writing shall be brought back, with the seal unbroken, and delivered to the six sworn men, that so their secret may remain a secret for ever on the peril of their souls."
In this council we all agreed, and the four confessors were nominated, to wit, Eustace, Gilbert de Alueth, Hugh the third prior, and Anthony, with two other old men, Thurstan and Rualdus. And when this had been done, we went out chanting the "Verba mea," while the said six remained behind with the rule of St. Benedict in their hands, and completed the matter as had been ordained.
While these six men performed their work, we had various opinions as to the choice of different men, but all considered it to be certain that Samson would be one of them. For the), called to mind his labours and the danger of death, which he had endured in his journey to Rome for the good of our church, and how he had been ill treated, and bound, and put in prison by Abbot Hugh, because he spoke to the common advantage. And they considered he was a man who could not be brought to flatter, though he might be driven to keep silence.
So, after some delay, the whole monastery was summoned to return
to the chapter. And the old men said that they had done as had
been commanded them.
HOW, ON THE ADVICE OF SAMSON, IT WAS DECIDED WHAT SHOULD BE DONE IF THE KING WOULD NOT GRANT FREEDOM OF ELECTION
THEN the prior asked what and if the lord king would not accept any one of the three whose names were written down. And it was answered that, since whomsoever the king wished to be received, must be received, there was but one course open to our church. It was added also that if those thirteen brothers should see in any writing aught that should be altered, they should make the alteration, according to God, unanimously and after consultation.
Samson the subsacristan, sitting at the feet of the prior, said,
"It would be for the good of the church were all to swear
on the word of truth that on whomsoever the lot of election shall
fall, that man shall treat the monastery reasonably, and not change
the chief officials without the assent of the house, nor burden
the sacristan, nor make any one a monk without the consent of
the monastery." And we agreed on this matter, all raising
their right hands in token of their approval. And it was provided
that if the lord king willed that some stranger should be made
abbot, the thirteen should not accept this man save with the advice
of the brothers who remained at home.
HOW THE CHOSEN THIRTEEN, JOURNEYED TO THE KING
ON the morrow, therefore, these thirteen set out for the court. Last of all was Samson, who had charge of the expenses of the journey as being subsacristan. And he bore a lettercase round his neck, in which were contained the letters of the monastery, as if he were only servant of them all. So, with no attendant, and with his frock borne in his arms, he went out of the court, and followed far behind his comrades.
On their journey to the court, the brothers gathered together,
and Samson said that it would be well if all were to swear that
whoever might be made abbot, should restore the churches on the
demesne lands of the monastery to the exercise of hospitality.
To this all agreed save the prior, and he said, "We have
sworn enough; you will so limit the power of the abbot, that I
would not care to be abbot at all." And for this reason,
they did not swear; and it was well that they did not do, for
had this oath been taken it would not have been observed.
OF THE DREAMS WHICH THE BROTHERS DREAMED CONCERNING THE ELECTION OF A NEW ABBOT
THEN on the day on which the thirteen departed, while we were sitting in the cloister, William de Hastings, one of our brothers, said, "I know that we shall have one of our own number as abbot." And when he was asked how he knew this, he answered that he had beheld in dreams a prophet, clothed in white, standing before the gates of the monastery. Him he had asked in the name of the Lord whether we should have one of ourselves as abbot. And the prophet answered, " Ye shall have one of your own number, but he shall raven as a wolf among you." And this dream was partly fulfilled, since he that became abbot strove rather to be feared than loved, as many were wont to say.
Another brother also, Edmund by name, was sitting by, and declared that Samson would be abbot, relating a dream which he had seen on the previous night. For he said that he had seen in dreams Roger the cellarer and Hugh the third prior standing before the altar, and Samson in their midst, head and shoulders taller than they, and wearing a long and flowing cloak, fastened at his shoulders, and he was standing as it were like a champion about to engage in a duel. Then the holy Edmund arose from his shrine as it seemed to the brother in his dream and showed his feet and legs bare, as though sickness was upon him. Then when one rose and would have covered the feet of the saint, the saint said, "Come not near. Lo! he shall cover my feet," and pointed his finger towards Samson. This is the interpretation of the dream: In that a champion was seen, this signified that he who was to become abbot would be constant in labour, alike when disputing with the archbishop of Canterbury about the pleas of the crown, and when striving with the knights of St. Edmund for the full payment of scutages, or with the burghers about encroachments on the market, or with the sokemen for the suits of hundreds; and that he was as it were a champion anxious to overcome his enemies by fighting, that so far as in him lay he might recover the rights and liberties of his church. Moreover, he covered the feet of the holy martyr, when he completed fully the towers of the church, which had been begun a hundred years before.
Such dreams did our brothers dream, and at once told them first
of all in the cloister and then in the court. And so it came to
pass that before vespers the people openly said that this and
this and this man was elected, and that one of them would be abbot.
HOW THE THIRTEEN CAME TO THE KING AND SHOWED TO HIM THE NAMES OF THOSE WHOM THE CONFESSORS HAD SELECTED
AD 1182 21st February
So the prior and the twelve with him after many labours stood at last in the presence of the king at Waltham, a manor of the bishop of. Winchester, on the second Sunday in Lent. And the lord king received them graciously, and declared that he wished to act according to the will of God and for the honour of our church. Then he gave command to the brothers through his proctors, Richard bishop of Winchester and Geoffrey the chancellor, who was afterwards archbishop of York, that they should nominate three members of our monastery.
Then the prior and the brothers withdrew themselves, as it were to discuss this matter, and drew forth the seal and broke it, and found these names written down in this order, Samson the subsacristan, Roger the cellarer, and Hugh the third prior. And at this the brothers who were of greater dignity blushed. Moreover all marvelled that the same Hugh should be both an elector and one of the elected. But because they could not alter the thing they unanimously changed the order of the names, naming Hugh, because he was third prior, first, and Roger the cellarer next, and Samson third. Thus, as far as words went, they made the last first, and the first last.
But the king, having first asked whether they were born in his
land, and in whose lordship, said that he did not know them, and
commanded that they should name three other members of the monastery
HOW THE THIRTEEN, BY COMMAND OF THE KING, CHOSE THREE OTHER NAMES FROM THE MONASTERY, AND THREE STRANGERS
AND when this had been granted, William the sacristan said , " Our prior ought to be nominated, for he is our head," and this was readily agreed. Then the prior said, " William the sacristan is a good man." The same was said of Dennis, and was agreed. And when these were named in the presence of the king without any delay, the king marvelled, saying, "These men act quickly. God is with them."
And after that the king commanded that for the honour of the kingdom,
they should nominate three persons from other houses. When they
heard this the brothers feared, for they suspected a fraud. Yet
did they agree to nominate three, but under conditions, namely,
that they would receive no one save with the assent of the members
of the monastery who were at home. And they named three, master
Nicholas de Waringford, who was afterwards for awhile abbot of
Malmesbury, and Bertrand, prior of St. Faith's, who was afterwards
abbot of Chertsey, and lord H. de St. Neots, a monk of Bec, a
most pious man, and in both secular and spiritual matters very
HOW THE LIST OF NAMES WAS REDUCED FROM NINE TO TWO
WHEN this had been done, the king sent them thanks and commanded that three of the nine should be removed, and the three strangers were at once removed, that is, the prior of St. Faith's, who was afterwards abbot of Chertsey, and Nicholas, the monk of St. Alban's, who was afterwards abbot of Malmesbury, and the prior of St. Neot's.
William the sacristan of his accord withdrew, two of the five
were removed by the order of the king, and finally one of the
last three, so that there remained then two, namely, the prior
HOW SAMSON WAS ELECTED ABBOT
THEN at last the abovementioned proctors of the lord king were summoned to the council of the brothers. And Dennis, speaking as one for all, began to commend the persons of the prior and Samson. He said that they were both learned men, both good, both praiseworthy in their lives and of unblemished reputation. But ever at the climax of his speech he put forward Samson, multiplying words in his praise, saying that he was a man strict in his conduct, stern in correcting faults, apt for labour, prudent in temporal matters, and proved in divers offices.
Then the bishop of Winchester answered, "We know well what you would say, from your words we gather that your prior has appeared to you to be somewhat slack, ;and that you wish to have him who is called Samson." Dennis answered, "Both of them are good men, but we desire to have the better, if God wills." Thereupon the bishop said, "Of two good things, the greater good should be selected. Say openly, do you desire to have Samson?" And many, and they a majority, answered plainly, ,We wish to have Samson," and none spoke against him. Some, however, were silent from caution, wishing to offend neither candidate.
Then Samson was nominated in the presence of the lord king, and when the king had consulted with his men for a while, all were summoned. And the king said, "You have presented to me Samson. I know him not. If you had presented your prior to me, I would have accepted him, for I have seen and know him. But I will only do what you will. Take heed to yourselves ; by the true eyes of God, if you do ill, I will exact a recompense at your hands."
Then he asked the prior if he assented to the choice and wished it, and the prior answered that he did will it, and that Samson was worthy of much greater honour. Therefore he was elected, and fell at the king's feet and embraced them. Then he arose quickly and hastened to the altar, with his head erect and without changing his expression, chanting the "Miserere mei, Deus" with the brothers.
And when the king saw this, he said to those that stood by, "
By the eyes of God, this elect thinks that he is worthy to rule
HOW THE NEWS OF THE ELEC I'ION CAME TO THE MONASTERY AND HOW SAMSON WAS BLESSED
AD 1182. 28th February
THE news of this election came to the monastery, and all the cloistered monks or almost all of them were rejoiced, and also some of the officials, but few. "It is well," said many, " because it is well." Others said that this was not so, "Of a truth, we have all been bewitched."
Before he returned to us, the elect received his benediction from the lord of Winchester, who in the same hour in the which he placed the mitre on the abbot's head and the ring on his finger, said, "This man is worthy of the abbacy of St. Edmund, and for a long while have I known it."
Therefore the abbot retained with him three monks, and allowed
the rest to return home. And he announced that he would himself
come on Palm Sunday, and charged certain men with the care of
providing those things which might be necessary for his feast.
HOW SAMSON, HAVING BEEN MADE ABBOT, RETURNED AND WAS RECEIVED AT THE MONASTERY
ON his homeward way a multitude of new relations met him, desiring to serve him. But he answered all of them that he was content with the servants of the prior, and that he was unable to maintain others until he had consulted the monastery on the matter. But one knight he did retain, a man who was eloquent and skilled in the law. This he did not only from consideration of their relationship, but from arguments of utility also, as he was indeed used to secular affairs. He received him as a novice and as his assessor in temporal disputes. For he was a new abbot and unskilful in such matters, as he himself protested, since until he received the abbacy he had never held any office in which surety and pledge was given.
On Palm Sunday he was received with due honour and with ceremony
also by his monastery.
AD 1182 21st March
Now the lord abbot was thus received. The night before he had lain at Kentford, and at the proper moment we went to meet him in solemn procession, after leaving the chapter, as far as the gate of the graveyard, while bells were rung in the choir and outside it. But he was surrounded by a multitude of men, and when he saw the monastery, dismounted from his horse without the threshold of the gate, and causing his sandals to be removed, was received within the door barefooted, the prior and the sacristan supporting him on either side. And we chanted the responses "Benedictus Dominus" from the service for Trinity Sunday, and afterwards the "Martiri adhuc " from that for St. Edmund, and conducted the abbot as far as the high altar.
And when this had been done, the organs and bells were silenced, and the prior said the prayer "Omnipotens sempiterne Deus, miserere huic," over the prostrate abbot. Then the abbot made oblation and kissed the shrine, and returned to the choir. There Samson the precentor took him by the hand and led him to the abbot's chair on the western side of the choir, and while he stood there the precentor at once began "Te Deum laudamus," and while it was being chanted, the abbot was embraced by the prior and by the whole monastery.
And so, these ceremonies being completed, the abbot entered the chapter, the whole monastery and many others following. He said many times "Benedicite," and then he first returned thanks to the monastery that they had chosen him, the least of them all, as he said, not for his own merits but only by the will of God, to be their lord and pastor. And asking in a few words that they would pray for him, he addressed the clerks and knights, and asked them to advise him for the good of the monastery.
Then Wimer, the sheriff, answered for them all, and said, " We also are ready to be with you in counsel and in helping you in every way, as with a dear lord whom the Lord has called for His honour, and for the honour of the holy martyr Edmund."
Afterwards the charters of the king concerning the donation of
the abbacy were brought forth, and were read in the hearing of
all. The abbot himself also prayed that God would guide him according
to His grace, and all answered " Amen." Then he went
into his own chamber, and celebrated his day of festival with
more than a thousand guests and with great joy.
HOW ABBOT SAMSON BEGAN TO RULE THE MONASTERY
IN those days I was prior's chaplain, and within four months was made chaplain to the abbot. And I noted many things and committed them to memory. So, on the morrow of his feast, the abbot assembled the prior and some few others together, as if to seek advice from others, but he himself knew what he would do.
He said that a new seal must be made and adorned with a mitred effigy of himself, though his predecessors had not had such a seal. For a time, however, he used the seal of our prior, writing at the end of all letters that he did so for the time being because he had no seal of his own. And afterwards he ordered his household, and transferred various officials to other offices, saying that he proposed to maintain twenty-six horses in his court, and many times he declared that " a child must first crawl, and afterwards he may stand upright and walk." And he laid this especial command upon his servants, that they should take care that he might not be laid open to the charge of not providing enough food and drink, but that they should assiduously provide for the maintenance of the hospitality of the house.
In these matters, and in all the things which he did and determined,
he trusted fully in the help of God and his own good sense, holding
it to be shameful to rely upon the counsel of another, and thinking
he was sufficient unto himself. The monks marvelled arid the knights
were angered ; they blamed his pride, and often defamed him at
the court of the king, saying that he would not act in accordance
with the advice of his freemen. He himself put away from his privy
council all the great men of the abbey, both lay and literate,
men without whose advice and assistance it seemed impossible that
the abbey could be ruled. For this reason Ranulf de Glanvill,
Justiciar of England, was at first offended with him, and was
less well-disposed towards him than was expedient, until he knew
well from definite proofs that the abbot acted providently and
prudently, both in domestic and in external affairs.
HOW THE ABBOT MET THE DEMAND OF THOMAS DE HASTINGS THAT HIS NEPHEW SHOULD BE STEWARD
AD 1182 1st April
A GENERAL summons was sent out, and on the fourth day of Easter all the barons, and knights, and freemen cameto do homage. And, lo! Thomasde Hastings came also with a great multitude of knights, and brought with him Henry his nephew, who was not yet a knight, and for whom he demanded the office of steward with the customary dues thereof, as his charter provided. And to this demand the abbot at once answered, "I neither deny, nor wish to deny, his right to Henry. If he were able to serve me in his own person, I would grant him the means of supporting ten men and eight horses in my court. And if you will present a steward to me, who knows how to fulfil the office of steward and is able to do so, I will receive him on the same terms as my predecessor had his steward on the day whercon he was alive and dead, that is, I will allow him four horses with the things needful. for them. But is you will not agree to this, I will make complaint before the king and before the chief justiciar."
When the abbot had so spoken, the matter was postponed. But afterwards
a certain simple and foolish steward, by name Gilbert, was presented
to him, and before he received him, the abbot said to his intimates,
"If the ignorance of the steward leads to the illrendering
of the justice of the king, then it will be he who will be responsible
to the king and not I, for he gained the stewardship by hereditary
right. For the time, therefore, I would rather accept him than
another, even more incompetent, to my loss. By God's help, I will
be my own steward."
HOW THE ABBOT DEALT WITH THE LANDS OF HIS HOUSE
WHEN homage had been received,the abbot demanded an aid from the knights, and they promised twenty shillings from each fee of a knight. But they at once took counsel, and reduced the aid by twelve pounds from twelve knights, alleging that these twelve ought to assist the other forty to keep ward, and to make scutages, and also in assisting the abbey. When the abbot heard this, he was wroth, and said to his friends that should his life be spared, he would repay them like for like, and injury for injury.
After this, the abbot caused inquest to be made in every manor belonging to the abbacy as to the annual revenues of the free men, and the names of the villeins, and their holdings, and the services due from each, and caused all these details to be written down. Then he restored the old halls and ruined houses, through which kites and crows flew; he built new chapels, and rooms and seats in many places where there had never been buildings, save perhaps barns.
He also made many parks, which he filled with beasts, and had a huntsman and dogs. And whenever any important guest arrived, he used to sit with his monks in some retired grove, and watch the coursing for a while; but I never saw him interested in hunting.
He made many clearings and brought land into cultivation, in everything regarding the advantage of the abbacy. But would that he had watched with equal care over the grants of the manors of the monastery. For he received our manors of Bradfield and Rougham for a while into his own hand, making good the loss of rent by the expenditure of forty pounds, which he afterwards handed over to us when he heard that the monastery murmured because he held our manors in his own hands.
For the management of the same manors and for the management of all other affairs, he appointed monks and laymen who were wiser than those who had previously held the posts, and who made careful provision for us and our lands.
Then he received eight hundreds into his own hands, and when Robert de Cokefield died, he took the hundred of Cosford. All these he handed over to the care of the servants of his own table. Matters of greater moment were kept for his own decision, and those which were of less import were decided by his agents ; all things he turned to his advantage.
By his command, a general account was drawn up for every hundred
of the leets and suits, of the hidages and customary supplies
of fodder, of the hens which ought to be paid to him, and of all
the other customary dues, revenues, and expenses, which the tenants
had always concealed to a great extent. All these things he reduced
to writing, so that within four years of his election, no one
could deceive him as to the resources of the abbey even to a penny's
value, whereas he had received nothing in writing from his predecessors
concerning the management of the abbey, except a little schedule
containing the names of the knights of St. Edmund and the names
of the manors, and the rent which attached to each farm. Now he
called this book of his his Calendar, in the which also were written
down all the debts which he had paid. And he consulted this book
almost daily, as if in it he saw the image of his probity as in
OF THAT WHICH WAS DONE AT THE ABBOT'S FIRST CHAPTER
ON the first day on the which he held a chapter, he confirmed to us under his new seal the sixty shillings for Southrey, which his predecessors had in the first instance unjustly received from Edmund, called the golden monk, that the same might hold the said township to farm all the days of his life.
And he proposed an edict that no one should pledge the ornaments of the church henceforth without the assent of the monastery, as had been done formerly. He proposed also that no charter should be scaled with the seal of the monastery save in the chapter and in the presence of the whole community.
Then he made Hugh subsacristan, ordaining that William the
sacristan should do nothing in the office of sacristan, either
as to receipts or as to expenses, save by his assent. Afterwards,
but on the same day, he removed the former custodians of the oblations
to other offices. And last of all he deposed William himself,
whereupon certain who loved William said, "See the abbot!
See the wolf of whom one dreamed! See how he ravens! "
HOW CERTAIN MEN WISHED TO CONSPIRE AGAINST THE ABBOT
THEN some wished to conspire against the abbot. And when this was revealed to the abbot, as he wished neither to keep silence altogether nor to disturb the monastery, he entered the chapter on the morrow. And there he drew forth a small bag full of cancelled bonds, to which the seals were still attached, some of which were those of his predecessor, some of the prior, some of the sacristan, some of the chamberlain, and some of other officials. Of these the total was three thousand two score and twelve pounds, and one pure mark, over and above the increase due to usury, the amount of which none could know; and for all these he had made some arrangement within a year of his election, and within twelve years he had paid them in full.
And he said, " Observe the wisdom of our sacristan, William! See the number of bonds marked with his seal, in which he has pledged silken caps, dalmatics, silver vases, and books of the gospels bound in gold, without the assent of the monastery. And all these things I have settled and restored to you." And he added many other words, showing wherefore he had deposed William. But on the principal cause he kept silence, not wishing to make him a public example.
And all things became peaceful once more when he had replaced
William with the precentor Samson, who was a man pleasing to all
of us, and well known to be without fault. But the abbot ordered
that the houses of the sacristan in the graveyard should be utterly
destroyed, as if they were unworthy to stand above ground. And
for this the cause was the frequent drinking bouts and certain
things which cannot be mentioned, which he had seen when he was
subsacristan with sorrow and pain. So he caused all the
buildings to be levelled with the ground, and within a year, where
there had stood a noble building we saw beans growing, and where
casks of wine had lain we saw nettles in abundance.
HOW THE ABBOT JOURNEYED THROUGH THE LANDS OF SAINT EDMUND, AND HOW HE ESCAPED DEATH AT WARKTON
AFTER the end of Easter the abbot went through all his manors and ours, and through those which we had confirmed in fee to tenants. And from all and sundry he demanded an aid and recognition, according to the custom of the realm. Daily he grew skilled in earthly learning, and turned his attention to the acquisition of knowledge of external affairs and of providing for them.
But when he was come to Warkton and was at night sleeping, a voice
came to him saying, " Samson, arise up quickly," and
again, " Rise, thou tarriest too long." So he arose
half dazed, and looking round about him saw in a necessary place
a light, a candle which Reiner the monk had left there through
carelessness, and which was about to fall on the straw. And when
the abbot had put it out, he went through the house and fourid
the doorfor there was but one so fastened that it
could only be opened with a key, and the windows barred. Wherefore,
had the fire grown, both he and all they who were sleeping in
that building would have perished. For there was no way by which
they might have gone out or escaped.
HOW THE CREDITORS OF THE ABBEY DEMANDED PAYMENT, AND HOW THE ABBOT TOOK HIS MANORS INTO HIS OWN HAND
Now at that time, wheresoever the abbot went, there hastened to him both Jews and Christians demanding payment of the debts due to them. And they so disturbed the abbot, and caused him such anxiety, that he lost his sleep, and grew pale and thin. Then he said, "There will be no rest for my soul until I shall see an end of my indebtedness."
When Michaelmas came, he took all his manors into his hand, with
very few necessary implements and but little stock. He forgave
Walter dc Hatfield nineteen pounds of arrears of rent, in return
for receiving from him the four manors in the which he had been
confirmed as tenant by abbot Hugh, namely, Hargrave, Saxham, Chevington
HOW THE ABBOT DID NOT THEN TAKE HARLOW INTO HIS OWN HAND
BUT the abbot delayed to receive Harlow, and for this cause. It
chanced that once when we were returning from London through the
forest, that in the hearing of the lord abbot I asked an old woman
who passed us whose this wood was, and to what township it belonged,
and who was its lord or who was warden over it. And she answered
that it was a wood of the abbot of St. Edmund, of the township
of Harlow, and that one called Arnald was warden of it. And when
I asked concerning him as to how he bore himself towards the men
of the township, she answered that he had been a fiend incarnate,
an enemy of God, and one who evilintreated the poor. But
now, she said, he fears the new abbot of St. Edmund, whom he believes
to be wise and provident, and therefore treats his men well. And
when he heard this the abbot was rejoiced, and delayed for a season
to take that manor into his own hand.
HOW THE ABBOT MANAGED THE LANDS WHICH HE FARMED HIMSELF
THEN there came the unexpected news of the death of the wife of Herlewin of Rungton. She held a charter by which she was to have that township for her life, and the abbot said, "Yesterday I would have given sixty marks to free that manor, now the Lord has freed it." Then when he had come and had received the township into his hand without any delay, and on the morrow had gone to Tillency which was a part of that manor, there came to him a certain knight offering thirty marks that he might hold that carucate of land with what belonged to it on the same terms as before, namely, four pounds a year. This the abbot refused, and he took thence that year five and twenty pounds, and in the next year twenty pounds.
This and other similar events led him to keep all things in his hand ; as it is written in another place, "Caesar was everything." Nor was he slack, but caused first of all barns and cattlesheds to be built ; he was anxious to cultivate the plough lands above all things; he was careful in maintaining the woods, and in giving and reducing these he made great profit for himself.
The one manor of Thorp alone he confirmed under his charter to
a certain Englishman, a man adscript to the soil, in whose fidelity
he had the fullest confidence, because he was a good farmer and
because he knew no French.
HOW ABBOT SAMSON WAS MADE A JUSTICE, AND HOW HE BORE HIMSELF IN THIS OFFICE
AD 1182 November
SEVEN months had not yet passed since his election, and, behold! letters of the lord pope were sent to him appointing him a judge for hearing causes. In the performance of this work he was rude and inexperienced, though he was skilled in the liberal arts and in the holy scriptures, as being a literate man, brought up in the schools and a ruler of scholars, and renowned and well proved in his own work. He therefore associated with himself two clerks who were learned in the the law and joined them with him, using their advice in church matters, while he spent his leisure in studying the decrees and decretal letters. And the result was that in a little while he was regarded as a discreet judge, by reason of the books which he had read and the causes which he had tried, and as one who proceeded in the cases which he tried according to the form of law. And for this cause one said, " Cursed be the court of this abbot, where neither gold nor silver profit me to confound my enemy! "
In course of time, he became somewhat skilled in temporal matters, being guided by his commonsense, for his mind was so subtle that all men wondered, and Osbert FitzHerbert, the undersheriff, used to say, "This abbot is given to disputation ; if he goes on as he has begun, he will blind us all, however many we be." But the abbot, being approved in these matters, was made a justice in eyre, though he kept himself from error and wandering. But "envy seeks out the highest." His men complained to him in the court of St. Edmund since he would not give judgment hastily or believe every spirit, but proceeded in a judicial manner, knowing that the merits of the cases of suitors are made clear by discussion. It was said that he would not do justice to any complainant, unless money were given or promised ; and because his aspect was acute and penetrating, and his face, like Cato's, rarely smiling, it was said that his mind lent rather to severity than to mercy. Moreover, when he took fines for any crime, it was said that judgment rejoiced against mercy, for in the opinion of many, when it came to a matter of taking money, he rarely remitted that which he might lawfully take.
So his wisdom increased, as well as his care in managing affairs,
and in improving his state, and in spending honourably.
HOW SOME MEN MADE COMPLAINT AGAINST THE ABBOT
BUT hereupon many of his adversaries raised objections. For they said that he received what he would from the sacristry, and spared his own money, and allowed his corn to lie in the barns until such time as the price should be high. They said that he managed his manors in a way diferent from that of his predecessors ; that he burdened his cellarer with guests who should rather have been received by the abbot, so that the abbot might win repute as a wise man and one who was clever and provident at the end of the year, but the monastery and its officials be thought ignorant and wasteful.
To these charges I used to answer that if he took anything from the sacristry, he employed it for the use of the church ; and that no envious person could deny this. And to speak the truth, much more good and much greater good was done with the offerings of the sacristry during the fifteen years after his election than in the forty years preceding.
To the others who objected that the abbot went often to his manors,
I was wont to answer and to excuse him by saying that the abbot
was happier and in better spirits anywhere than at home. This
also was the truth, whether on account of the constant complaints
which came to him, or on account of those who told him rumours
concerning himself. Accordingly, it often happened that his appearance
was stern, and that so he lost much favour and grace with the
guests, though he satisfied them with food and drink.
HOW THE AUTHOR TALKED WITH THE ABBOT CONCERNING THIS SADNESS OF HIS MANNER
BUT I noticed this, and taking a favourable occasion, as I was with him alone, said, "There are two things in you which make me marvel greatly." And when he asked what they were, I said, "One is, that you, in the circumstances in which you are placed, favour the opinion of those of Mclun who say that from a false premiss nothing can follow, and other foolish things." And when he answered what he would to this, I added, "The other thing at which 1 marvel is that you do not show a smiling face at home as you do elsewhere, nor remain among the brothers who cherish you, and love you, and have chosen you to be their lord, but are rarely with them, nor do you then rejoice with them, so they say."
When he heard this, his expression changed, and he answered, with bowed head, "You are a fool, and speak as a fool. You should know the saying of Solomon, Hast thou many daughters; show not thyself cheerful toward them." Then I was silent, and from that time placed a guard on my lips.
Yet on another occasion I said, "Lord, I heard you this night keeping watch after matins and breathing heavily contrary to your wont." And he answered, "It is not strange. You share my good things, food, and drink, and riding, and the like. But you think little of the toil of providing for the house and household, of the many and arduous labours which are a pastor's care. These make me anxious, and cause me to groan and to be troubled in spirit." Thereupon I raised my hands to heaven and answered, "From so great anxiety, almighty and merciful Lord, deliver me!",
I heard the abbot say that if he were in that condition in which
he had been before he became a monk, and had five or six marks
income wherewith he might support himself in the schools, he would
never become either monk or abbot. And on another occasion, he
said with an oath that had he known beforehand what care there
was in ruling an abbey, and how great that care was, he would
far rather have been almoner or librarian, than abbot and lord.
And he declared that he had ever longed for the post of librarian
above all others. Yet who would believe such things? Not I ; no,
not I ; but that as I lived with him day and night for six years,
I know fully the merit of his life and the wisdom of his mind.
CONCERNING A DREAM WHICH THE ABBOT HAD WHEN A BOY
ONCE he told me how when he was a boy of nine years, he dreamed that he stood before the doors of the cemetery of St. Edmund, and that the devil wished to seize him with his outstretched arms. But the blessed Edmund, who stood near, received him into his arms; and when he had cried out in his sleep, "St. Edmund, help me! " though he had never heard the saint named before, he awoke. Then his mother was amazed at his loud cry and at his words. And when she had heard the dream, she took him to St. Edmund's, that he might pray there. So coming to the gate of the cemetery, he said, " Mother mine! see this place! See, the very door which I beheld in my dreams, when the devil would have taken me." And he knew the place, he said, as if he had already seen it with his carnal eye.
The abbot himself explained the dream, saying that the devil in
it meant the joys of this world which would have enticed him ;
but that the blessed Edmund embraced him, since he would have
him become a monk of his church.
HOW THE ABBOT RESTRAINED HIS TEMPER THAT HE MIGHT NOT OFFEND
ONCE when it was told him that certain of those in the monastery murmured on account of some act of his, he said to me, as I was near him, " God, God, it is most expedient that I should be mindful of that dream which was dreamed concerning me before I became abbot, to the effect that I should raven as a wolf. Of a truth, I fear this above all earthly things, that my house may do something which may make it lawful for me to raven. But so it is, that when they say or do aught against my will, I call to mind that dream, and though I raven in spirit, groaning and gnashing my teeth in secret, I put force on myself that I may raven neither in word nor in deed. And hidden grief chokes me, and my heart burns within me."
But though he was naturally choleric and easily moved to wrath,
yet from respect for his office he generally restrained his anger,
albeit with much grief of mind. Of this also he often spoke, saying,"
I have seen this and that, I have heard this and that, and yet
have I borne it patiently."
HOW THE ABBOT FORBADE SECRET ACCUSATIONS, AND HOW HE ORDERED THE RESTORATION OF ALL PRIVATE SEALS
ONCE as he sat in the chapter, the abbot spoke certain words whereby he seemed to court the favour of the monastery with success. " I will not," he said, "that any come to me to accuse other, unless he will declare the same openly. But if any desire to act otherwise, I will publicly announce the name of the accuser. And I will also that every monk shall have free access to me, that he may talk with me of his needs when he will." Now this he said because the chief men of our house in the days of abbot Hugh, wishing nothing to be done in the monastery save through them, decreed that no cloistered monk should speak with the abbot, unless he had first shown to the abbot's chaplain that which he desired to say to the abbot and the reason.
One day he commanad in the Chapter that all who had seals of their
own should restore them to him, and so it was done ; and thirty
and three seals were found. He himself clearly declared the reason
for this command, and forbade any official to contract any debt
above the sum of twenty shillings without the consent of the prior
and monastery, as had been wont to be done in the past. Then he
restored the prior and sacristan their seals and retained the
CONCERNING FURTHER REGULATIONS WHICH THE ABBOT MADE
AT another time he ordered that all the keys of the chests, cupboards, and hampers should be given up to him, and forbade anyone henceforth to have any chest or anything locked up, save by permission, or to possess anything of any description except such things as the rule allowed. However, he gave general permission to all of us to have money to the value of two shillings, if perchance this should be given to us in charity. The leave was still conditional on the money being expended for the benefit of poor relations or in pious uses.
On another occasion the abbot said that he wished to maintain
our ancient custom in the matter of the reception of guests, so
that when the abbot was at home he should receive all guests of
whatever condition, except religious men, and except priests of
secular habit, and except their men, who should come to the doors
of the court by instruction of their masters. If, however, the
abbot should not be at home, all guests of whatever condition
should be received by, the cellarer, up to the number of thirteen
horses. But if a layman or clerk should come with more than thirteen
horses, they should be received by the servants of the abbot,
either within or without the court, at the expense of the abbot.
All religious men, even bishops, if by chance they were monks,
were to be the care of the cellarer and entertained at the expense
of the monastery, unless the abbot were desirous of showing them
honour and of receiving them in his hall at his own expense.
CONCERNING THE APPEARANCE AND PRIVATE CHARACTER OF THE ABBOT
ABBOT SAMSON was below the average height, almost bald; his face was neither round nor oblong ; his nose was prominent and his lips thick; his eyes were clear and his glance penetrating; his hearing was excellent; his eyebrows arched, and frequently shaved; and a little cold soon made him hoarse. On the day of his election lie was fortyseven, and had been a monk for seventeen years. In his ruddy beard there were a few grey hairs, and still fewer in his black and curling hair. But in the course of the first fourteen years after his election all his hair becane white as snow.
He was an exceedingly temperate man ; he possessed great energy and a strong constitution, and was fond both of riding and walking, until old age prevailed upon him and moderated his ardour in these respects. When he heard the news of the capture of the cross and the fill of Jerusalem, he began to wear under garments made of horse hair, and a horsehair shirt, and gave up the use of flesh and meat. None the less, he willed that flesh should be placed before him as he sat at table, that the alms might be increased. He ate sweet milk, honey, and similar sweet things, far more readily than any other food.
He hated liars, drunkards, and talkative persons; for virtue ever loves itself and spurns that which is contrary to it. He blamed those who grumbled about their meat and drink, and especially monks who so grumbled, and personally kept to the same manners which lie had observed when he was a cloistered monk. Moreover, he had this virtue in himself that lie never desired to change the dish which was placed before him. When I was a novice, I wished to prove whether this was really true, and as I happened to serve in the refectory, I thought to place before him food which would have offended any other man, in a very dirty and broken dish. But when he saw this, he was as it were blind to it. Then, as there was some delay, I repented of what I had done, and straightway seized the dish, changed the food and dish for better, and carried it to him. He, however, was angry at the change, and disturbed.
He was an eloquent man, speaking both French and Latin, but rather careful of the good sense of that which he had to say than of the style of his words. He could read books written in English very well, and was wont to preach to the people in English, but in the dialect of Norfolk where he was born and bred. It was for this reason that he ordered a pulpit to be placed in the church, for the sake of those who heard him and for purposes of ornament.
The abbot further appeared to prefer the active to the contemplative
life, and praised good officials more than good monks. He rarely
commended anyone solely on account of his knowledge of letters,
unless the man happened to have knowledge of secular affairs,
and if he chanced to hear of any prelate who had given up his
pastoral work and become a hermit, he did not praise him for this.
He would not praise men who were too kindly, saying, ' He who
strives to please all men, deserves to please none."
HOW ABBOT SAMSON DEALT WITH FLATTERERS
Now in the first year of his abbacy he seemed to hate all flatterers, and especially those who were monks. But in course of time he appeared to listen to them with some willingness, and to treat them more graciously. Once a certain one of our brothers, who was skilled in this art, had bent his knees before him, and under pretence of giving him counsel, had poured the oil of flattery into his cars, while I stood at a distance and smiled. Then when the brother had gone, the abbot called me and asked me why I had been smiling, and I answered that the world was full of flatterers.
And the abbot said, "My son, I have been flattered for a
long while, and therefore I cannot attend to flattery. There must
be much pretence and much concealment that the peace of the monastery
may be preserved. 1 will hear them speak, but they will not deceive
me, if I can prevent it, as they deceived my predecessor, who
gave such unconsidered attention to them that for a long while
before his death he had nothing wherewith to feed himself or his
household, save that which he borrowed from creditors. And on
the day of his burial there was nothing which could be distributed
among the poor, save fifty shillings which were received from
Richard the tenant of Palgrave, because on the same day he entered
on the tenancy of Palgrave ; and this money the same Richard afterwards
paid again to the officials of the king, who exacted the full
rent for the royal use." And with these words I was reassured.
HOW ABBOT SAMSON MANAGED HIS HOUSEHOLD
HE laboured to secure a well regulated house, and a household large, but not larger than was right, and he took care that the weekly allowance which in the time of his predecessor had not been enough for five days, should last him for eight days, or nine, or ten, if he were on his manors and there were no great coming of guests. Every week, moreover, he audited the expenses of his house, not through an agent, but in person, a thing which his predecessor had never been accustomed to do.
For his first seven years he had four dishes in his house, afterwards
only three, if one excludes presents, and game from his parks
and fish from his ponds. And if he happened to keep anyone for
a while in his house at the request of some great man or of one
of his friends, or messengers, or minstrels, or any such person,
he used to take any opportunity of crossing the sea or going a
long journey, and so prudently freed himself from so great expense.
HOW THE ABBOT TREATED THOSE MONKS WITH WHOM HE HAD BEEN INTIMATE BEFORE HE BECAME ABBOT
THOSE monks whom the abbot, before he acquired the abbacy, had treated as his most cherished and intimate friends, he seldom raised to official positions on the score of his former intimacy with them, unless they were fit persons. Therefore some of our number, who had favoured his election as abbot, said that lie showed them less favour than was their due, who had loved him before he was abbot, and that those rather were cherished by him who had slandered him both openly and secretly, and in the hearing of many had publicly declared him to be a hottempered man, one who was unsociable, conceited, and a Norfolk cheat. But, just as after he received the abbacy he made no injudicious exhibition of affection or of a desire to honour his former friends, so also he did not show towards the others any of that rancour or hatred which they deserved, returning good for evil on many occasions, and doing good to those who persecuted him.
He had also a characteristic which I have never seen in any other
man, namely, that he had a strong affection for many to whom he
never or seldom showed a loving face, which the common saying
declares to be usual, when it says, "Where love is, there
the glance follows." And there was another noteworthy thing,
that he wittingly suffered loss from his servants in temporal
matters, and allowed that he suffered it ; but, as 1 believe,
the reason for this was that he waited for a fit season when the
matter might be conveniently remedied, or that by concealing his
knowledge he might avoid greater loss.
HOW THE ABBOT TREATED HIS RELATIONS
FOR his relations he displayed moderate affection, but yet no less tender than that which others are wont to show, since he had no relatives within the third degree, or pretended that he had not. I have, however, heard him assert that he had relations who were noble and distinguished, but that he would never at any time recognise them as relations. For, as he said, they would be rather a burden than a source of advantage to him if they knew of their relationship. On the other hand, he wished to have as kin those who had claimed kinship with him when he was a poor cloistered monk.
Some of his relations, in cases where he thought them useful and capable men, he appointed to various offices in his house, and others he entrusted with the wardenship of manors. But any whom he proved to be unfaithful he drove far from him, without hope of return.
He held as his dear kinsman a certain man of low birth, who had
managed his inheritance faithfully and served him devotedly in
his boyhood. To this man's son, who was a clerk, he gave the first
church which fell vacant after his accession to the abbacy, and
he also promoted all the man's other sons.
HOW THE ABBOT WAS MINDFUL OF THOSE WHO HAD SHOWN KINDNESS TO HIM IN THE PAST, AND HOW HE TREATED THOSE WHO HAD BEEN HARSH
THERE was a certain chaplain who had maintained him in the schools of Paris by the sale of holy water, when he was poor. This man the abbot caused to be summoned to him, and conferred on him an ecclesiastical benefice, with the position of vicar, whereby he might be supported.
He granted to a certain servant of his predecessor food and clothing for all the days of his life, this man being he who had placed fetters on him at the command of his lord when he was imprisoned.
When FitzElias, the cupbearer of abbot Hugh, came to do him homage for his father's land, the abbot said to him in open court, "I have delayed now for seven years to receive your homage for the land which abbot Hugh gave to your father, since that gift was to the detriment of the manor of Elmswell. Now I give way, since I am mindful of the good which your father did to me when I was in bonds. For he sent to me some of the very wine which his lord drank, with a message that I should be of good courage in God."
When master William, son of master William of Diss, asked of his grace for the vicarage of the church of Chevington, he answered, "Your father was master of the schools, and when I was a poor clerk he allowed me to enter the school without terms and of his grace, and to have the opportunity of learning. And I, for the sake of God, grant you that which you ask."
Two knights also from Risby, William and Norman, were by chance
judged to be at his mercy, and he thus addressed them in the presence
of all : "When I was a cloistered monk, I was sent to Durham
on the business of our church. And as I was returning thence by
way of Risby, I was overtaken by a dark night, and' sougfit entertaihment
tiom tfie i1orce Norman, but suffered an absolute denial. Then
I went to the house of lord William and prayed for lodging, and
was honourably received by him. For this cause I will take twenty
shillings, the full penalty, without pity, from Norman; but I
give thanks to William, and gladly remit the due penalty of twenty
CONCERNING OTHER GOOD ACTS OF ABBOT SAMSON
A CERTAIN young girl, who was begging her bread from door to door,
made complaint to the abbot that one of the sons of Richard FitzDrogo
had assaulted her. This wrong, by the abbot's intervention, was
at last settled for the sake of peace by the acceptance of one
mark by the girl. The abbot further took four marks from the said
Richard for leave to compound for his offence. But all these five
marks he ordered to be given at once to a certain pedlar, on condition
that he should marry the poor girl.
Before AD 1198
In the town of St. Edmund's the abbot bought stone houses, and
appointed them for the maintenance of the schools. His reason
for so doing was that thus the poor clerks might there be for
ever free from paying rent for houses. Hitherto, for the payment
of the rent, all the scholars, poor and rich alike, had been compelled
to contribute a penny or a halfpenny twice a year.
HOW THE JEWS WERE DRIVEN FROM SAINT EDMUND'S
THE recovery of the manor of Mildenhall for one thousand one hundred silver marks, and the expulsion of the Jews from the town of St. Edmund's, and the foundation of a new hospital at Babwell, were signs of great virtue.
The lord abbot sought letters from the king that the Jews might
be expelled from the town of St. Edmund's, asserting that whatever
is in the town of the blessed Edmund, or within the district subject
to the jurisdiction of the monastery, belongs of right to the
Saint, and that consequently the Jews ought either to be the men
of St. Edmund, or else be driven from the town. Leave, therefore,
was given to him to eject them, provided that they should have
all their chattels, as well as the value of their houses and lands.
And when they were sent forth, and under armed force were conducted
to various towns, the abbot ordered that in every church and
before every altar those should be solemnly excommunicated who
should henceforth receive Jews or entertain them as guests in
the town of St. Edmund's. This provision was afterwards modified
by the justices of the king, to the effect that if Jews should
come to the great pleas of the abbot in order to exact debts due
to them from their debtors, then for this reason they might be
entertained for two days and two nights in the town, and depart
in peace on the third day.
HOW THE ABBOT SECURED THE MANOR OF MILDENHALL, AND ENDOWED THE HOSPITAL AT BABWELL
AD 1189 September
THE abbot offered king Richard five hundred marks for the manor of Mildenhall, saying that the annual value of that manorwas seventypounds, and that it had been enrolled for that amount in the great roll of Winchester. And when he thought that he would obtain his desire in this matter, the settlement of the affair was postponed to the following day. In the interval there came one to the king and told him that the manor was worth quite one hundred pounds. And so when the abbot urged his request on the morrow, the king said to him, " My lord abbot, it is useless for you to make this petition to me. Either you shall give me a thousand marks, or you sliall not have the manor."
But queen Eleanor, who according to the custom of the realm, had
the right to receive a hundred marks when the king received a
thousand, took from us a great gold chalice of the value of a
hundred marks, and restored this same chalice to us for the good
of the soul of king Henry her lord, who had originally given it
to St. Edmund.
At a later date, when the treasure of our church was carried to
London for the ransom of king Richard, the queen redeemed the
same chalice for a hundred marks and restored it to us, and received
from us a charter in proof of our promise, made on the word of
truth, that we would never for any reason alienate that chalice
from our church.
Now when this large sum of money had been collected with great difficulty and had been paid, the abbot, sitting in the chapter, said that he ought to share somewhat in so great an acquisition as that of so fair a manor. And the monastery answered, "That is just. Let it be done according to your will." And the abbot said that he might lawfully claim half of it, and showed that he had spent more than four hundred marks with great labour, but that he would be content with one portion of that manor, a place called Icklingham, and this was most readily granted to him by the monastery. Hearing this, the abbot said, "And I receive that portion of the land for my own purposes, not that I may keep it in my hand or to give it to my relations, but that for the good of my soul and of the souls of all of you, I give it to the new hospital at Babwell, for the support of the poor and for the use of the hospital." So he spoke, and so it was done, and the act was afterwards confirmed by a charter from the king.
These and other like things did abbot Samson, which are worthy
to be written down and to be praised for all time. Yet he declared
that he would have done nothing, unless in his time he could bring
to pass that our church should be dedicated; and when that had
been accomplished, he asserted that he was ready to die. Moreover,
he said that for the doing of this thing he would expend two thousand
marks of silver, if so the king might be present and the affair
carried through with due ceremony.
CONCERNING THE CHURCH OF WOOLPIT, AND HOW IT WAS SECURED FOR THE ABBEY
THE abbot learnt that the church of Woolpit was vacant, for Walter
of Coutances had been elected to the bishopric of Lincoln. And
presently he summoned together the priorand most of the monastery,
and taking up his tale, said:
Between AD 1159 and AD 1162
"You know well what great labours I have undergone in the matter of the church of Woolpit, and how to secure it for your exclusive use I journeyed to Rome by your advice, in the days of the schism between Alexander and Octavian. And I traversed Italy at the time when all clerks bearing letters of pope Alexander were seized, some of them being imprisoned and others hanged, and others, after having their noses and lips cut off, were sent back to the pope to his shame and confusion. I, however, pretended that I was a Scot, and put on Scottish dress, and adopted the manners of a Scot. And I often shook my staff as they shake the weapon which they call a gaveloc at those who mocked me, shouting threatening words in the manner of the Scots. To those who met me and asked me who I was, I answered nothing except, " Ride, ride Rome, turne Cantwereberei." I acted thus that so I might conceal my purpose, and as a Scot might safely reach Rome. Then when I had obtained from the lord pope such letters as I desired, on my homeward way I passed by a certain castle as the road led me from the city. And, lo! the officers of the castle surrounded me, laying hold on me, and crying, "This wanderer, who makes himself out to be a Scot, is either a spy or one bearing letters of the false pope Alexander." And while they closely examined my clothes and boots and undergarments, and even the old shoes, which I carried on my shoulders in the Scottish manner, I put my hand into the little bag which I carried, and in which the letter of the lord pope was contained, lying under a little cup from which I was wont to drink. And the Lord God and St. Edmund willing it, I drew out the writing and the cup together, so that, stretching my hand on high, I held the writ underneath the cup. And they saw the cup, it is true, but they did not notice the writ. And so I escaped their hands, in the name of the Lord. Whatever money I had on me they took away, so that it was necessary for me to beg for my bread, spending nothing, until I came to England. But when I heard that the church was given to Geoffrey Ridel, my soul was grieved with the thought that my labour had been vain. So when I reached home I secretly cast myself before the shrine of St. Edmund, for I feared that the lord abbot would seize me and cast me into prison, who had deserved no ill. And there was no monk who dared to speak with me, and no layman who dared supply me with food, save secretly. At length, the abbot took counsel and exiled me to Acre, and there I long remained. These and many other countless ills I have suffered for the sake of the church of Woolpit. But blessed be God, Who maketh all things work together for good! Behold! the church for which I have borne so many hardships, is given into my hand, and now I have the power to give it to whomsoever I will, since it is vacant. And I restore it to the monastery, and for its sole use I assign the ancient customary due or pension of ten marks, which you have lost for more than sixty years. I would give it in its entirety to you with pleasure were I able to do so; but I know that the bishop of Norwich would forbid this, or if he were to grant it, he would make it an excuse to demand subjection and obedience from you, which is neither wise nor convenient. Therefore let us do what we may lawfully do. Let us place there a clerk as vicar to answer to the bishop for the spiritualities, and to you for the ten marks ; and I wish, if you agree, that the vicarage may be given to some relative of Roger de Hengham, a monk and your brother,who was my companion in that journey to Rome, and was exposed to the same dangers as I was and for the same cause."
At these words we all arose and gave thanks ; and Hugh, a clerk
and a brother of the said Roger, was received in the said church,
saving our annual pension of ten marks.
HOW THE ABBOT DISPUTED WITH THE ARCHBISHOP CONCERNING THE MANOR OF ELEIGH
Circa AD 1186
IN a manor of the monks of Canterbury, which is called Eleigh, and which is in the hundred of the abbot, there chanced to be a murder. 1186. But the archbishop's men would not allow the murderers to take their trial in the court of St. Edmund. Then the abbot made complaint to king Henry, and said that archbishop Baldwin was claiming the liberties of our church for himself, on the ground of a new charter which the king had given to the church of Canterbury after the death of the blessed Thomas.
Then the king answered that he had never given a charter to the prejudice of our church, and that he did not wish to take from the blessed Edmund anything which he had formerly possessed. On hearing this, the abbot said to his intimate advisers: "It is wiser counsel that the archbishop should make complaint of me than that I should make complaint of the archbishop. I wish to place myself in possession of this liberty, and then I will defend myself with the help of St. Edmund, in whose right our charters bear witness that this liberty is."
Accordingly, unexpectedly, and very early in the morning, with
the help of Robert de Cokefield, about eighty armed men were sent
to the town of Eleigh, and took those three murderers by surprise
and brought them bound, to St. Edmund's, and cast them into the
dungeon of the prison. And when the archbishop made complaint
of this, Ranulf Glanvill, the justiciar, commanded that those
men should be bound by surety and pledges to stand their trial
in the court wherein they ought to stand it; and the abbot was
summoned to come to the court of the king and to make reply concerning
the violence and injury which he was said to have done to the
archbishop. And the abbot many times presented himself at the
court, without attempting to make excuse.
AT last, at the beginning of the fasting time, they stood before the king in the chapterhouse of Canterbury, and the charters of the two churches were read publicly. And the lord king answered, "These charters are of equal age, and come from the same king Edward. I know not what to say, save that the charters arc contradictory." To this the abbot rcplied, "Whatever may be said about the charters, we are seised of the liberty, and have been in the past, and on this point I will submit to the verdict of the two counties, Norfolk and Suffolk, which will allow this."
Archbishop Baldwin, however, having first taken counsel with his men, said that the men of Norfolk and Suffolk loved St. Edmund greatly, and that a large part of those counties was under the rule of the abbot, and therefore he would not abide by their arbitration. But the king was angry and offended at that, and rising up, left the place, saying, " He that is able to receive it, let him receive it." And thus the matter was postponed, and is still undecided.
But I saw that some of the men of the monks of Canterbury were
wounded to the death by the rustics of the township of Midling,
which is situated in the hundred of St. Edmund, and as they knew
that the prosecutor is bound to go to the court of the defendant,
they preferred to be silent and to hide the matter, rather than
complain of it to the abbot or his officers, since they were in
nowise willing to come and plead in the court of St. Edmund.
After these things the men of Eleigh set up a certain measure
for the doing of justice in cases where bread and corn had been
measured with false measures, and the abbot made complaint of
this to the lord bishop of Ely, who was at that time justiciar
and chancellor. But he would not hear the abbot, because he was
alleged to be scenting the archbishopric, which was then vacant.
When, however, he had come among us, and was received as legate,
before he departed, he made prayer at the shrine of the holy martyr.
And the abbot, seizing the opportunity, said in the hearing of
all who were present,
AD 1191 29th October
"My lord bishop, the liberty, which the monks of Canterbury claim, is the right of St. Edmund, whose body is here, and as you will not assist me to protect the liberty of his church, I put a complaint between you and him. Henceforth he may secure his right." The chancellor did not condescend to make any answer, and within a year was forced to leave England, and suffiered divine vengeance.
But when the same chancellor had returned from Germany and had landed at Ipswich, and spent the night at Hitcham, a report came to the abbot that the chancellor wished to pass through St. Edmund's, and to hear mass with us on the morrow. Therefore the abbot forbade the celebration of the divine offices while the chancellor was present in the church, for he said that he had heard in London that the bishop of London had pronounced the chancellor excommunicate [AD 1191 September], in the presence of six bishops, es pecially for the violence which he had done to the archbishop of York, at Dover, and that the said chancellor, while excommunicate, had departed from England.
Accordingly, when the chancellor came among us on the morrow,
he found no one to chant mass for him, either clerk or monk. But
the priest, indeed, who stood at the first mass and at the canon
of the mass, and the other priests by the altars, ceased, and
stood with unmoved lips, until a messenger came and said that
he had left the church. The chancellor took no notice openly,
but he did many ills to the abbot, until, by the mediation of
friends, they both returned to the kiss of peace.
HOW THE ABBOT WISHED TO TAKE THE CROSS, AND HOW HE OFFERED TO SEEK KING RICHARD IN GERMANY
AD 1188 21st January
WHEN king Henry had taken the cross and was come less than a month
later that he might pray among us, the abbot secretly made for
himself a cross of linen cloth. Then, holding in one hand the
cross and a needle and thread, he sought leave from the king that
he might take the cross. But leave was refused him, for John,
bishop of Norwich, opposed it, and said that it was not well for
the land, nor safe for the counties of Norfolk and Suffolk, that
the bishop of Norwich and the abbot of St. Edmund's should go
away at the same time.
When news had reached London of the capture of king Richard, and
of his imprisonment in Germany, and the barons had met to take
counsel on the matter, the abbot stood forth in their presence,
and said that he was ready to seek his lord the king. He said
that he would search for him in disguise or ;n any other way,
until he found him and had certain knowledge of him. And from
this speech he gained great praise for himself.
HOW THE ABBOT RESISTED THE AUTHORITY OF THE LEGATE
WHEN the chancellor, the bishop of Ely, filled the office of legate
and held a council at London, he proposed certain decrees against
the black monks, talking of their wandering to the shrines of
St. Thomas and of St. Edmund under pretence of pilgrimage, and
speaking against the abbots, mentioning a certain number of horses
which they ought to have. Then abbot Samson answered, "We
will not receive any decree which is contrary to the rule of St.
Benedict, which allows the abbots a free hand in the control of
their monks. And I serve the barony of St. Edmund and his realm
; thirteen horses are not enough for me, as they may be for some
other abbots, unless I have additional horses for the administration
of the justice of the king."
OF THE CONDUCT OF THE ABBOT WHILE KING RICHARD WAS IN CAPTIVITY
AFTER the capture of king Richard, there was war throughout England. And the abbot with the whole monastery solemnly excommunicated all who stirred up war and broke the peace, showing no fear of earl John, the king's brother, or of any other, whence he was called a greatsouled abbot. And after doing this, he went to the siege of Windsor, where he appeared in arms with some other abbots of England, and had his own standard. He had there also with him many knights at great expense, and he gained a reputation rather for skill in the council than for virtue.
But we who were cloistered monks considered this course of action
to be fraught with danger, fearing lest some future abbot might
be compelled to go to war in person. Then, when a truce had been
granted, he went to Germany, and there sought the king with many
CONCERNING THAT WHICH BEFEL CERTAIN KNIGHTS WHO DESIRED TO HOLD A TOURNAMENT CONTRARY TO THE WISH OF THE ABBOT
AFTER the return of king Richard to England, leave was granted
to knights to hold tournaments, and many gathered, between ThetfordA.D.
and St. Edmund's for this purpose. Then the abbot forbade them,
but they resisted him, and did all that they desired.
On another occasion twentyfour young men, sons of nobles, came fully armed with their followers to have their revenge at the same place. And when they had made an end, they returned to the town to lodge there. But when the abbot heard of it, he commanded the gates to be closed and all of them to be shut within the town. The following day was the vigil of the apostles Peter and Paul. Therefore, when they had given their word that they would not leave the town without permission, they all ate with the abbot on that day. After the meal, when the abbot had retired to his private chamber, they all arose and began to laugh and sing. And sending to the town for wine, they drank and afterwards shouted loudly, and so they kept the abbot and the monastery from their sleep, and did everything to mock the abbot. So they spent the day until the evening, nor would they cease at the abbot's command.
Finally, when evening was come, they broke the bars of the gates
of the city, and forced their way out. The abbot solemnly excommunicated
them all, by the advice of archbishop Hubert, who was then justiciar,
and many of them made reparation and sought absolution.
CONCERNING THE MISSIONS OF THE ABBOT TO THE PAPAL COURT
Ad 1182 31st Marcc
THE abbot sent many messengers to Rome, and not in vain. The first whom he sent, immediately after his benediction, obtained in detail all the liberties and rights which had been granted to his predecessors, even in the days of schism.
A.D.1187 21st January
Afterwards he obtained that he might give episcopal benediction wherever he might be, and he was the first of the abbots of England to gain this. This right he won for himself and for his successors.
At a later date he acquired complete exemption for himself and for his successors from all the archbishops of Canterbury, a privilege which abbot Hugh had secured for himself alone. In these confirmations of privileges abbot Samson caused the inclusion of many new liberties, to the great freedom and safety of our church.
Then a certain clerk came to the abbot, bearing letters asking
for the grant of some ecclesiastical benefice. And the abbot drew
from his desk seven apostolic letters, with leaden seals hanging
to them, and answered as follows : " See the apostolic letters,
whereby different popes seek that ecclesiastical beneficcs may
be given to this or that clerk. When then I have satisfied those
who come first I will give you a benefice, since he who first
comes to the mill ought to grind first."
HOW THE ABBOT MET THE CLAIM OF EARL DE CLARE TO BEAR THE STANDARD OF SAINT EDMUND
A GENERAL summons was issued in the hundred of Risbridge that the complaint and trial of earl de Clare might be heard at Witham. And he was accompanied by a great crowd of barons and knights, while Earl Alberic and many others were present, and he said that his officers had given him to understand that they were wont to receive five shillings for his use from the hundred and from the officers of the hundred, which were now wrongfully withheld. He also alleged that his predecessors had been enfeoffed with the land of Alfric, son of Withgar, who was formerly lord of that hundred, at the time of the conquest of England.
But the abbot, considering in his own mind and not stirring from
his place, answered, "My lord earl, your words astonish me!
Your case is not proven. King Edward gave to St. Edmund, and confirmed
the gift in his charter, this whole hundred, and no mention was
made of these five shillings. Do you tell us for what service,
or on what grounds, you claim those five shillings!" And
the earl, having consulted his men, replied that he had the right
to bear the standard of St. Edmund in the host, and for this reason
those five shillings were due to him. Then the abbot answered,
"In truth, it seems an unworthy thing that so great a man
as the earl de Clare should receive so small a gift for so important
a service, but it is small harm to the abbot of St. Edmund's to
give five shillings. Earl Roger Bigod holds that he is scised
of the land, and declares that he is seised of the duty of bearing
the standard of St. Edmund, and he bore it when the earl of Leicester
was taken and the Flemings destroyed. Moreover, Thomas de Mendham
says that this right belongs to him. But when you shall have proved
against them that this right is yours, I will willingly pay the
five shillings which you demand." Then the earl answered
that he would speak of the matter to earl Roger his relative,
and so the matter has not been decided to this day.
CONCERNING THE CASE OF ADAM DE COKEFIELD
Now, when Robert de Cokefield was dead, his son Adam came with his relatives, earl Roger Bigod, and many other powerful men. And they sought from the abbot the holdings of the said Adam, and especially for half the hundred of Cosford, to be held at an annual rent of a hundred shillings, as if this was his by hereditary right, and declared that his father and grandfather had held it for eighty years past and more.
But the abbot, when he had opportunity for speaking, put his two fingers to his two eyes, and said, "May I lose these eyes in that day and hour in the which I grant a hundred to any man to hold by hereditary right, unless the king, who is able both to take away the abbacy from me and to deprive me of life, force me to do this thing." And he gave the reason for this saying, and added, "If any man hold a hundred by hereditary right, and if he commit an offence of any sort against the king for the which he ought to be disinherited, forthwith the sheriff of Suffolk and the officers of the king would seize the hundred, and would exercise authority within our borders. And if they should have the wardenship of this hundred, then would the liberty of eight hundreds and a half be imperilled."
Then he addressed himself to Adam, and said, "If you, who claim hereditary right in this hundred, were to marry any free woman, who held even a single acre of land from the king in chief, the king after your death would have seisin of the whole of your land and the wardship of your son, if he were a minor, and thus the officers of the king would enter the hundred of St. Edmund to the prejudice of the abbot. For the matter of that, your father made acknowledgment to me that he claimed no hereditary right in that hundred, and because his service pleased me, I permitted him to hold it all the days of his life, as his deserts warranted."
After he had thus spoken, much money was offered to the abbot,
but he could not be turned from his purpose either by prayer or
present. At the last it was thus agreed between them: Adam abandoned
the right which he had verbally claimed in the hundred, and the
abbot confirmed to him all his other lands. No mention was made,
however, of our township of Cokefield, and it is believed that
he had no charter concerning it. Semere and Groton he was to hold
for the term of his life.
HOW THE MILL WHICH HERBERT THE DEAN HAD BUILT WAS OVERTURNED
HERBERT the dean built a windmill on Haberdon. When the abbot heard this, he was so wroth that he would hardly eat, or speak a single word. On the morrow, after he had heard mass, he commanded the sacristan that without delay he should cause his carpentcrs to go thither and overturn everything, and place the wood with which it had been built in safe keeping.
And the dean heard this, and he came, saying that he was by law able to do this on his freehold land, and that the profit which may come from the wind ought to be denied to no man. He said also that he intended to grind his own corn there and not that of other men, that he might not be thought to have done this thing to the detriment of neighbouring mills.
And the abbot, still angry, replied, " I thank you as much as if you had cut off both my feet ; by the face of God, I will never eat bread until that building be overturned. You arc an old man, and you ought to know that neither the king nor his justiciar may change anything or build anything within the jurisdiction of the monastery, without the leave of the abbot and the house. And who are you, that you are so very presumptuous? Nor is this without harm to my mills, as you pretend, for the burghers go to your mill, and grind their corn at their pleasure, while I cannot lawfully hinder them, since they are free men. And I would not allow even the mill of the cellarer, which has been newly built, to stand, had it not been that it was built before 1 was abbot. Depart," he went on, "depart. Before you come to your house, you will hear what has come to pass in the matter of your mill."
Then the dean, fearing before the face of the abbot, took counsel
with his son, master Stcplicn, and anticipatcd the servants
of the sacristan, and caused the mill which had been built by
his own servants to be destroyed without delay. And so it was,
that when the men of the sacristan came there, they found nothing
HOW THE RIGHT OF THE ABBOT TO PRESENT TO CERTAIN CHURCHES WAS DISPUTED, AND WHAT BEFEL IN THE MATTER
AD 1194 and Later
THE right of the abbot to present to certain churches was disputed, and hegained the point. He also retained theright topresent incertain other cases where that right had been disputed, in the cases of the churches of Westly, Meringthorpe, Bretenhamy Wencling, Pakenham, Newton, and Bradfield in Norfolk, half the church of Boxford, the church of Scaldwcll and the church of Endgate. All these he retained against the claim of others, and he recovered the right of presentation to three parts of the church of Dickleburgh. And in those portions he restored the holdings to the freehold of the church, saying the service due thence to the manor of Titshall.
But when the church of Boxford fell vacant, and an inquest was ordered in the matter, five knights came, tempting the abbot~ and asking him what they should swear in that matter. But the abbot would not either give or promise them anything, and said, "When the time comes to make oath, say that which is right according to your conscience." Then they went away in anger and by their oath, in an inquest of darrein presentment, deprived him of the right of presenting to that church. This right he afterwards regained at great expense and by a payment of ten marks.
The abbot retained the church of Honington, which had not been vacant, but to which his claim had been disputed in the time of Daniel de Hostelli, though he produced in evidence of his right a charter of William, bishop of Norwich, wherein it was provided that Robert de Valoniis, his fatherinlaw, had given that church to Ernald Lovell.
Before AD 1191
When half the church of Hopeton was vacant, a dispute arose on
this matter between the ibbot and Robert de Ulmo. And when a day
for settling the matter was appointed at Hopeton, after much disputing,
the abbot said to the same Robert, being moved thereto by some
sudden impulse, "Swear in your own person that this right
is yours, and I will grant that it is." And when the knight
refused to swear, the matter was transferred with the assent of
both parties to sixteen legal men of the hundred, who made oath
that the right belonged to theabbot. Gilbert Fitz Ralph and Robert
de Cokefield, the lords of that fief, were Present, and gave their
HOW ABBOT SAMSON DISPUTED WITH JORDAN DE ROS
THEN Master Jordan de Ros, who bad charters both from abbot Hugh and the said Robert, came forward, and addressing both parties, said that whichever of them proved his claim to the church, he ought to have the position of rector. He declared that he was rector of the whole church, and that the recently deceased clerk was his vicar, paying to him an annual income from that half, and in evidence he produced a charter of Walchelin the archdeacon.
Then the abbot was perturbed and angered with him, nor did he ever receive him into his favour until the same Jordan in the chapter of the monks of Thetford, owing to the abbot's insistence, resigned into the hands of the bishop, who was present there, that half absolutely, without any conditions or hope of recovery, in the presence of a number of clerks. When this had been done, the abbot said, "My lord bishop, I am bound on a promise to give the revenue to one of your clerks, and I will give the half of this church to whichsoever of your clerks you will." And the bishop asked that he would restore it in a friendly manner to the sairic Jordan, and thus Joraan receivea it by presentation from the abbot,
After this a dispute arose between the abbot and this same Jordan about the land of Herard in Harlow, ,is to whether or no it was a free fief of the church. And when an inquest of twelve knights was ordered on this matter, to be made in the king's court, by leave of the justiciar Ranulf Glanvill it was made in the court of the abbot at Harlow. And the jurors swore that they had never known that land divided from the church, but yet that this land owed to the abbot the same service as the land of Eustace and certain other land of laymen in the same township owed to him.
At last an agreement was reached between them on the following
terms: master Jordan in full court acknowledged that this land
was a lay fief, and that he had no rights in it except by
the grace of the abbot. And he was to hold that land all the days
of his life, paying an annual rent to the abbot for it of twelve
pence in commutation of all services.
HOW THE AUTHOR MADE A LIST OF THE ABBOT'S CHURCHES AS A GIFT TO THE ABBOT, AND THE NAMES OF THOSE CHURCHES
Now when, in the manner of the English, many men gave many presents to the abbot, as to their lord, on the day of the Circumcision of the Lord, I, Jocelin, thought what I could give to him. And I began to write out a list of all the churches which are in the gift of the abbot, both on our irianors and on his, and the right values of the same, according as they might be placed at firm at a time when the price of corn was moderate. And when the beginning of the next year came, I gave to the abbot that schedule as my gift to him, and he received it with great pleasure.
Then I, because I was then pleasing in his sight, "thought in my heart" that I might say to him that he should give some church to the monastery and should assign it to the maintenance of hospitality, as he had himself desired when he was a poor cloistered monk, and as before his election be had wished the brothers to swear, that he on whom the lot of the abbacy should fall should do this. But while I so thought I suddenly called to mind that some other had already said to him this word, and that I had heard the abbot answer that he could not dismember his barony, that is, that he ought not to reduce the liberty and dignity which abbot Hugh and others, his predecessors, had possessed in the matter of giving churches, which brought little or no gain to the monastery. And for this cause I was silent.
Now the writing was as follows:
"These are the churches on the manors and socages of the abbot: The church Of Melford, valued at forty pounds; Chevington, ten marks; Saxhjm, twelve marks; Hargrave, five marks; Bretenham, five marks; Boxford , a hundred shillings ; the greater Fornham, a hundred shillings; Stowe, a hundred shillings ; Honington, five marks ; Elmswell, three marks; Cotton, twelve marks; Brocford, five marks ; Palgrave, ten inarks ; the greater Horningsherth, five marks; Kingston, four marks; Harlow, nineteen marks ; Stapleford, three marks ; Tivetshall, a hundred shillings ; Worlingworth and Bedingfeld, twenty marks ; Saham, six marks; half the church of Worthain, a hundred shillings ; Rungton, twenty marks; Thorp, six marks; Woolpit, with the pension excluded, a hundred shillings ; Rushbrook, five marks ; half the church of Hopeton, sixty shillings ; Richinghall, six marks; three parts of the church of Dickleburgh, at the rate of over thirty shillings for each part ; half the church of Gislingham, four inarks; Ickflngham, six marks ; the church of Mildenhall which is worth forty marks, and half the church of Wederden, some unknown quantity; Weneling, a hundred shillings; the church of Len, ten marks; that of Scaldwell, five marks ; Warkton . . .
"These are the churches on the manors of the monastery :Mildenhall, Barton, and Horningsherth, valued at twentyfive marks, exclusive of the pension Rougham, fifteen marks, exlcusive of the pension Bradfield, five marks ; Pakenham, thirty marks ; Southrey, a hundred shillings; Risby, twenty marks; Newton, four marks; Whepstead, fourteen marks ; Fornham St. Genevieve, fifteen marks; Herningswell, nine marks; Fornham St. Martin, three marks; Ingham, ten marks ; Lackford, a hundred shillings ; Alpheton, ten marks; Cokefield, twenty marks; Semere, twelve marks; Groton, five marks ; half the church of Fresingfeld, fourteen marks ; Beccles, twenty marks ; Broc, fifteen marks ; Heldcercle, ten marks ; Warkton, ten marks; Scaldwell, five marks; Westley, five marks; a church in Norwich, two marks, excluding the pension of herrings ; and two churches in Colchester, three marks, excluding the pension of four shillings ; Chelsworth, a hundred shillings ; Meringthorp, four marks half the church of Bradfield in Norfolk, three marks staffacres, and foracres, and a third of the tithes of the demesnes of Wrabnesse, six marks."
HOW THE ABBOT FREED HIS CHURCH FROM CONTRIBUTION TO THE FINE INFLICTED ON NORFOLK AND SUFFOLK
The two counties of Norfolk and Suffolk were adjudged by the itinerant justices to be fined at the king'sdiscretion for some fault, and fifty arks were imposed upon Norfolk and thirty upon Suffolk. And when some portion ofthat common fine was placed upon the lands of St. Edmund and sternly exacted, the abbot without delay went to the lord king, and we found him at Clarendon. And when a charter of king Edward, which freed the lands of St. Edmund from all gelds and scot, had been shown to him, the king ordered by his letters that six knights of the county of Norfolk and six ofthat of Suffolk should be summoned to make inquest in the presence of the barons of the exchequer, as to whether the demesnes of St. Edmund ought to be quit of that general fine.
Then six knights were chosen, that so trouble and expense might
be saved, and these because they held lands in both counties,
namely, Hubert de Brisewood, W. FitzHervey, and William de Francheville,
and three others. They went with us to London, and on behalf of
the two counties adjudged this libertyto belong to our church.
Then the justices who were present enrolled their verdict.
HOW THE ABBOT DISPUTED WITH HIS KNIGHTS
ABBOT SAMSON began a struggle with his knights, he against all and all against him. lie declared that they ought to make to him the full serviceof fifty knights in scutages, aids; and the like, since, as they admitted, they held the fees of that number of knights. He disputed as to why ten of those fifty knights should be free from service, and as to the reason or authority those forty received the service of ten knights. They all with one voice answered that such was the custom, that ten of them should ever help the forty, and they said that on this matter they would neither make answer nor stand trial, as they ought not to do so.
But when they were summoned to make answer on this matter in the court of the king, some craftily excused themselves and others craftily appeared, the latter saying that they ought not to answer without their peers. On another occasion, those who had at first absented themselves appeared, and said the same thing, that they ought not to make answer without their peers, who were with them in the dispute.
And when they had thus many times mocked the abbot, and had vexed him with great and heavy expenses, the abbot complained on this matter to archbishop Hubert, who was then justiciar. And he answered in the full council that each knight ought to reply for himself and for his own holding. Aridhesald openly that he knew well, and was well able to secure, the right ofhis churchagainst alland every one of them.
Then earl Roger Bigod was the first to acknowledge freely that in law he owed his lord, the abbot, the full seryice of three knights, and both in reliefs, and scutages, and aids. But as to the wardenship of the castle of Norwich, he was silent.
After that there came two of the knights, and then three, and then more, and eventually almost all, and, following the example of the earl, admitted the same service. And is a recognition made on this matter in the court of St. Edmund was not enough, the abbot took with him to London at his own expense the wives and women, who were heiresses of lands, that they might make recognition in the king's court, and each received a separate charter.
Alberic de Vere and William de Hastings, and two others were in the service of the king, across the sea, when these things were done, and therefore this dispute had to await final settlement. Alberic de Vere was the last who resisted the abbot ; but the abbot took and sold his cattle, by which means he was driven to come to the court and make answer as his peers had done. And so he took counsel, and at last recognised the right as belonging to St. Edmund and the abbot.
Therefore when all the knights had been overcome, the abbot might have made great gain of money from so notable a victory, had he not desired to spare some of them. For whenever twenty shillings are charged on a fee, there will remain for the abbot twelve pounds, and if more or less be charged, then more or less will remain according to the due proportion. Further, the abbot and his predecessors were wont at the end of twenty weeks to give seven shillings for the wardship of the castle of Norwich from his own money, to supply the defect of the three knights ; fees which earl Roger Bigod holds of St. Edmund. And all the knights of the four constabularies used to pay twentyeight pence when thq~began to make wards, and one penny to the marshal who collected those pennies, and they gave twentyeight pence and no more, because the ten knights of the fifth constabulary were wont to assist the other forty. Therefore, when they ought to have given three shillings in full, they gave only nineteen pence, and one who should have entered upon the duty of making ward at the end of four months, entered at the end of twenty weeks. Now, however, all the knights paid three shillings in full, and the amount by which it has been increased beyond twentynine pence remains to the abbot, wherefore he can repay himself the said seven shillings.
Thus was seen how the threats of the abbot, which he uttered on his first day when he received the homage of his knights, had their fulfilment, when, as has been related, all the knights promised him twenty shillings and at once went back on their promise, refusing to give him a total sum of more than forty pounds in making aids and performing wards and in all like things.
In Tivetshall there is some land on the fee of the abbot which
used to pay to the watchmen of the castle of Norwichwaitefee,
which is to say, twenty shillings a year, at the rate of five
shillings at each of the four fasting time This is an ancient
custom, which the abbot very anxious to change if he could. But
as he saw his weakness in this matter, he still is silent and
conceals his wish.
CONCERNING HENRY OF ESSEX
IN order to spread far and wide the memory of the blessed king and martyr, we have added what follows to our writings, not improperly we hope. It is not that I, who am unimportant and almost of no account at all, should put this out with an historical title, but that master Jocelin, our almoner, a man of renowned piety, one mighty in word and deed, at the pressing request of the powers that be, at last thus began it in this way; and I regard the work as mine, since, according to the precept of Seneca, I may without presumption ascribe to myself whatever has been well said by another.
When the abbot was come to Reading, and we with him, we were rightly received by the monks of that place. And among them was Henry of Essex as a professed monk, who, when he had a chance to speak to the abbot and to those who were present, told us how he had been conquered in a trial by battle, and how and why St. Edmund confounded him, in the very hour of conflict. But I wrote down his tale by command of the lord abbot, and I wrote it also in these words.
Inasmuch as it is impossible to avoid unknown evil, we have thought it well to commit to writing the acts and crimes of Henry of Essex, that they may be a warning, and not an example. Stories often convey an useful and salutary warning.
The said Henry, then, while he enjoyed great prosperity, had the reputation of a great man among the nobles of the realm, and he was renowned by birth, noted for his deeds of arms, the standardbearer of the king, and feared by all men owing to his might. And when others who lived near him enriched the church of the blessed king and martyr Edmund with goods and rents, he on the contrary not only shut his eyes to this fact, but further violently, and wrongfully, and by injuries took away the annual rent of five shillings, and converted it to his own use.
In the course of time, moreover, when a case arose in the court of St. Edmund concerning a wrong done to a certain maiden, the same Henry came thither, and protested and declared that the trial ought to be held in his court *ause 'the place where the said maiden was born was within is lordship of Lailand.
With the excuse of this affair, he dared to trouble the court of St. Edmund for a long while with journeyings and countless charges.
But fortune, which had assisted his wishes in these and other like matters, brought upon him a cause for lasting grief, and after mocking him with a happy beginning, planned a sad conclusion for him ; for it is the custom of fortune to smile, that she may rage ; to flatter, that she may deceive ; and to raise up only that she may cast down. For presently there rose against him Robert de Montfort, his relative, and a man not unequal to him in birth and power, and slandered him in the presence of the princes of the land, accusing him of treason to the king. For he asserted that Henry, in the course of the Welsh war, [AD 1157] in the difficult pass of Coleshill, had treacherously cast down the standard of the lord king, and proclaimed his death in a loud voice; and that he had induced those who were coming to the help of the king to turn in flight. As a matter of fact, the said Henry of Essex believed that the renowned king Henry the Second, who had been caught in an ambush by the Welsh, had been slain, and this would have been the truth, had not Roger, earl of Clare, a man renowned in birth and more renowned for his deeds of arms, hastened up quickly with his men of Clare, and raised the standard of the lord king, which revived the strength and courage of the whole army.
Then Henry resisted the said Robert in the council, and utterly denied the charge, so that after a little while the matter came to a trial by battle. Then when they met at Reading to fight on an island somewhat near the abbey, [AD 1163]there gathered there also a multitude of persons, to see how the affair would end. And it came to pass, that when Robert manfully made his armour ring again with hard and frequent blows, and his bold beginning promised the fruit of victory, Henry's strength began to fail him a little. And as he looked round about, behold! on the edge of land and water, he saw the glorious king and martyr Edmund, armed and as it were flying in the air, and looking towards him with an angry countenance, often shaking his head in a threatening manner, and showing himself full of wrath, And Henry also saw with the saint another knight, Gilbert de Cereville, who appeared not only less than the saint in point of dignity, but also head and shoulders shorter ; and he looked on him with accusing and angry glances. This Gilbert, by order of the said Henry, afflicted with bonds and tortures, had died, as the result of an accusation brought against him by the wife of Henry, who cast the penalty for her own illdoing on an innocent man, and said that she could not endure the evil suggestions of the said Gilbert.
When he saw these sights, then, Henry grew alarmed and fearful, and called to mind that an old crime brings new shame. And now, giving up all hope, and abandoning skilful fighting for a blind rush, he took the part of one who attacks rather than that of one who defends himself. And when he gave hard blows, he received harder ; and while he fought manfully, he was more manfully resisted. In a word, he fell conquered.
And as he was thought to be dead, in accordance with the earnest
request of the magnates of England, the relatives of the said
Henry, the monks of that place were allowed to give burial to
his corpse. But he afterwards revived, and when he had regained
the blessing of health, under the regular habit, he wiped out
the stain of his former life, and taking care to purify the long
week of his dissolute past with at least one sabbath, he cultivated
the study of the virtues, to bring forth the fruit of happiness.
HOW THE ABBOT DECEIVED THE BISHOP OF ELY FOR THE GOOD OF HIS CHURCH
GEOFFREY RIDEL, bishop of Ely, sought from the abbot a supply of wood for making some great buildings at Glemesford, and the abbot granted this request against his will, for he did not at that time dare to offiend the bishop. But while the abbot was staying at Melford, a certain clerk of the bishop came and asked on behalf of his lord that they might be allowed to take the said wood at Elmswell ; and he made a mistake in his speech, saying Elmswell where he should have said Elmset, the latter being the name of a certain wood at Melford. And the abbot marvelled at the message, for such wood was not to be found at Elmswell.
Then when Richard the forester of the same township had heard this, he told the abbot privately that the bishop in the preceding week had sent his carpenters as spies into the wood of Elmset, and that they had chosen the best trees in the whole wood, and marked them with their signs. At this news, the abbot saw at once that the messenger of the bishop had delivered his message wrongly, and told him that he would gladly meet the wish of the bishop.
On the morrow, after the messenger had departed, as soon as he had heard mass, the abbot went with b is carpenters into the said wood, and caused all the oaks which had been already marked, and more than a hundred others, to be marked for the use of St. Edmund, and for the completion of the great tower ; and he ordered that they should be cut down as rapidly as possible.
But the bishop, when he learned from the report of his messenger
that the needed wood was to be taken at Elinswell, overwhelmed,
the messenger with much abuse, and sent him back to the abbot
that he might correct the word which he had said wrongly, that
is, when be said Elmswell for Elmsct. But before he had come to
the abbot, all the trees, which the bishop desired, and which
his carpenters had marked, had been cut down. It was therefore
necessary for the bishop to take other trees and in another place,
if he would. But 1, when I saw this, laughed and said in my heart,
"Thus craft is defeated by craft."
HOW THERE WERE DISPUTES CONCERNING THE APPOINTMENT OF BAILIFFS FOR THE TOWN
ON the death of abbot Hugh, the wardens of the abbacy desired to depose the bailiffs of the town of St. Edmund's, and to appoint new bailiffs by their authority, alleging that this right pertained to the king, in whose hand the abbey was. But when we made complaint on this matter and sent our messengers to the lord Ranulf Glanvill, who was then justiciar, he answered that he was well aware that forty pounds ought to be rendered from the town to our sacristan annually, and especially for the lights of the church. And he added that abbot Hugh, according to his pleasure and in his chamber, without the assent of the monastery, had given the office of bailiff as often and to whomsoever he would, saving the forty pounds of revenue for the altar; it was therefore not remarkable if the officials of the king exacted this right on the king's behalf. Then in rough tones, he called all us monks fools in that we had allowed our abbot to do such things, not thinking that the chief duty of monks is to keep silence, and to shut their eyes to all the faults of their prelates, nor thinking of the fact that we are called cheats if in any matter, either rightly or wrongly, we raise opposition, and that sometimes we are accused of treason, and sometimes condemned to imprisonment and exile. For these reasons, it seems the wiser counsel to me and those in my position, rather to die as confessors than as martyrs. When our messenger returned to us and told what he had heard and seen, we took counsel, as it were unwillingly and under compulsion, to the effect that, by the common action of the monastery and of the wardens of the abbey, the old bailiffs of the town should be deposed; this was as far as possible to be a joint act, though Samson, who was our subsacristan, was opposed to the plan.
At a later date, when he had been made abbot, Samson was not unmindful of the injury which had been done to the abbey, and on the morrow of the Easter next after his election, he caused the knights and clerks and many burgesses to be gathered together in our chapter, and in the presence of all of them said that this town belonged to the monastery and to the altar, especially in the matter of finding lights for the church. And he said that he wished to renew the old custom, that all that concerned the balliwick of the town and such like matters pertaining to the monastery, should be decided in the presence of the monastery and by common assent,
And at that same time two burghers, Godfrey and Nicholas, were named bailiffs, and there was a dispute as to the question from whose hand they should receive the horn, which is called moothorn. At last they received it from the hand of the prior, who after the abbot is the chief man in the affairs of the monastery. Then those two bailiffs peacefully exercised their jurisdiction for many years, until they were said to be slack in administering the justice of the king. Then at the suggestion of the abbot himself, that greater security might be given to the monastery in this matter, they were removed, and the sacristan Hugh received it into his hand. He appointed new servants, who were responsible to him for the balliwick. In course of time, howeverI know not for what rcasonnew bailiffs were again appointed elsewhere than in the chapter, and without the assent of the monastery, on which account there was a fear of the same or greater danger after the death of abbot Samson than there had been after the death of abbot Hugh.
And one of our brothers, who was fully confident of the love and friendship of the abbot, took an opportunity to address the abbot on this matter, with due modesty, and he declared that the monastery murmured for this cause. When the abbot heard this he was long silent, as if he were somewhat troubled for this, and at last, so it is said, answered as follows: "Am not I, even I, the abbot? Is it not my affair to dispose of the goods of the church committed to my care, provided that I act wisely and according to God? If there be a default in the administration of the king's justice in this town, I shall be accused on the matter, 1 shall be summoned to the court, on me will fall the labour of the journey and the expense, and the defence of the town and of that which pertains thereto. It will be 1 who am regarded as a fool, and not the prior or the sacristan or the monastery. No, it will be I, who am and ought to be their head. By my means and by my counsel, with God's help, the town shall be preserved unharmed so far as in me lies, and the forty pounds of annual rent to the altar shall be preserved. Let the brothers murmur ; let them blame me ; let them say what they will among themselves. I am their father and abbot, and while 1 live, 1 will not give mine honour to another."
When he had so spoken, the monk left him and told his answers.
But I marvelled at such words, and thought the thing over in secret
and with care. At last I was forced to doubt still, since the
rule of law says and teaches us that all things are in the disposition
of the abbot.
HOW ABBOT SAMSON DISPUTED WITH THE MEN OF LONDON ABOUTTHE PAYMENT OF TOLLS
THE merchants of London wished to be quit from toll at the fair of St. Edmund's. Many, however, though unwillingly and under compulsion, paid it, and on this account many tumults and a great disturbance occurred between the citizens of London in their court. Wherefore, having held a meeting about the matter, they sent word to abbot Samson that they ought to be quit of toll throughout all England, under the authority of the charter which they held from king Henry the Second.
To this the abbot answered that, were it needful, he could easily bring the king to warrant him that:he had never made them a charter in prejudice of our church, or to the injury of the liberties of St. Edmund, to whom the holy Edward had granted and confirmed toll and thearn and all regalian rights before the conquestofEngland. And he added that king Henry had given to the Londoners quittance from toll throughout his own demesnes, where he had the right to give it; for in the city of St. Edmund's he could not give it, for it was not his to give.
When the Londoners heard this, they decreed with common assent that none of them should come to the fair of St. Edmund's, and for two years they did absent themselves, whence our fair suffered great loss, and the offerings in our sacristry were greatly diminished. Eventually, when the bishop of London and many others had mediated, an agreement was reached between them and us whereby they should come to the fair, and some of them should pay toll, but this should be at once returned to them, that by such a device the privilege of both parties might be maintained.
But as time went on, when the abbot had come to an agreement with his knights, and as it were, rested in peace, lo! again, "The Philistines be upon thee, Samson!" For the Londoners, with one voice, threatened to level with the earth the stone houses, which the abbot had built in the same year, or to take distress a hundredfold from the men of St. Edmund, if the abbot not at once make reparation to them for the wrong which they had suffered from the bailiffs of the town of St. Edmund's. For they had taken fifteen pence from the carts of the citizens of London, which were coining from Yarmouth and carrying herrings, and which passed through our town. And the citizens of London said that they had been quit of toll in every market, and always and in every place, throughout England, from the time when the city of Rome was first founded, at which time the city of London was also founded. They said that they ought to have this privilege throughout all England, both on the ground that their city was a privileged city, which had been the metropolis and capital of the kingdom, and on the score of the antiquity of the city.
The abbot, however, asked for a truce on this dispute for a reasonable
time, until the return of the king to England, that he might consult
with him on this matter; and taking the advice of men skilled
in the law, he handed back to the complainants those fifteen Pence
as a pledge, without prejudice to the question of the right of
HOW THERE WAS A DISPUTE WITH THE BURGHERS AS TO THE DUES FROM THE TOWN
IN the tenth year of the abbacy of abbot Samson, by common counsel ofour chapter, we made complaint to the abbot in his court and said that the receipts from all the goods of the towns and boroughs of England were increased, and had grown to the advantage of the possessors and the greater profit of their lords, save in the case of this town, which had been wont to pay forty pounds and had never had its dues increased. And we said that the burghers of the city were responsible for this, since they held so many and such large stands in the marketplace, shops and sheds and stalls, without the assent of the monastery, and at the sole gift of the bailiff; of the town, who were annual holders of their offices, and as it were servants of the sacristan, being removable at his good pleasure.
But when the burghers were summoned, they answered that they were under the jurisdiction of the king, and that they ought not to make reply, contrary to the liberty of the town and their charters, concerning that which they had held and their fathers well and in peace, for one year and a day without dispute. And they said that it was the old custom that the bailiffs should, without consulting the monastery, give to them places for shops and sheds in the marketplace, in return for some annual payment to the balliwick. But we disputed this, and wished the abbot to dispossess them of such things as they held without having any warrant for them.
Then the abbot came to our council, as if he had been one of ourselves, and privately informed us that he wished, so far as he could, to do right to us; but that he had to proceed in a judicial manner, and that he could not, without the judgment of the court, dispossess his free men of their lands and revenues, which they had, whether rightly or wrongly, held for many years. He added that if he were to do this, he would he liable to punishment at the discretion of the king and at the assizes of the kingdom.
The burghers, therefore, took counsel and offlered the monastery
a revenue of a hundred shillings for the sake of peace, and that
they might hold that which they held as they had been accustomed.
But we would not grant this, preferring to postpone the matter,
and perchance hoping that in the time of another
abbot, either we might recover all, or change the place of the
fair; and so the matter for many years advanced no further.
CONCERNING THE CHARTER GRANTED TO THE TOWN BY THE ABBOT
BUT when the abbot had returned from Germany, the burghers offered him sixty marks, and sought his confirmation of the liberties of the town, under the same form of words as that in which his predecessors Anselm and Ording and Hugh had confirmed them to them. And this also the abbot graciously conceded. But while we murmured and grumbled, a charter was made for them, as he had promised to them ; and as it would have been a source of shame and confusion to him if he had been unable to do that which he had promised, we would not oppose him, or provoke him to anger. But the burghers, from the time when they had the charter of abbot Samson and of the monastery, were full of confidence that they would never lose their holdings and liberties in, the time of abbot Samson ; and, therefore, never afterwards would they, as they had done before, give or offer the said revenue of a hundred shillings.
The abbot, however, at length turned.his attention to this, and assembling the burghers together about the matter, said that if they would not make their peace with the monastery, he would forbid their sheds to be put up at the fair of St. Edmund's. Then they answered that they would give every year a silken cope, or some other ornament to the value of a hundred shillings, as they had before promised. But they offlered this on condition that they should be quit for ever from the tenths on their money which the sacristan sternly exacted from them.
The abbot and the sacristan opposed this offer, and so the dispute
was again left unsettled. But we have lost those hundred shillings
from that day to this, according is is said in the proverb, "
He that will not when he may, when he will he shall have nay."
HOW THE MONASTERY WAS TROUBLED WITH INCOMPETENT CELLARERS
CELLARERS succeeded each other in rapid succession, and each one of them at the end of the year was oppressed with great debt. The twenty pounds from Mildenhall were given to assist the cellarer, and proved insufficient. Afterwards there were assigned to him forty pounds a year from the same manor, and still the cellarer said that this was not enough.
Accordingly the abbot, wishing to provide for his own safety and comfort and for ours, as be knew that in the case of any deficiency ive must appeal to him, as the father of the monastery, associated with our cellarer one of the clerks of his table, master Ranulf by name, that be might assist him as a witness and companion both in the paying out and in the receiving of money.
And behold! there was much diversity of opinion. Murmurs rose ; lies were invented ; slanders are joined to slanders, nor is there a spot in the house which is not resounding with poisonous hissings. One says to another, "What is this which has been done? Who has seen such things? Never was such a disgrace inflicted on a monastery. See! the abbot has made a clerk superior to a monk. See! he has made a clerk master and guardian over the cellarer, that he may be able to do no good without him. The abbot little regards his monks; he suspects them : he consults the clerks ; he loves clerks. How is the gold become dim! how is the most fine gold changed! "
And friend said to friend. " We are become a reproach to our neighbours. All we monks are held to be either dishonest or extravagant ; credit is given to a clerk, not to a monk ; the abbot has more confidence in a clerk than in a monk. Why should this clerk be more faithful, or wiser, than some monk?" And one said to his companion, " Are not our cellarer and subcellarer, or cannot they be, as faithful men as the sacristan or as the chamberlain? The result is that this abbot or his successor will associate a clerk with the sacristan, and a clerk with the chamberlain, and a clerk with the subsacristans, to collect the offerings at the shrine, and so with ill the officials, whereby we shall become a laughingstock and a scorn to all people."
But when I heard these things, I used to answer, "If I were cellarer, I should wish to have a clerk to be my witness in all that had to be done, and so if I did well, he would bear witness of the good, but if at the end of the year I were burdened with any debt, I should be able by means of the clerk to gain credence and be excused."
I heard a certain one of our brothers, a man discreet and learned
indeed, say a thing which moved me and many others. " It
is not wonderful," he declared, " if the lord abbot
intervenes in matters connected with tl~ safe conduct of our affairs.
For he rules wisely the part of the abbey, which belongs to him,
and he makes wise dispositions for his house; and it is his concern
to supply that which is lacking to us, if a want arises owing
to our carelessness or poverty. But," he continued, "there
is yet one possible danger which may arise after the death of
abbot Samson, and such a danger has never been in all the days
of our life. There is no doubt that the officers of the king will
come and will take the abbey into his hand, that is, the barony
which pertains to the abbot, as has been done hitherto, after
the death of other abbots, and as was done before on the death
of abbot Hugh, the officials of the king will desire to appoint
new bailiffs in the town of St. Edmund, alleging as their authority
that abbot Hugh did this. And for the same reason, in course of
time, the officials of the king will appoint a clerk of theirs
to watch over the cellar, that all things may be done through
him and by his command, and they will say that this ought to be
done, because abbot Samson did so. And in this way they will be
able to mingle and to confound the affairs and revenues ofthe abbot and of the monastery, which abbot Robert, of
happy memory, after taking counsel, separated and divided from
each other." And when I heard these and other like words
from a man of great wisdom and prudence, I was overwhelmed and
was silent, wishing not to condemn and wishing not to excuse the
lord abbot in so great a matter.
HOW THE ABBOT RESISTED HUBERT WALTER WHEN HE CLAIMED LEGATINE AUTHORITY OVER THE ABBEY
HUBERT WALTER, archbishop of Canterbury, and legate of the apostolic see and justiciar of England, after he had visited many churches, and had changed many things and introduced innovations by his legatine authority, on his return from his carnal mother, who was dying at Dereharn where she dwelt, he sent to us two of his clerks, who bore scaled letters from their lord, in which it was announced that we should give credence to their sayings and acts. Then these clerks made enquiry of the abbot and monastery as to whether we would receive their lord, the legate, who was coming to us, in such a manner as a legate ought to be received, and as he had been received in other churches. And if we would grant this, then he would shortly come to us, to ~ettle the business and affairs of our church according to God, with the advice of the abbot and monastery. But if we would not grant this, those two clerks would explain to us more in detail the message of their lord.
Then the abbot summoned the majority of the monastery and we took counsel that we should give a favourable answer to the clerks who had been sent to us, saying that we would receive their lord, as legate, with all honour and respect, and that we should send with them our messengers, who should say the same to the lord legate on our behalf. And our idea was that, as we had previously done in the case of the bishop of Ely and other legates, we should show him all honour with a procession and the ringing of bells, and receive him with the other due ceremonies, until perchance he should come to hold a visitation in the chapter. And if he wished to do this, then at last we should all resist him in common to the face, appealing to Rome and trusting to our charters.
The lord abbot said also, "If the legate now wishes to come to us, let us act in this manner as has been said. But if he delay his coming to us for a while, let us again seek counsel of the lord pope, and ask what force the privileges of our church, which we have obtained from him and his predecessors, ought to have as against the archbishop, who has obtained power from the apostolic see over all the other privileged churches of England." Such then was our counsel.
And when the archbishop heard that we would receive him as legate, he received our messengers graciously, and with giving of thanks. And he became kind and friendly to the lord abbot in all his affairs, and delayed his coining among us for a while on account of some urgent business. Therefore, without any delay the abbot sent to the lord pope the same letters which the legate had sent to the monastery, which announced that he would come to us by the authority of his legation and by the authority of tiie lord pope, and in which it was written that power had been given him over all the exempt churches of England, notivithstanding letters granted to the church of York and others.
So at the instance of the messenger of the abbot, the lord pope wrote to the lord of Canterbury and declared that our church, his spiritual daughter, was accountable to no legate, unless it might be to a legate a latere, sent by the lord pope, and forbade him to stretch forth his hand over us. And the lord pope addedp on his own account, that he further forbade him to exercise power over any other exempt church. Our messenger returned to us and the matter was hidden for some days. But it was made known to the lord of Canterbury by his friends In the court of the lord pope.
Now when at the end of the year the legate made his visitation in Norfolk and Suffolk, and had come first to Colchester, he sent a secret messenger to the abbot, and informed him that he had heard it said many times that the abbot had obtained letters against his legation, and asked that he would send those letters to him in a friendly way. And so it was done, for the abbot had two copies of the letters in identical terms. But the abbot visited the legate neither in person nor through any intermediary, as long as he was in the bishopric of Norwich, lest he might be thought to desire to come to terms with the legate as to the matter of providing entertainment for him, as the other monks and canonical persons had done. The legate, for his part, was disturbed and angry, and fearing that be would be shut out if he should come to us, passed through Norwich, Acre, and Dereham to Ely, making his way towards London.
Then within a month, the abbot appeared before the legate between Waltham and London, in the king's highway, and the legate blamed him because he would not come to him as justiciar of the lord king, when he was in that district. But the abbot answered that he had been there not as justiciar, but as legate, making scrutiny in all churches, and brought forward as his excuse the season of the year, and that the Passion of the Lord drew near, at which time it was necessary for him to be engaged in divine services and in the observances of the cloister. And when the abbot met words with words and objections with objections, and could not be terrified or bent, the legate answered with anger that he well knew that he was skilled in argument, and that he was a better clerk than the legate was.
Therefore the abbot, without passing over in a cowardly manner things which ought not to be mentioned, or speaking arrogantly of those things which had to be said, in the audience of many men, answered that he was the type of man who would never allow the liberty of his church to be infringed, either owing to lack of knowledge or to lack of money, even if it were necessary for him to die or be condemned to perpetual banishment. And when an end was made of these and other like altercations, the legate began to blush when the abbot spoke softly and prayed that he would deal more mildly with the church of St. Edmund, for the sake of his native land, for he was as it were a son of St. Edmund and there brought up. He blushed, indeed, because he had thoughtlessly poured forth the poison which he had conceived within him.
On the morrow, word was brought to the archbishop of Canterbury
that the lord of York was coming to England as legate, and that
he had hinted many evil things to the lord pope concerning him,
saying that he had oppressed the churches of England by taking
on account of his visitation thirty thousand marks of silver.
For that reason the legate sent his clerks to the abbot, asking
that he would write with the other abbots to the lord pope and
defend him. And then the abbot granted this, and gave witness
that the lord of Canterbury had neither come to our church, nor
oppressed that or any other church, speaking according to his
knowledge. And when the abbot had handed over those letters to
the messengers of the archbishop, he said before all men that
he had no fear even if the archbishop wished to make an improper
use of these letters. And the clerks answered on the peril of
their master's soul, that their lord wished not to deal craftily,
but only desired to excuse himself. And so the archbishop and
the abbot were made friends.
HOW THE ABBOT CONTENDED WITH HIS KNIGHTS AS TO SERVICE ACROSS THE SEA
KING RICHARD sent orders to all the bishops and abbots of England that every nine knights should furnish a tenth, and that these should come to him in Normandy without delay, with horses and arms, to help him against the king of France. It therefore was necessary for the abbot to be responsible for the sending of four knights. And when he had caused all his knights to be summoned, and had gathered them together on this matter, they answered that their fees, which they held of St. Edmund, were not liable to this, and that neither they, nor their fathers, had ever gone out of England, though they had sometimes paid scutage by command of the king.
Then the abbot was in a difficult position, as on the one hand he saw that the liberty of his knights was endangered, and on the other feared lest he might lose seisin of his barony for default of service to the king, as had happened to the bishop of London and to many barons of England. And he at once crossed the sea, and having wearied himself with many labours and expenses and with the many presents which he gave to the king, at first he was unable to come to terms with the king by means of a money payment. And so, when the king said that he needed neither gold nor silver, but instantly demanded the four knights, the abbot offered him four mercenary knights. And the king received these and sent them to the castle of Eu. And the abbot gave them thirtysix marks at once for their expenses for forty days.
But on the morrow there came certain friends of the king, and counselled the abbot that he should proceed cautiously, saying that the war might last for a full year or more, and the cost of the knights increase and multiply to the perpetual loss of him and his church, They therefore advised that before he left the court, he should come to terms with the king, so that he might be quit of the said knights after forty days. Then the abbot, taking good advice, gave a hundred pounds to the king for this quittance, and so returned to England in high favour with his lord. And he bore with him the king's writ that distraint should be levied on the fees of his knights to repay him for the service which he had made to the king on their behalf.
When the knights were summoned, they alleged their poverty and many different grievances, and offered their lord two marks from each fee. And the abbot, not unmindful of the fact that he had himself burdened them in that same year, and had brought a suit against them to force them to pay a full scutage, wished to win back their favour, and graciously accepted that which they willingly offered to him.
At that time, though the abbot incurred great expenses over sea,
he did not return emptyhanded to his church, but brought
with him a golden cross and a precious copy of the scriptures,
which was worth twentyfour marks. And on another occasion,
when he had returned from across the sea, sitting in his chapter
he said that had he been cellarer or chamberlain he would have
sought for something which would be helpful in the administration
of his office. And he added that as he was abbot he ought to acquire
something which was fitting for an abbot, and saying this he offered
the monastery a costly chasuble and a mitre inlaid with gold,
and sandals with silken buskins, and the head of a pastoral staff,
made of silver and well worked. In the same way, as often as he
returned from beyond the sea, he brought some ornament with him.
HOW THE ABBOT TOOK CHARGE OF THE CELLAR, AND HOW FOR THAT CAUSE MURMURING AROSE IN THE MONASTERY
IN the year of grace one thousand one hundred and ninetyseven, certain changes and alterations were made in our church, which may not be passed over in silence. When our cellarer did not find his ancient revenues sufficient, abbot Samson ordered that fifty pounds should be given him in annual increase from Mildenhall by the hand of the prior. This was not to be paid at one time, but in instalments every month, that in each month there might be something to spend, and that the whole might not be used up in one part of the year ; and so it was done for one year.
But the cellarer and his assistants complained of this, and he said that if he had had that money in his hands, he would have provided for himself and gathered stock for himself. Then the abbot, against his will indeed, granted that request. And when the beginning of August came, the cellarer had already spent the whole amount, and moreover owed twentysix pounds, and was bound to pay a debt of fifty pounds before Michaelmas.
And when the abbot heard this, he was wroth, and spoke thus in the chapter, " I have often threatened that I would take our cellar into my own hands owing to your incompetence and extravagance, since you bind yourselves with great debt. I placed my clerk with your cellarer as a witness, that the office might be managed with greater care. But there is no clerk or monk who dares tell me the cause of the debt. It is said, indeed, that the too elaborate feasts in the prior's house, which occur with the assent of the prior and of the cellarer, and the superfluous expense in the guesthouse owing to the carelessness of the guestmaster, are the cause of it. You see," he went on, "the great debt which is pressing on us ; tell me your opinion as to the way in which the matter should be remedied."
Many of the cloistered monks, hearing this, and, as it were, laughing to themselves, were pleased with what was said, and said privately that what the abbot said was true. The prior cast the blame on the cellarer, and the cellarer on the guestmaster, and the guestmaster made excuse for himself. We, of course, knew the true reason, but were silent from fear. On the morrow the abbot came and again said to the monastery, "Give me your advice as to how your cellar may be more thoughtfully and better managed." And there was no one who would answer a word, save one who said that there was no waste at all in the refectory whence any debt or burden could arise. And on the third day the abbot said the same words, and one answered, " The advice ought to come from you, as from our head."
Then the abbot said, " Since you will not give advice, and cannot rule your house for yourselves, the control of the monastery falls upon me as your father and chief guardian. I receive," he went on, "into my own hand your cellar and the charge of the guests, and the task of getting supplies within and without." And with these words, he deposed the cellarer and guestmaster, and replaced them with two monks, with the titles of subcellarer and guestmaster, and associated with them a clerk of his table, master G., without whose assent nothing was to be done in the matter of food and drink, or in expenditure or in receipts. The former buyers were removed from the work of buying in the market, and food was to be purchased by a clerk of the abbot, and our deficits were to be made jgood from the abbot's treasury. Guests who ought to be received were received, and those who ought to be honoured were honoured. Officials and cloistered ` monks alike took their meals in the refectory, and on all sides superfluous expenses were cut down.
But some of the cloistered monks said among themselves, " There were seven, yes, seven, who devoured our goods, and if one had spoken of their devouring he would have been regarded as one guilty of hig~ treason." Another said, as he stretched forth his hands to heaven, 'I Blessed be God, Who hath given such a desire to the abbot, that he should correct so great faults." And many said that it was well done.
Others said that it was not well done, thinking so great a reformation derogatory to the honour of the house, and calling the discretion of the abbot the ravening of a wolf; and in truth they called to mind old dreams, to the effect that he who should become abbot would raven as a wolf.
The knights were astonished, the people marvelled, at these things which had been done, and one of the common sort said, " It is a strange thing that the monks, being so many and learned men, should allow their affairs and revenues to be confused and mingled with the affairs of the abbot, when they had always been wont to be separated and parted asunder. It is strange that they do not guard themselves against the danger which will come after the death of the abbot, if the lord king should find things in this state."
A certain man again said that the abbot was the only one who was skilled in external affairs, and that he ought to rule all, who knew how to rule all. And one there was who said, "If there were but one wise monk in so great a monastery, who might know how to rule the house, the abbot would not have done such things." And so we became a scorn and derision to those who were round about us.
About this time it happened that the anniversary of abbot Robert was to be celebrated in the chapter, and it was decreed that a Placebo and a Dirige should be sung more solemnly than was wont, that is, with ringing of the great bells, as on the anniversaries'of abbots Ording and Hugh. The cause of this was the noble deed of the said abbot Robert, who separated our goodsand revenues from those of the abbot. But this solemnity was due to the counsel of some that so the heart of the lord abbot might be moved to do well. One there was, however, who thought that this was to be done to the shame of the abbot, who was accused of wishing to confound and intermingle his affairs and revenues and ours, in that he had taken our cellar into his own hand.
Then when the abbot heard the unusual ringing of bells, and knew well and considered that this was contrary to custom, he wisely hid the cause of the action and sang mass solemnly. But on the following Michaelmas, since he wished to silence the murmurs of some men in part, he appointed him who had been subcellarer to the post of cellarer, and ordered another to be nominated as subcellarer, though the same clerk remained with them and procured all needful things as before. But when that clerk passed the bounds of moderation, saying, "I am Bu,"whereby he meant that the cellarer had passed the bounds of temperance in drinking,and when, without consulting the abbot, he held the court of the cellarer and took sureties and pledges, and received the revenues for the year and spent them with his own hand, he was publicly called chief cellarer by the people.
And when the clerk often wandered through the court, and many
poor and rich debtors followed him as if he had been master and
chief agent, as well as claimants of divers sorts and on divers
matters, perchance one of our officials stood in the court. He
saw this, and wept for shame and confusion, thinking that this
was a shame to our church, and thinking of the danger which would
result, and thinking that a clerk was preferred to a monk to the
prejudice of the whole monastery. Accordingly he, whoever he was,
procured by means of another, that this should be fitly and moderately
pointed out to the lord abbot, and it came to pass that it was
brought to the abbot's knowledge how arrogant the clerk was, and
what he did to the shame and wrong of all ; and that he was the
cause of great disturbance and discord in the monastery. But when
the abbot heard this, he at once ordered word to be sent to the
cellarer and to the said clerk, and commanded that the cellarer
should henceforth regard himself as cellarer in the receipt of
money, and in holding pleas, and in all other matters, saving
this only, that the said clerk should assist him, not on an equality,
but as a witness and adviser.
CONCERNING THE WILL OF HAMO BLUND
HAMO BLUND, one of the richest men of that town, being on his deathbed, was scarce willing to make any will. At length, however, he left three marks by will, no one hearing his wishes except his brother and his wife and a chaplain. And when the abbot held an inquest after his death, lie summoned those three and sternly rebuked them because the brother, who was the heir, and the wife, would not permit any other to come to the sick man, desiring to gain all things.
And the abbot said in full audience, "I was his bishop, and
I had the care of his soul; that the ignorance of his priest and
confessor may not be harmful, and because I was absent and could
not advise the sick man while he yet lived, it is my concern that
I should do so even when it is late. I command that all his money
and moveable property, which is reported to be worth two hundred
marks, shall be written down, and that one portion shall be given
to the heir, and a second to his wife, and a third to his poor
relations and to other poor men. But the horse, which was led
before the coffin of the dead man, and which was offered to St.
Edmund, 1 order to be sent back and returned. For it is not right
that our church should be disgraced by the present of him who
died intestate, and who is accused by report of having been wont
often to lend his money upon usury. By the face of God, if what
has now happened occur again in the case of any man in my time,
he shall not be buried in the cemetery." And when he had
so spoken, the others went away in confusion.
HOW THERE WERE RIOTS IN THE CEMETERY, AND CONCERNING THAT WHICH WAS DONE IN THE MATTER
ON the morrow of the Nativity of the Lord, meetings and sports and bandying of words were held in the cemetery between the servants of the abbot and the burghers of the town; and from words it came to blows, from blows to wounds, and to bloodshed. But when the abbot knew of this, he privately called together some of those who had come to the spectacle, but who had taken no part in it, and commanded the narnes of all the offenders to be written down. And he caused all of them to be summoned to appear to make answer before him in the chapel of St. Denis on the morrow of the feast of St. Thomas the archbishop. And in the meantime he would not invite any of the burghers to his table, as he had been wont to do in the first five days of Christmastide.
So on the appointed day, when oath had been taken from sixteen legal men, and their evidence had been heard, the abbot said, " It is well known that those wrongdoers have broken the canon Latae sententiae. But as there are laymen in both parties, and they know not how great a crime is such notable sacrilege, that the others might fear the more I will excommunicate them by name and publicly, and that justice may not be in any wisc lacking, I will begin with my domestics and servants."
Then this was done, when we had robed and lighted the candles. And all went out from the church, and having taken counsel, they all stripped themselves, and, naked except for their underclothes, prostrated themselves before the door of the church. And when the assessors of the abbot had come, monks and clerks, they told him in lamentable tones that more than a hundred men lay thus naked, and the abbot was grieved. Yet showing the rigour of the law in his word and face, and concealing the kindness of his heart, he wished to be compelled by his advisers to absolve the penitents, knov;,ng that mercy should be exalted against judgment, and that the church should receive all penitents. Therefore all were heavily scourged and absolved, ,rid all swore that they would abide by the judgment of the church for the sacrilege which had been done.
But next day a penance was assigned to them according to the provisions
of the canons, and so the abbot received all in full peace, and
threatened terrible things to all who 1 n word or deed should
produce cause for dispute. Then also he publicly forbade meetings
and spectacles to be held in the cemetery, and so, when everything
had been restored to peace, the burghers ate with the lord abbot
on the days following with great joy.
HOW THE MONKS WERE RESTORED TO COVENTRY
A COMMISSION of the lord pope was issued to Hubert, archbishop of Canterbury, and the lord bishop of Lincoln, and to Samson, abbot of St. Edmund's, for the reformation of the church of Coventry and for the restoration of the monks, without hearing the case again. And so the parties to the suit met at Oxford, and the judges received letters from the lord king, asking that the matter might be postponed. Then the archbishop and the bishop dissembled and kept silence, and as it were sought the favour of the clerks. But the abbot alone spoke openly as a monk for the monks of Coventry, publicly favouring their case and defending them. And by his means, it advanced so far on that day that a certain simple scisin was made to one of the monks of Coventry to the value of one pound. But the restoration of the whole body was for a while delayed, that to this extent at least the abbot might meet the request of the lord king.
At that time fourteen monks of Coventry, who were present there, were entertained by the abbot in his lodging, and while the monks were seated at table in one part of the house, and the masters of the schools, who had been invited, the abbot was praised as being magnanimous and magnificent in his entertainment, nor was he ever in his life seen in better spirits than then, owing to his zeal for the reform of the monastic order.
AD 1198 13th January
And when the next feast of St. Hilary came, the abbot went with
great gladness to Coventry, and was overcome
neither by labour nor by his expenses, and he said that if he
had to be borne in a horse litter, he still would not tarry. Then
he came to Coventry, and for five days waited for the archbishop,
and honourably maintained all the said monks with their servants,
until a new prior was created and the monks solemnly introduced
into the church [18th January]. He who has ears to hear, let him
hear; the deed is worthy of remembrance.
HOW THE ABBOT ENDOWED SCHOOLS AT SAINT EDMUND'S
AFTER these things an agreement was made between abbot Samson and Robert de Scales as to the half of the advowson of the church of Wetherden, and the same Robert acknowledged the right of St. Edmund and of the abbot. The abbot, when no agreement had been made beforehand, and no promise had been given, gave the half of that church which belonged to him to master Roger de Scales, brother of the same knight, on condition that he would render an annual pension of three marks by the hand of our sacristan to the master of the schools, who should read in the town of St. Edmund's.
The abbot was led to do this by motives of memorable generosity,
and since he had already bought stone houses for the purposes
of the school that the poor clerks might be quit from house rent,
so henceforth they were free from all exaction of money, which
the master of the schools had, according to custom, exacted for
their education. Then by the will of God and in the lifetime of
the abbot, the whole half of that church, which was worth, so
it is said, a hundred shillings, was turned to such uses.
CONCERNING IMPROVEMENTS WHICH THE ABBOT MADE IN THE ABBEY
Now when the abbot had built many different buildings in his townships throughout the abbacy, and had taken up his residence on them more often and more frequently than with us at home, at last he returned, as it were, to himself. And making good, as it were, better, he said that he would stay at home more than had been his wont, and that he would build houses which were needed, regarding things within and without, and knowing that the presence of the master is the profit of the field.
Accordingly he ordered that the stables and offices in and around the court, which had previously been covered with reeds, should be covered with new roofs, made of slates, by means of Hugh the sacristan, that so all fear might be removed and all danger of fire. And behold the acceptable time, the day which had been desired! Of this I cannot write without joy, for that I had the care of the guests. Behold! by order of the abbot, the court resounded with spade's and with the tools of masons, that the guesthouse might be overthrown, and now was almost entirely razed, since the Highest planned its restoration!
The abbot built a new larder for himself in his court, and gave the old larder of the monastery for the use of the chamberlain, since it was unfittingly situated under the dormitory. The chapels of St. Andrew and St. Catherine and St. Faith were newly covered with lead. And many improvements were efrected within and without the church. If you do not believe, open your eyes and behold!
And in his time also our stone almonry was constructed, which had before been out of repair and built of wood, and to the cost of this one of our brothers, Walter the physician, who was then almoner, contributed that which he had made from the practice of medicine.
Moreover, when the abbot saw that the silver table of the high altar, and many other precious ornaments, had been alienated for the recovery of Mildenhall and for the ransom of king Richard, he would not restore that table or other similar things, which for a like purpose might be torn away and distrained. But he turned his attention to the construction of a most valuable crest over the shrine of the glorious martyr Edmund, that his ornament might be placed there, whence for no reason could it be taken away, and where no man would dare to lay hands upon it. Indeed, when king Richard was taken captive in Germany, there was no treasure in England which was not given or for which redemption was not made, yet the shrine of St. Edmund remained intact.
For when there was a dispute before the justices in the exchequer
court as to whether the shrine of St. Edmund should be partially
disman tled for the ransom of the king, the abbot arose and said,
" Know it for the truth that this shall never be done by
me, nor is there any man who can compel me to assent to this.
But I will open the doors of the church ; let him enter who will,
let him approach who dares." And all the justices answered
with oaths, " I will not come near it," "1 will
not come near it." And they said, "St. Edmund is even
more angered against those who are far away and absent, than he
is with those who are present and would take away his cloak."
And when this had been said, the shrine was not stripped, nor
was a ransom paid for it. And for this cause the abbot omitted
other things, and turned his mind with forethought and providence
to the making of a crest for the shrine. And now the plates of
gold and silver resounded between the hammer and the anvil, and
the smiths worked with their tools.
HOW THE ABBOT DISPUTED WITH THE KING AS TO THE WARDSHIP OF THE LAND OF ADAM DE COKEFIELD
About AD 1198
ADAM DE COKEFIELD died,and left a daughter of three months as his heir, and the abbot gave the wardship of the fief to whomsoever he would. But king Richard, at the request of some of his friends, earnestly sought the wardship and the child for the advantage of a servant of his own, both by letters and bymessengers. But the abbot replied that he had given the wardship, and had confirmed the gift under his charter; and sending a messenger to the king, tempted him with prayers and presents, that he might so calm his wrath.
Then the king answered with great anger that he would avenge himself on the proud abbot, who opposed him, if he were not ready to refrain from his reverence for St. Edmund whom he feared. Therefore the messenger of the abbot returned, and the abbot wisely concealed the threats of the king, and said, "Let the king send if he will, and take possession of the wardship ; he has force and power tor perform his will, and to take away the whole abbacy. I will never bend to do readily that which he desires, and it shall never be done by my means. For there is fear that such an action might be drawn into a precedent to the hurt of my successors, and for this matter I will never give the king money. Let the Most High regard it. I will bear patiently whatever may befall."
Then when many said and believed that the king was moved against
the abbot, lo! the king wrote in a friendly way to the abbot,
and sent word that he should present to him some of his dogs.
And the abbot was mindful of the saying of a wise man, "Presents,
believe me, move both men and gods, and Jupiter himself may be
appeased with gifts." So he sent the dogs for which the king
asked to him, and in addition he sent also horses and other valuable
gifts. And when the king had graciously received these, he commended
the uprightness of the abbot and his fidelity to his trust publicly
in the presence of his earls and barons, and sent to the abbot
in token of his friendship and love a valuable ring, which the
lord pope Innocent the Third had given him for his great affection
to him, and which was the first gift which had been made to him
after his coronation. And he sent many things by his writ to him
for the presents which he had sent.
HOW THE CUSTOMARY DUES OF THE TOWN WERE CHANGED
MANY marvelled at the changes in the customary dues which took place with the orders or consent of the lord abbot Samson. From the time when the town of St. Edmund's received the name and liberty of a borough, the men of every house had been wont to give to the cellarer one penny at the beginning of August for the reaping of our corn, which tax was called repselver. And before the town was free all were wont to reap as slaves, and only the houses of the knights and chaplains and servants of the court were free from this tax. But as time passed, the cellarer spared some of the richer men of the town and exacted nothing from them.
When the other burghers saw this, they said publicly that no one who had a messuage of his own ought to pay that penny, but only those who rented the houses of others. Afterwards, all in common sought this freedom, coming to the lord abbot about it, and offering an annual payment in place of this exaction. Then the abbot learnt that the cellarer had gone through the town to collect repselver in a wrongful manner, and thit he had caused sureties to be taken from the houses of the poor men, taking sometimes tripods, and at others doors, and other goods, and how the old women appeared with their distaffs, threatening and cursing the cellarer and his men. And he decreed that twenty shillings should be given to the cellarer every year at the next portmanmoot, by the hand of the bailiff, before August, by the burghers who should give money to pay this.
And this was done, and confirmed by our charter. And they were given quittance from a certain customary due which is called sorpenny, in return for fourshillings to be paid at the same time. For the cellarer had been wont to receive one penny a year for each cow, belonging to the men of the city, which went out to pasture, unless the cows were those of the chaplains or servants of the court, and these cows he used to put in the pound, and about this he used to have much trouble.
But later on, when the abbot spoke of this in the chapter, the
monastery was indignant and angry, and so Benedict the subprior
made answer for all in the chapter, and said, " He, that
abbot Ording, who lies there, would not have done such a thing
for five hundred marks of silver." But the abbot was angry
at this, and postponed the matter for a time.
CONCERNING A DISPUTE BETWEEN THE CELLARER AND THE SACRISTAN
ALSO a dispute arose between Roger the cellarer and Hugh the sacristan concerning the perquisites of their offices,so that the sacristan would not lend to the cellarer the prison in the town for the imprisonment of robbers, who were taken in the fee of the cellarer. Wherefore the cellarer was often vexed, and when the robbers escaped, was blamed for the failure of justice.
But it happened that a certain free tenant of the cellarer who remained without the gate, a man called Ketel, being accused of robbery and defeated in a trial by battle, was hanged. And the monastery was grieved at the abusive words of the burghers, who said that if the man had lived within the gate, the matter would not have come to trial by battle, but that he would have been acquitted by the oaths of his neighbours, as was the privilege of those who dwelt within the borough.
And when the abbot and the more reasonable section of the monastery saw this, and observed that the men, both without and within the borough are our men, and that all should enjoy the same liberty within the jurisdiction of the abbey, except the villeins adscript to the soil at Hardwick and their like, provided with care that this should be so.
Then the abbot being anxious to define with definite conditions the offices of the cellarer and of the sacristan, and to calm disputes, as though he favoured the side of the sacristan, gave orders that the servants of the bailiff of the town and the servants of the cellarer should enter together the fee of the cellarer to take robbers and malefactors. And he ordered that the bailiff should have half the pay due for the imprisonment and guarding of the men and for the labour required, and that the court of the cellarer should go to the portmanmoot, and that there cases which had to be adjudged should be adjudged with common assent. And it was also resolved that the men of the cellarer should go to the tollhouse with the rest, and there renew their sureties, and that they should be inscribed in the roll of the bailiffl, and pay a penny to the bailiff there, which payment is called borthsclver, and that the cellarer should have half of it. Now, however, the cellarer receives nothing on this account.
All this was done that all might enjoy equal liberty. But the
burghers still say that those who dwell without the town ought
not to be free from market toll, unless they are members of the
gild merchant. And the bailiff, with the assent of the abbot,
claims the pleas and forfeitures of the fee of the cellarer to
CONCERNING THE CUSTOMS AND DUES OF THE CELLARER
The old customs of the cellarer, which we have seen, were as follows:The cellarer had a messuage and barns near Scurun's well. There lie was wont to hold his court solemnly for the trial of robbers and all other pleas and disputes. There he used to place his men in pledge and enrol them, and to renew the pledges every year, and to take for this such money as the bailiff took at the portmanmoot. This messuage, with the garden adjoining it, which a tenant holds now, was the manor of Bcodric, who was formerly lord of that town, and the town was therefore formerly called Bcodricsworth, and his demesne lands are now in the demesne of the cellarer. That which is now called averland was the land of his villeins. The total amount of his holding and those of his men was thirty times thirty acres of land, and these are still the fields of the town. The service from this, when the town was made free, was divided into two parts, so that the sacristan or bailiff might receive a free tax of twopence from each acre. The cellarer was to have the ploughing and other services, that is, the ploughing of one rood for every acre without giving of food, and this custom is still observed.
He was also to have the folds where all the men of the town, with the exception of the steward, who has his own fold, were bound to place their sheep, and this custom is still observed. And he was to have also ayepenny, that is twopence for every thirty acres, but this custom was changed before the death of abbot Hugh, when Gilbert de Elveden was cellarer.
The men of the town, by order of the cellarer, were wont to go to Lakenheath, and to bring back a catch of eels from Southrey, and often they returned emptyhanded, so that they were burdened without profit to the cellarer, wherefore it was agreed among them that henceforth every thirty acres of land should pay one penny a year, and the men remain at home. That land, however, is now so divided that it is hard to tell what rent should be paid from it, with the result that I have seen the cellarer in one year take twentyseven pence, while now he can hardly take tenpence halfpenny.
Again, the cellarer used to have authority in the roads without the town, so that no one was permitted to dig for chalk or clay without a licence from him. And he used to summon the fullers of the town, that they should give cloth for his chalk. Otherwise, he would prohibit them the use of water, and would take the webs which he found there, and these customs still maintain. And also whoever bought of the cellarer corn or anything, used to be free from toll at the gate when he went out, for which cause the cellarer sold his goods at a higher price, and this custom still remains. Also the cellarer was wont to take toll from flax, when it was carried about, at the rate of one bundle from each load. And the cellarer alone ought, and used, to have a free bull in the fields of this town ; now more men have free bulls. And whenever any one gave his land held in burgage in frank almoin to the monastery, and this was handed over to the cellarer or to another official, that land was wont to be quit from haggovele, and especially when it was assigned to the cellarer, on account of the importance of his office, for that he is the second father in the monastery, and for respect to the monastery, since the state of those who procure our food ought to be good. This custom the abbot regards as unjust, since the sacristan loses his service.
The cellarer was also wont to warrant the servants of the court, that they should be free from scot and tallagc, but now this is not the case, for the burghers say that the servants of the court ought to be quit indeed as fir as they are servants, but not in so far as they hold land in burgage in the town, and in so far as they or their wives buy or sell publicly in the market. The cellarer was wont to take all the manure in every street for his use, except such as Was before the doors of those who had averland ; for they alone might collect and have it. That custom rather fell into abeyance in the time of abbot Hugh, until Dennis and Roger de Hengham were cellarers. They, wishing to revive the ancient custom, seized the manure carts of the burghers, and caused them to be unloaded. But as a number of burghers then resisted successfully, every one now collects the manure which is on his holding, and the poor sell theirs when and to whom they will.
The cellarer had also this right in the market of the town, that
he and his agents should buy first in the case of all food for
the use of the monastery, if the abbot were not at home. The buyers
of the abbot or of the cellarer, whichever should come first to
the market, was to buy first, either the former without the latter,
or the latter without the former ; in case they both came at the
same time, the preference was given to the abbot's agents. At
the time when herrings were sold, the abbot's agents were always
to buy a hundred herrings for a penny less than other men, and
the cellarer and his agents had the same right. If a load of fish
or other food should come first to the court or should come into
the market, and the load had not been taken from the horse or
from the cart, then the cellarer and his agents might buy and
take for themselves the whole load without toll. Abbot Samson,
however, ordered his agents that they should give place to the
cellarer and his agents, because, as he himself said, he would
rather that he lost than his monastery. Accordingly, the agents,
in honour preferring one another, when anything came to be sold
which was not enough for both parties, bought the thing jointly
and divided it equally, and so discord became concord between
the head and the members, and between the father and his sons.
HOW THE AUTHOR WAS BLAMED FOR PRAISING THE ABBOT TOO MUCH
THE poet has said that envy aims at the highest, and so I relate that when a certain person saw the present writing, and read of so many good actions, he called me a flatterer of the abbot, and said that I was hunting after grace and favour, telling me that I had passed over in silence some things which ought not to have been left unmentioned. And when I asked him what things, and what sort of things these were, he answered, "Have you not seen that the abbot gives the escheated lands in the demesnes of the monastery, and heiresses of lands being minors, and widows both within and without the town of St. Edmund's, to whomsoever he will? Have you not seen that the abbot has attracted to himself suits and pleas of those who by the royal writ claim lands which are of the fee of the monastery, and more especially suits in which there is money to be gained ; and that he passes on those suits in which there is no profit to the cellarer or the sacristan or the other officials?"
And to this I answered as best I knew how, and perhaps well, perhaps ill, saying that every lord of a fief, to whom homage is due, ought to have the escheat by law, when there is one in the fief, whence he reccives homage ; and for a similar reason, ought to have a general aid from the burghers and the wardship of boys, and marriage rights over widows and girls, in those fees whence he has homage ; and all these things seemed to belong to the abbot alone, unless by chance the abbacy should be vacant. In the town of St. Edmund's, however, as it is a borough, there is a custom that the wardship of a boy, until he comes to years of discretion, and his inheritance, vests with the nearest relative.
And as to suits and pleas, I answered that I had never seen the
abbot usurp to himself our pleas, unless on account of a failure
of justice on our part ; but yet that he had sometimes received
money that, by the intervention of his authority, suits and pleas
might come to a right conclusion. And I have sometimes seen pleas,
which belonged to us, conducted in the abbot's court, since there
was no one who at the beginning of the case would claim the trial
for the monastery.
HOW THERE WAS A FIRE NEAR THE SHRINE OF SAINT EDMUND
IN the year of grace one thousand one hundred and ninetyeight, the glorious martyr Edmund willed to terrify our monastery, and to teach us that his body should be more reverently and carefully guarded. There was a certain wooden floor between the shrine and the high altar, on which were two candles, which the guardians of the shrine used to relight. And they were wont to put one candle on another, and to stick them together carelessly. And under this floor many things were lying together in an untidy manner, such as flax and thread and wax and vessels of different sorts, in fact the keepers of the shrine used to put there whatever came into their hands, behind the door with iron sides which the place had.
On the night of St. Etheldreda's day then the keepers were asleep, and part of a candle, which had been relit, fell, is we believe, while it was still burning, on the same floor which was covered with rags. And it caught all things which were near it, and those above and underneath went on fire, so that the iron walls were all white hot. And lo! the anger of the Lord was kindled, but not without mercy, as it is written, In wrath remember mercy. For in the same hour the clock struck before the hour of matins, and the master of the vestry arose and perceived and knew of the fire. Then he ran at once, and sounding the gong, as if for a dead man, he cried with a loud voice and said that the shrine was on fire.
Then we all ran up and found the fire raging with incredible fierceness, and surrounding the whole shrine, and almost reaching the beams of the church. Then the young men ran for water, some to the well and some to the clock, and some used their hoods, and with great labour put out the fire. But first they stripped some of the altars. Then, when cold water had been poured on the front of the shrine, the stones fell and were reduced as it were to dust. And the nails with w1iich the silver plates were fastened to the shrine came out of the wood, which had been burnt to the depth of my finger, and the plates hung one from another without nails.
Yet the golden image of the saint at the front of the shrine, and some stones, remained firm and unharmed, and the image was more beautiful after the fire than it had been before, because it was of pure gold.
Now it happened by the will of the Most High, that at this time the great beam, which had been over the altar, had been taken away that it might be newly carved. It happened also that the cross, and the little Mary, and the John, and the chest with the garment of St. Edmund, and the case containing the relics, which had formerly hung from the same beam, and other holy things which had stood onthe beam, had all been carried away beforehand. Otherwise, we believe that they would all have been burnt, as a painted cloth was burnt, which was hanging in the place of the beam. But what would have happened if the church had been hung with curtains?
So when we were sure that the fire had nowhere entered the shrine, after carefully looking at the cracks and chinks, wherever they were, and after seeing that all was cold, our sorrow was greatly lessened. And lo! some of our brothers cried with much wailing that the cup of St. Edmund was consumed. And when many sought the stones and metal plates in all directions among the ashes and cinders, they brought forth the cup quite unharmed. It was lying in the midst of a heap of ashes, which were now cool, and it was found covered with a linen cloth, which, however, was halfburned. The oak chest, also, in which the cup was usually placed, had been burnt to ashes, and only the iron fastenings and the iron lock were found. Then when we saw this miracle, we all wept for joy.
Then when we saw that the greater part of the front of the shrine had been ruined, and were angered at the wickedness of the cause of the fire, with common assent a goldsmith was privately summoned, and we caused him to make plates and fix on the shrine without any delay, that the scandal might be avoided, and we caused the signs of the fire to be covered up with wax or in some other way.
But the gospel bears witness, There is nothing hid which shall not be revealed. Very early in the morning there came strangers bearing gifts, and noticed nothing of the fire. Yet some of them looking round, asked where the fire round the shrine had been, of which they had already heard. And so when it was impossible to conceal it altogether, we answered those who asked that a candle had fillen and burnt three napkins, and that owing to the heat of the fire some stones on the front of the shrine had been destroyed. Yet lying rumour pretended that the head of the saint had been burnt ; some said that only the hair had been consumed ; but in the end the truth was known, and the mouth of them that spoke lies was stopped.
Now all this was done, by the providence of the Lord, that the
places round the shrine of His saint might be more honestly cared
for, and that that which the lord abbot proposed might the more
quickly come and without delay come to a fitting conclusion. For
he proposed that the shrine, with the body of the glorious martyr,
should be placed more securely and splendidly in a more prominent
position. And, before this same misfortune befell, the crest of
the shrine was half finished, and the marble stones for raising
and supporting the shrine had been largely prepared and polished.
HOW THE ABBOT ATTRIBUTED THE FIRE TO THE GREED OF THE MONKS
THE lord abbot, who was absent, was greatly grieved when he heard these rumours. And on his return home, he came into the chapter and said that these and other like perils would result from our sins, and especially because of our murmuring about our food and drink. And he turned the blame to some degree rather on the whole monastery than on the avarice and carelessness of the guardians of the shrine.
Therefore, that he might skilfully lead us to abstain from our
pittances, at least for one year, and that we might appropriate
the revenues of the pittancy to the restoration of the shrine
with pure gold, he gave the first example of generosity himself.
For in our presence, he gave the whole treasure in gold, which
he had, that is, fifteen golden rings of the value, it is believed,
of sixty marks, towards the restoration of the shrine. And we
all granted that our pittances should be given for this purpose,
until our decision was changed by the sacristan, who said that
St. Edmund was well able without such assistance to repair his
CONCERNING THE DREAM THAT A CERTAIN GREAT PERSON HAD, AND HOW THE ABBOT INTERPRETED THE SAME
AT this time some great person, I know not who it was, came and told a vision of his to the abbot, whereby the abbot was much moved, and related it in full chapter with a very bitter speech. And he told it in this way: "That is a true vision," he said, " which a certain great man has seen; For he beheld the holy martyr Edmund lying without his shrine, and saying with groans that he was robbed of his garments and wasted with hunger and thirst, and that his cemetery and the halls of his church arc carelessly guarded."
And the abbot interpreted this dream in the presence of all, turning
the blame on us in this way: "St. Edmund declares that he
is naked because you withheld your old clothes from the
naked poor, and give unwillingly that which you ought to give,
and do the same in the matter of food and drink. The idleness,
the neglect of the sacristan and his fellows, is very clear from
the recent disaster of the fire which has occurred between the
shrine and the altar."
HOW THE MONKS INTERPRETED THE DREAM IN A DIFFERENT WAY, AND HOW THEY ANGERED THE ABBOT ON THAT ACCOUNT
AT these words the monastery was grieved, and after the chapter many of the brothers met together and interpreted the dream in this way : " We are the naked limbs of St. Edmund," they said, " and the monastery is his naked body. For we have been despoiled of our ancient customary dues and liberties. The abbot has all things ; the chamberlain ship, the sacristry, the cellar. And we perish with hunger and thirst, when we cannot have our food save by means of a clerk of the abbot and through his ministration, If the guardians of the shrine were negligent, the abbot may put it down to himself, for he it was who appointed such men." And in this way many spoke in the monastery.
But when this interpretation was made known to the abbot, as he was in the forest of Harlow on his way back from London, he was very wroth and greatly moved, and he answered and said, "They would turn that dream against me. By the face of God! as soon as I shall reach home, I will restore to them what they call their customary dues, and I will take my clerk away from the cellarer, and I will leave them to their own devices. And at the end of the year I shall see how wise they are. For this year I have stayed at home, and I have caused their cellar to be supplied without debt. And they show such gratitude towards me!
And so when he returned home, and was intending to translate the
holy martyr, he humbled himself before God and men, thinking that
he would amend his way in all things, and make peace with all
men, and especially with his monastery. Then as he sat in the
chapter, he ordered a cellarer and subcellarer to be chosen by
our common assent ; and he removed his clerk, saying that whatever
he had done, he had done for our welfare, calling to witness God
and His saints, and excusing himself in many ways.
CONCERNING THE TRANSLATION OF THE BODY OF SAINT EDMUND
AD 1198 20th November
HEAR, O Heaven, the things which I speak; give ear, 0 earth, to the deed of abbot Samson. For, when the feast of St. Edmund drew nigh, the marble stones were polished, and all things were made ready for the elevation of the shrine. Accordingly, the feast was celebrated on a Friday, and on the following Sunday a three days' fast was proclaimed to the people, and the cause for that fast was publicly announced. Moreover, the abbot preached to the people that they should prepare themselves for the transference of the shrine and for placing it upon the high altar, until the masons should have completed their preparations. And he appointed a time and method for so great a work.
Therefore, when we had on that night come to the time of matins, the great shrine stood upon the altar empty within, adorned with white doe-skins, and one panel stood below against a pillar of the church, and the holy body lay still where it was wont to lie. Then hymns of praise were sung, and we all went to take our discipline. After that, the lord abbot and some with him were clothed in white raiment, and approaching with reverence, as was right, hastened to uncover the coffin.
Now there wasa linen cloth outside, which covered the coffin and all the other things, and which was found to be fastened with some strings of its own. Next there was a silken cloth, and then another linen cloth, and then a third, and so at last the coffin was uncovered and stood upon a wooden stand, that the coffin might not be harmed by the marble stone.
Above the breast of the martyr, and on the outside of the coffin,!here lay a golden angel of the length of a man's foot, having a golden sword in one hand and a standard in the other. And beneath it was a hole in the coffin's cover, where the former guardians of the martyr were wont to put in their hands to touch the holy body. And there was this verse written over the image :
Lo! the image of St. Michael keeps the martyr's corpse.
And there were iron rings at the two ends of the coffin, as there used to be in Danish chests.
Therefore raising the coffin with the body, they bore it to the altar, and I gave my sinful hand to help in the carrying, though the abbot had ordered that no one should approach unless be were summoned. And the coffin was enclosed in the shrine, the panel being put in place and shut up.
Now we all thought that the abbot would show the coffin to the people in the octave of thefeast, and would have the holy body translated in the presence of all men; but we were quite deceived, as that which followed proved. On the Wednesday, while the monastery was chanting compline, the abbot spoke with the sacristan and Walter the physician, and having taken counsel, summoned twelve brothers, who were strong to bear the panels of the shrine, and were skilled in fastening and unfastening them. And the abbot said that he had prayed to see his patron saint, and that he wished that the sacristan and Walter the physician should be joined with him in making the inspection. And the two chaplains of the abbot were named, and the two guardians of the shrine, and the two masters of the vestry, and six others, the sacristan Hugh, Walter the physician, Augustine, William de Diss, Robert and Richard.
So while the monastery slept, those twelve dressed in white, drew the coffin from the shrine, and bore it and placed it on a table near the old place of the shrine. And they prepared themselves to remove the cover, which was joined and fastened to the coffin with sixteen very long iron nails. And when they had with difficulty done this, all were ordered to stand afar off, save the two associates above mentioned.
Now the coffin was filled with the holy body, and that both in respect of its length and of its breadth, so that it was hardly possible for a needle to be placed between the head and the wood, or between the feet and the wood. And the head lay joined to the body, being a little raised by a small pillow.
And so the abbot looking near, found after this a silken cloth which covered the whole body, and then a linen cloth of wonderful whiteness ; and over the head a little linen cloth, and another small and skilfully made silken cloth, as it were the veil of some holy woman. And then they found the body wrapped in a linen cloth, and so at last all the lines of the holy body were clearly traceable.
Here the abbot stopped, saying that he dared not go further, and behold the naked body of the saint. Therefore, he held his head between his hands, and said with a groan, "Glorious martyr, holy Edmund, blessed be that hour in the which you were born. Glorious martyr, turn not my daring to my hurt? in that I, who am a sinner and wretched, touch you. You know my devotion and my intention." And then he touched the eyes and nose, the latter being thick and very large, and afterwards touched the breast and arms, and raising the left hand touched the fingers and placed his own fingers between those of the saint. And going further, be found the feet standing upright as though they had been the feet of a man but lately dead,and he touched the toes, and counted them as he touched them.
And then counsel was taken that other brothers should be summoned and behold these miraculous things, and six came upon summons, and six other brothers who forced their way in without the assent of the abbot, and these saw the holy body. Their names were Walter do St. Alban's, Hugh the farmer, Gilbert the prior's brother, Richard do Hengham, Jocell the cellarer, and Thurstan the Little; and the last alone put forth his hand and touched the feet and knees of the saint. And, that there might be abundance of witnesses, by the disposition of the Highest, one of our brothers, John de Diss, sat on the roof of the church with the servants of the vestry, and saw all these things plainly.
After these things had been done, the cover was fastened on the coffin with the same nails as before, and with the same number and in the same manner, and the martyr was covered with the same cloths and those in the same order, as he had first been found. And then the coffin was placed in its accustomed place, and on the coffin, near the angel, there was placed a certain silken bag, in which a document, written in English, was put setting forth certain salutations of Aylwin the monk, as it is said, and this document was before found near the golden angel when the coffin was uncovered.
And by order of the abbot another little writing was also made, and hidden in the same bag, and the words of this second writing were as follows. "In the year of the incarnation of the Lord one thousand one hundred and ninety eight, abbot Samson, being led by devotion, saw and touched the body of St. Edmund, on the night next after the feast of St. Catherine, in the presence of these witnesses," and there were written below the names of the eighteen monks.
Then the brothers wrapped the whole coffin in a sufficiently large linen cloth, and placed above it a valuable new silken cloth, which Hubert, archbishop of Canterbury, had sent as an offering in the same year, and they placed a certain double linen cloth of the same length as the coffin next the stone, that neither the coffin nor the wooden platform on which it rested might be injured by the stone. After this the panels were brought up and fitly joined together in the shrine.
And when the monastery came to chant matins, and saw these things, all who had not seen the body were grieved, and said among themselves, " We have been grossly deceived." But when the hours of matins had been chanted, the abbot called the monas tery before the high altar, and having briefly explained to them that which had been done, declared that it was neither right nor possible to summon them all to such events. And on hearing this we sang "Te Deum laudamas " with tears, and hastened to ring the bells in the choir.
Four days later the abbot deposed the guardians of the shrine,
and the guardian of the shrine of St. Botolph, and he appointed
new guardians for whorn he laid down rules, that they might take
more honest and diligent care of the sanctuaries. And the great
altar, up to this time, was concave, and on it things were often
placed with little reverence. This space and that which was between
the shrine and the altar, he caused to be filled up with stone
and cement, that there might be no danger of fire possible for
the negligence of the guardians, as had been the case before,
according to that which a wise man says, Happy is he whom the
perils of others make cautious.
HOW KING JOHN VISITED THE ABBEY SOON AFTER HIS ACCESSION
WHEN the abbot had purchased the favour and grace of king Richard with gifts and money, so that he believed that he could carry through all his affairs according to his desire, king Richard died, and the abbot lost his labour and expenditure. But king John after his coronation, laying aside all his other work, at once came to St. Edmund's, being led to do so by his vow and devotion. And we thought that he would have made some great offering, but he offered a silken cloth, which his servants borrowed from our sacristan and have not yet paid for.
He enjoyed the hospitality of St. Edmund, which involved great
expenses, and when he left he gave nothing at all honourable or
beneficial to the saint, except thirteen pence sterling, which
he paid for a mass for himself, on the day on which he departed
CONCERNING THE DISPUTE BETWEEN THE PORTER AND THE MONKS
AT that time some of our officials complained and said in the chapter that Ralph the porter, our servant, appeared in cases and suits against them to the injury of the church and to the prejudice of the monastery. The prior commanded, with the common assent of the monastery, that he should be punished according to our custom by which our servants were wont to be punished, that is by the confiscation of their incomes.
Therefore orders were given that the cellarer should withdraw from him, not the salary which of right pertained to his office, according to the witness of his charter, but certain additions and grants which the cellarer and subcellarer had made to him, without the assent of the monastery. But the same Ralph, taking with him certain of those of the table of the abbot, complained to the abbot on his return from London, that the prior and the monastery had deprived him of his salary, of which he was possessed when the abbot first came into the abbacy. And they told the abbot that this was done without him, and to his shame, and unreasonably, when he was not consulted and the case was not tried.
Then the abbot believed this, and was moved more than was right or usual with him, and constantly excusing Ralph and protesting that he was innocent, came into the chapter. And making complaint on this matter, he said that what was done, was done to his prejudice, since he was not consulted. Then one answered, all the rest supporting him, that this had been done by the prior and with the assent of the whole chapter.
Thereupon the abbot was confused, and said, "I have nourished and brought up children, and they have rebelled against me." And passing over nothing, as he should have done for the peace of the multitude, but rather showing his power, and not allowing himself to be overcome, he publicly commanded the cellarer that he should fully and completely restore all things which had been taken away to the said Ralph, and that he should drink nothing but water until he had restored all things.
But when Jocell the cellarer heard this, he chose rather to drink
water on that day, than to return Ralph his salary contrary to
the will of the monastery. And when the abbot learnt this, on
the morrow he forbade the cellarer to eat or drink until he had
made complete restitution. And having spoken thus, the abbot at
once left the town, and absented himself for eight days.
HOW DISTURBANCES AROSE IN THE MONASTERY, AND OF THE END TO WHICH THEY CAME
ON the dayof the abbot's departure,the cellarer arose in the chapter, and showing the command of the abbot, and holding his keys in his hand, said that he would rather be deposed from his office than do anything against the monastery. And there arose a great disturbance in the monastery, such as I never saw before ; and they said that the command of the abbot ought not to be observed. But the older and wiser men of the monastery, who wisely kept silence, at last declared that obedience was due to the abbot in all things, unless they were clearly against God, and they agreed in declaring that we must bear with this evil doing for a time and for the sake of peace, lest worst should befal us.
And when the prior had begun to chant the Verba Mea for the dead, as was the custom, the novices resisted, and with them almost half the monastery, and with aloud voice they disputed and opposed him. Yet the older half of the monastery prevailed, though they were few in number as compared with the multitude on the other side.
Now the abbot, being absent, frightened some by his threatening messages, and won over some with his graciousness, and he caused the chief men to abandon the views of the whole body, as though they feared hisgarments. And so the gospel was fulfilled," Every kingdom divided against itself is brought to desolation. And the abbot said that he would in nowise come among us, owing to our conspiracies and the oaths which, as he said, we had taken against him, that we would kill him with our knives.
Then he returned home and sat in his chamber. And he sent word to one of our brothers, who was greatly suspected by him, that he should come to him, and because he would not come, as fearing that he would be taken and bound, he was excommunicated, and for a whole day afterwards he was placed in bonds and remained until morning in the infirmary. The abbot bound three others with a smaller sentence, that the rest might fear.
Next day counsel was taken to summon the abbot and to humble ourselves before him in word and gesture, whereby his mind might be calmed, and so it was done. Then he answered with some humility, but always justifying himself and blaming us, and when he saw that we were ready to be conquered, he was overcome. And with many tears, he swore that he had never been so grieved for anything as for this matter, both for his own sake and for ours, and especially for the evil report, which had already spread abroad our dissension, and which said that the monks of St. Edmund wished to slay their abbot.
Then when the abbot had also told how he absented himself of intent until his anger should have cooled, and repeated the word of the philosopher, I would not have taken vengeance on you, unless I had been angry, he arose with tears and received all and every one of us with the kiss of peace. He wept, and we wept with him. Forthwith the excommunicated brothers were absolved, and thus the storm ceased and there was a great calm.
Yet the abbot secretly ordered that the accustomed salary should
be given to Ralph the porter as before and in full. This we passed
over, at last realising that there is no lord who does not wish
to rule, and that it is a dangerous battle to strive against the
stronger and to undertake a contest with the more powerful.
CONCERNING THE KNIGHTS OF SAINT EDMUND AND THEIR FIEFS
IN the year of grace one thousand and two hundred, an account of the knights of St. Edmund and of their fiefs was made, of which their ancestors had been possessed.
Alberic de Vere holds five knights and half a knight ; that is, in Loddon, and in Brome, one knight; in Mendham and Preston, one knight in Rede, one knight ; and in Cokefield, half a knight and in Livcrmerc, two knights.
William de Hastings holds five knights; namely, in Lidgate and in Blunham and in Harling the fees of three knights, and in Tibenham and Gissing, two.
Earl Roger holds three knights in Nortune and Brisingeham.
Robert Fitzroger holds the fee of one Knight in Marlesford.
Alexander de Kirkby holds the fee of one knight in Kirkby.
Roger de Eu holds the fees of two knights in Mickfield and in Topescroft.
Arnald de Charneles and his partners, one knight in Oakley and in Quiddenham, and in Thurston and Stuston.
Osbert de Wachesham, one knight in Marlingford and Wortham.
William de Tostock, one knight in Randeston.
Gilbert FitzRalph, three knights; namely, in Thelnetham and Hepworth one knight; in Reydon, in Blithing, and in Gissing one knight, and in Saxham one knight.
Radulfde Bukenham,halfa knight in Old Bukenham.
William de Berdewcll, two knights in Barningham, and in Berdewell, and in Hunston, and in Stanton.
Robert de Langetot holds three knights, in Stowbangtoft and in Ashfield, in Troston, and in Little Waltham in Essex.
Adam de Cokefield, two knights, namely, in Lavenham and in Onehouse one knight, and in Lilesey.
Robert FitzWalter, one knipht and in Sapeston.
William Blund, one knight in Thorp.
Gilbert de Peche, two knights, namely in Waude and in Gedding one knight, and in Falsham and Euston and Groton one knight.
Gilbert de St. Clare, two knights in Bradfield and Wattisfield.
Geoffirey de Whelnetham and Gilbert de Manston, one knight in Whelnetham and in Manston.
Hubert de Ansty, half a knight in Briddinghoe.
Gervase de Rothing, one knight in Chipley and in Rothing.
Robert de Halstcdc, one knight in Halstede and half a knight in Brockley.
Reginald de Brockley, one knight in Brockley.
Simon de Patteshall, half a knight in Whatefield.
Peter FitzAlan, half a knight in Brockley.
Ralph de Presserei, half a knight in Stanningfield.
Richard de Ickworth, two knights in Ickworth and in Wangford.
Robert de Horning, half a knight in Horningsherth.
Walter de Saxhami one knight in Ashfield and Saxham.
William de Wordwell, half a knight in Whelnetham.
Norman de Risby, half a knight in Risby.
Peter de Livermere and Alan de Flemetun, one knight in Livermere and Ampton.
Roger de Muriaux, one knight in Thorp.
Hugh de Eleigh, two knights in Eleigh and Preston and Bradfield.
Stephen de Brockdish, a fourth of one knight in Brockdish
Adam de Barningliam, a fourth of one knight in Barningham
William de Wordvvell, a fourth of one knight in Livermere and
CONCERNING THE MANORS OF GEOFFREY RUFFUS, AND THE CELLAR
GEOFFREY RUFFUS, our monk, though he lived in rather too secular a manner, was of use to us in the custody of four manors, Barton, Pakenham, Rougham, and Bradfield, where there had often in former times been a deficiency in rent. But when the abbot heard ill reports of his morals, for a long while he concealed the matter, perchance because Geoffrey was clearly useful to the whole community. At last, when the truth was known, he suddenly caused his chests to be taken and placed in the vestry, and all the stock of the manors to be strictly guarded, and placed the said Geoffrey in the cloister. There was found a great store of gold and silver to the value of two hundred marks, and all of this the abbot decreed should be devoted to the building of the front of the shrine of St. Edmund.
And when Michaelmas came it was decided in the chapter that two brothers, and not one alone, should succeed to the custody of the manors, Of these one was Roger de Hengham, who publicly promised that he would as well as he could take charge both of the manors and the cellar, and the abbot assented to this, though the monastery was unwilling. Jocell, the cellarer, was then deposed. He had well and providently managed his office, and had controlled the cellar for two years, without contracting debt, contrary to the custom of the other cellarers. And he was made subcellarer. But at the end of the year Roger rendered an account Of his receipts and expenses, and declared that he had received sixty rnarks from the stock of the manors to supplement the deficit of the cellarer.
Therefore, when counsel had been taken, the said jocell was replaced
at the cellar, and Mildenhall, and Chebenhall, and Southwold,
and other manors were entrusted to Roger and Albinus, and were
separated from the cellar, that neither the manors might be destroyed
for the sake of the cellar, nor the cellar destroyed for the sake
of the manors.
CONCERNING THAT WHICH OCCURRED ON THE DEATH OF ADAM DE COKEFIELD
WHEN Adam dc Cokefield was dead, the abbot could have taken three hundred marks for the wardship of the only daughter of Adam ; but as the grandfather of the maid had secretly removed her, and the abbot could not obtain posession of her person, save with the held of the archbishop, he granted that wardship to Hubert, archbishop of Canterbury, on receipt of a hundred pounds.
The archbishop, when he had received five hundred marks, granted that wardship to Thomas de Burgh, brother of the chamberlain of the king, and the maiden was given to him with her right by the hand of the abbot. Thomas then at once sought scisin of three manors, which had been in our hand after the death of Adam, Cokefield, Semere, and Groton. We thought that we could retain them all in our demesne, or at least two of them,Semere and Groton, both because Robert de Cokefield on his deathbed had publicly declared that he claimed no hereditary right in those two manors, and because his son Adam in full court had acknowledged our right to those two manors, and had given his charter on the point, wherein it was laid down that he held those two manors, by the grace of the monastery, for his life only.
When Thomas, then, sought a writ of recognition on the matter,
he caused the knights to be summoned to come to mike oath before
the king at Tewkesbury. our charters read in public had no weight,
for the whole court was against us. And when oath had been made,
the knights said that they knew nothing of our charters, or our
private agreements ; but they said that they believed that Adam
and his father and grandfather for a hundred years back had held
the manors in feefarm, and each after the other, on the
days when they were alive and dead. So we were disseised by the
judgment of the court after undergoing many labours and many expenses,
though the old annual payments of rent were preserved.
HOW THE ABBOT RECEIVED THE ABBOT OF CLUNY
THE lord abbot seemed to be deceived by some appearance of right,
because the scripture truly says, I will not give my glory to
another. For when the abbot of Cluny came to us, and was received
by us as was fittting, our abbot would not give place to him,
either in the chapter or in the procession which took place on
the Sunday, but sat and stood between the abbot of Cluny and the
abbot of Chertsey. And upon this there were different opinions,
and many said many things.
HOW ROBERT THE PRIOR DIED, AND OF THE DISCUSSIONS AS TO HIS SUCCESSOR
WHILE Robert the prior was ill and still lived, there was much talk as to the appointment of a new prior. Then one said that the lord abbot, sitting in the choir and beholding all the brothers, from the first to the last, had not found anyone on Whom his spirit might rest to make him prior, save Heribert his chaplain. By these and other like things the will of the abbot was made clear to many. And on hearing this, another answered that this was incredible ; he asserted that the abbot, a man diligent and provident, would never give the office of prior to such a man, who was a youth and almost a beardless novice twelve years before, who had only been a cloistered monk for four years, and who was not proved in the rule of souls.
Then when the prior was dead, the abbot was in London, and one said, "A month has not yet passed since the abbot made Heribert chaplain and subsacristan, and when he gave that post to him in the chapel of St. Nicasius, he did so with a promise that if it were in any way possible to make him prior, he would devote all his care to doing so." Another heard this, and wishing to please the abbot and him who was to be prior, made request to many, both old and young, that when opportunity was given they would nominate Heribert, at ]east in conjunction with others, for the office of prior. And he swore that in this way they would please the abbot, for such was his will.
And there were, indeed, many both among the older and among the younger men, who asserted that the same Heribert was an amiable and affable man, and worthy of great honour. And there were others also, few indeed in number, but more praised in counsel and from the wiser section of the monastery, who wished for master Hermer, the subprior, a mature man, learned and eloquent, skilled and experienced in the rule of souls, who had then ruled the cloister with success for fourteen years, an approved subprior and one known. They wished, I say, that he might be preferred to the post of prior, according to the word of wisdom, Trust an experienced master. But the multitude secretly murmured to the contrary, saying that he was a man of ill temper, impatient, restless, turbulent, nervous, litigious, a disturber of the peace. And they mocked him, saying that " the wisdorh of a man appears in his patience."
One also said, "There is this one thing which, as it is a scandal, as it a scandal, must be greatly feared, that the subprior being removed, learned clerks may not condescend to receive the garb of religion among us, if perchance it happen that some dumb idol be raised up, and a wooden log preferred in so great a monastery." And the same brother added that such a man should be prior of our monastery that, if any matter connected with some great question of ecclesiastical or secular business arose, while the abbot was absent, it might be referred to the prior as to one who was the highest and most discreet member.
When he heard these and other like sayings, one of the brothers
said, " Why is it that you multiply so many and such words?
When the abbot shall come home, he will do what he wills on this
matter. Perchance he will seek counsel from all of us and that
privately and with much solemnity; but eventually, by argumentg
and plausible reasonings and twisting words, he will at last reach
the fulfilment of his will. And as he has beforehand decided,
so will the niatter go."
HOW HERIBERT WAS ELECTED PRIOR
THEN the abbot returned and as he sat in the chapter, he put forward many things with sufficient eloquence as to the type of man who ought to be made prior. And John the third prior answered, in the presence of all, that the subprior was worthy, and a suitable person. But at once the multitude cried out, saying, " Give us a man of peace, a man of peace," And two of us answered so great a multitude, and said that such a man ought to be appointed as knew how to rule souls, and to discern between leprosy and leprosy ; and this speech was very displeasing since it seemed to favour the party of the subprior.
But the abbot, hearing this tumult, said that he would, after chapter, hear the advice of all men, that so he might proceed wisely in the matter, and on the morrow would settle the affair as he would. And meanwhile one said that the abbot was proceeding with this ceremony that he might cautiously prevent the subprior from obtaining the office of prior, but as if this had been done by the advice of the monastery, and not by the will of the abbot, and that the abbot himself might be held as excused. By this art the mouth of them that speak lies should be stopped.
When the morrow came, the abbot sat in the chapter and wept bitterly. And he said that he had not slept all that night, owing to his anxiety and fear lest he might nominate someone who should not be pleasing to God; and he swore on the peril of his soul that he would nominate four of us, who according to his opinion were the most fitted and suitable, that we might choose one of the four. Then the abbot named first the sacristan, of whom he knew well that he was a weak and incompetent man, as the sacristan himself witnessed with an oath. And at once before us all he named John the third prior, his relative, and Maurice his chaplain, and the said Heribert, all of whom were full young, about forty years old or less, and all of moderate intelligence, and men who needed to learn, rather than to teach, the rule of souls, though they were ready to learn.
The abbot nominated these three and put them forward, and he passed over the subprior and many other of the senior monks, who were older, more experienced, learned, and who included those who had formerly been masters of schools, and all the others. Then the abbot spoke at length and highly commended the person of John, but yet put forward also the opposite opinion, saying that the number of his relatives in this district would be a weight round his neck if he were made prior.
And as the abbot was ready to say the same of Maurice, as he could do, and thus craftily proceed to the mention of Heribert, his speech was interrupted, one of the older men of the monastery saying, "Master precentor, it is yours to speak first ; nominate lord Heribert." Then the precentor said, " He is a good man." And when he heard the name of Heribert, the abbot ceased speaking, and turning to the precentor said, "I will readily receive Heribert, if it is your wish."
At these words the whole monastery cried out, "He is a good man; he is a good man and lovable." And many of the older men witnessed this same thing, and at once the precentor and some friend with him, and two others from the other side, rose with all haste and placed Heribert in the midst.
But Heribert at first humbly begged to be excused, saying that he was unable to support so great an office, and especially, as he said, because he was not so well instructed as to be able to preach in the chapter, as the prior ought to do. Many were amazed when they saw such things, and were dumb with confusion.
But the abbot said much to console him, and as it were, in prejudice
of learned men, saying that he was well able to remember and consider
the sermons of others, as others did. And he condemned rhetorical
colouring and elaborate verbiage, and neatly turned sentences
in a sermon, saying that in many churches the sermon is delivered
in French, or rather in English, for the securing of the improvement
of manners, and not as a literary exercise. And when he had so
spoken, the newly received prior went to the feet of the abbot,
and kissed them. But the abbot received him with tears, and placed
him with his own hand in the prior's stall, and commanded all
that they should should show him due reverence and obedience as
HOW THE AUTHOR REFLECTED ON THE CHOICE OF HERIBERT
WHEN the chapter was ended, I was sitting as guestmaster in the porch of the guesthouse, and I was amazed and revolved in my mind that which 1 had seen and heard. And I began to think subtly for what reason and for what special merits, such a man deserved to be promoted to so great a position. And I began to reflect that he was a man of comely stature and personal appearance, that he was a handsome man and had a kindly face ; that he was always cheerful, and showed a smiling face early and late, and friendly to all men; that he was quiet in his manner, sober in his walk, polite in speech, with a sweet voice for chanting and good for reading. I reflected that he was young, strong, and sound in health, and fitted to labour for the needs of the church ; that he knew how to suit himself to place and time, at one moment to laymen, at another to clerks, at another to the regular clergy, and at another to the secular men that he was liberal, sociable, and facile ; that he was not spiteful in punishing, nor suspicious, nor greedy, nor tiring, nor lazy. I reflected that he was sober, and a fluent speaker in the French tongue, as he was a Norman by birth ; that he was a man of fair intelligence, who, if learning would not drive him mad, at least could be called a man of absolute probity.
And when I thought on these things, I said, in my heart, that
such a man would be popular, but that nothing is altogether blessed.
And I wept for joy, saying that the Lord hath visited us, and
as it pleased the Lord, so it had come to pass. But suddenly another
thought came to me, "Praise a new man sparingly, for honours
change manners, or rather make them known. Wait and see first
whom and what manner of men he has as his advisers, and whom he
trusts, for everything naturally draws towards its like. The event
will prove that which has been done, and therefore 1 will praise
HOW THE UNLEARNED BROTHERS MOCKED THOSE THAT WERE LEARNED
ON the same day some unlearned brothers, both officials and cloistered monks, assembled and sharpened their tongues like a sword that they might privily shoot at the learned. And repeating the words of the abbot which he had on the same day spoken, as if in prejudice of the learned, they said amongst themselves, " Now let our philosophers take to their philosophy; now one can see clearly how their philosophy profits them! Our good clerks have declined so often in the cloister that they are all declined. They have sermoniscd so much in the chapter, that they are all rejected. They have spoken so often about distinguishing between leprosy and leprosy, that they are now put forth as lepers. They have declined muya, musae so often, that they are all reckoned as fools."
These and like words did some put forth in mockery of others and
to their shame, and were pleased'with their own folly. They abused
knowledge of letters, and disparaged those who were learned, rejoicing
greatly and hoping great things which perchance will never come
to pass, for, Hope of good is ofttimes falsified.
HOW THE ABBOT WAS NOT PERFECT
A WISE man has said that no one is altogether blessed, and so abbot Samson was not. This indeed I will say, that, in my opinion, he is not to be commended in that which he did when he ordered a charter to be drawn up and to be given to a certain servant of his, that he might have the sergeanty of John Ruffus, after the death of the said John. Ten marks, as has been said, blinded the eyes of the wise.
Master Dennis, also, our monk, speaking of this matter, said that
it was a thing unheard of, and the abbot answered, " I will
not cease to do my will for you, any more than I would do for
that boy there." And the abbot did the same thing in the
case of the sergeanty of Adam the farmer, and received a hundred
shillings. Of such an act one may say that a little leaven leaveneth
the whole lamp.
CONCERNING THE FISHPONDS OF BABWELL
THERE is also another ill deed, a stain which, by the will of
God, he may wash away with the tears of penitence, lest one excess
counterbalance so great a sum of good actions. He raised the dam
of the fishpond at Babwell, near the new mill, to such a height
that owing to the holding back of the waters there was no man,
rich or poor, who had land near the water from the gate of the
town to the eastern gate, who did not lose his garden and orchards.
The pasture of the cellarer, on one part of the bank was lost,
and the arable land of the persons near was made worse. The meadow
of the cellarer, and the orchard of the farmer, were swallowed
up in the abundance of water, and all the neighbours complained
of the thing. And when the cellarer complained to him in full
chapter about so great a loss, he at once answered with anger
that his fishpond should not suffer for the benefit of our meadow.
WHETHER IT IS BETTER TO HAVE AN ABBOT FROM ONE'S OWN HOUSE
THE dean of London writes as follows in his chronicles:" King Henry the Second, having a discussion as to the vacant abbacies with the archbishop and bishops, so observed the rule of the canons in the matter of appointing abbots, as to make use of votes obtained from other houses. Perhaps he thought that if pastors were everywhere created by their own body, the familiarity which had been contracted before election would lead to impunity for vices ; equality glosses over faults; and there will be too much slackness in the cloisters."
Another has said, "It does not seem right that a pastor should
be chosen from his own house, but rather from another. For if
he be taken from another house, he will ever believe, according
to size of the monastery which he has undertaken to rule, that
many are wise, and will ~,eek their counsel, if he be a good man,
and if he be an evil man, he will fear their virtue. But a member
of the house knows fully the ignorance, weakness and incompetence
of all, and he will raven with the greater security, mingling
square with round." The monks of Ramsey, acting an these
grounds, when they had full power to choose whomsoever they would
of their own number, twice elected an abbot from foreign houses,
in our own times.
HOW THERE WAS A QUARREL WITH THE MONKS OF ELY
IN the year of grace one thousand two hundred and one, the abbot of Flaix came to us, who with the assent of the abbot, and by his own preaching, caused public buyings and sellings which had taken place on Sundays in the market place to be abandoned, and it was decreed that they should be held on Mondays. The same abbot did the like in many cities and boroughs of England.
Ans in the same year, the monks of Ely set up a market for buying
and selling at Lakenheath, for which they had the assent and charter
of the king. But we, at first, with our friends and neighbours,
labouring peacefully, sent messengers to the chapter of Ely, and
also at first letters to the lord of Ely, praying that they would
desist from that which had been begun. And we added that we would
in a friednly manner pay the fifteen marks which had been given
for thr charter obtained from the king for the sake of peace,
and for the securing of the maintenance of mutual affection. What
more need be said? They would not desist, and threatening words
went to and fro, and spears threatened spears.
But we received a writ of recognition as to whether that market had been established to the prejudice of ourselves and market town of St. Edmund's. And oath was made, and it was protested that this was done to our injury. And when it was told to the king, the king caused inquest to be made by his registrar as to the kind of charter which he had given to the monks of Ely, and it was found that he had given them the said market under this condition, that it should not be to the detriment of the neighbouring markets.
However the king, when forty marks were promised to him, made us a charter that no market should henceforth be made without the assent of the abbot. And he wrote to Geoffrey FitzPetcr, the justiciar, that the market of Lakenheath should be destroyed. Then the justiciar wrote to the sheriff of Suffolk to the same effect.
And the sheriff, knowing that he was not able to enter the liberties of St. Edmund, nor to exercise any power there, sent this to the abbot by his writ, that this same thing might be carried out according to the command of the king.
So the bailiff of the hundred came thither on the market day with the witness of the free men, and publicly forbade that market in the name of the king, and exhibited the letters of the king and of the sheriff. But being assailed with abuse and injuries, he departed without performing his work. But the abbot put off the matter for a time, and when he was in London, consulted the wise men on the point. Then he sent word to his bailiffs that they should take the men of St. Edmund, with horses and arms, and destroy the market, and if they found any buying or selling, they should bring them in bonds with them.
So at midnight, there went out almost six hundred coming, all those who were in the market dispersed hither and thither, and not one was found. On the same night, however, the prior of Ely came with his officials, as he suspected the coming of our men, that he might defend so far as he could those who were selling and buying, but would not leave his lodging. And when our bailiffs demanded from him surety and pledge that he would stand his trial in the court of St. Edmund for the injury which he had done, and he would not give it, having taken counsel, they overthrew the shambles of the butchers and the stalls in the market, and carried them away with them; and they took with them all the cattle, sheep, and oxen, yea, and all the beasts of the field, and made their way towards Icklingham.
The bailiffs of the prior followed them, and asked for their cattle
in pledge for fifteen days ; and it was done as they asked. And
within fifteen days there came a writ, in which the abbot was
summoned to com to the exchequer to make answer for such a deed,
and to the effect that the cattle which had been taken should
in the meanwhile be sent back free. For the bishop of Ely, a
man eloquent and cunning, had in person made complaint on this
matter to the Justiciar and to the magnates of England, saying
that an unheard of act of daring had been done in the land of
St. Etheldreda in time of peace whence also many were moved against
HOW THE ABBOT DISPUTED WITH THE BISHOP OF ELY
MEANWHILE also other causes of dispute arose between the bishop
of Ely and the abbot. For when a youth of Glemesford was accused
in the court of St. Edmund for a breach of the king's peace, and
had long been sought, and in this county, at last the bishop's
seneschal produced that youth, and sought the court of St. Etheldreda
for him, showing the charters and liberties of his lord. But our
bailiffs, when they claimed the right to try the case and the
possession of such liberty, could not be heard. For the county
court placed the matter in respite until it might be decided before
the itinerant justices, so that St. Edmund was driven from his
HOW KING JOHN SUMMONED THE ABBOT TO HIM, AND OF THAT WHICH WAS DONE THEREUPON
AD 1203, 21st January
Now when the abbot heard of this he proposed to cross the sea, but as he was ill, he wished to put it off until the feast of the Purification. And lo! on St. Agnes' day, there came a messenger from the king, bearing a brief from the lord pope, in which it was laid down that the lord of Ely and the abbot of St. Edmund's should make inquest concerning Geoffrey FitzPeter and William de Stuteville and certain other magnates of England, who had taken the cross, and for whose absolution the lord king made request, alleging the infirm I ty of their health, and the need of their advice for the preservation of his realm. And the same messenger bore letters of the lord king, ordering that when the letters had been read, the abbot should come to speak with him concerning the message of the lord pope.
Then the abbot was disturbed, and said, "I am straitened on every side. I must offiend either God or the king. By the true God, come what may, I will not knowingly lic." And so he came home with all speed, being rather weak with illness and mind, and being humbled and timid, contrary to his usual manner, by means of the prior, he sought counsel of us, which he had very rarely done hitherto. And he asked what was to be done about the threatened liberties of the church, and whence the expenses undertake this might be provided if he were to journey, and to whom the custody of the abbey should be given, and what was to be done as to the poor servants who had long time served him.
And it was answered that he should go in person and that he should borrow enough money, which should be paid from our sacristry and pittances, and from our other revenues according to his will. And it was answered that he should commit the abbey to the care of the prior and of another clerk, whom he had enriched, and who could meanwhile live of his own, that thus the abbot might save expense, and that he should give money to his servants according to the time which they had served him. And when he had heard such counsel, he was pleased, and so it was done.
So the abbot came into the chapter next day, before his departure,
and caused to be borne with him all his books and he presented
them to the church and monastery, and commended our counsel, which
we had shown to him through the prior.
HOW THE ABBOT LEFT THE MONASTERY IN PEACE WITH ALL MEN
MEANWHILE ee heard some murmuring and saying that the abbot was careful and thoughtful for his barony, but as to the liberties of the monastery, which we had lost in his time, that is, for the loss of the court and liberties of the cellarer, and for the liberties of the sacristan in the matter of the appointment ot the bailiffs of the town by the monastery, he said nothing. Therefore the Lord stirred up the spirit ot three brothers of moderate intelligence, and they, having roused many others, came to consult the prior on this matter, that on his departure the abbot might provide for the indemnity of his church in respect of her liberties,
When the abbot heard this, he answered many things which must not be spoken, swearing that he would be lord while he lived. But when vespers came, he spoke gently on the matter with the prior. And on the morrow, as he was about to depart and came to seek leave, as he sat in the chapter, he said that he had satisfied all his servants, and had made his will, as it he were then about to die. Then beginning to speak concerning the liberties of the church, he excused himself, saying that he had changed the ancient customs lest there might be a defect in the king's justice. And he cast the blame on the sacristan, and said that if Durand the bailifr, who was then ill, should die, the sacristan should hold the balliwick in his own hand, and should appoint a bailiff in the presence of the chapter, as had been the ancient custom, provided that this were done by the counsel of the abbot. But he would in nowise return the gifts and presents annually made by the bailiff.
And when we asked what was to be done in the matter of the court of the cellarer which had been lost, and especially as to the pence which the cellarer had been wont to receive for the renewal of pledges, he grew angry at this, and asked by what authority we exacted the right of royal justice, and those thihgs which pertain to the royal powers. And the answer was that we had always had this from the foundation of the church, and even for three years after he received the abbacy, and that we had this liberty still in all our manors for the renewal of pledges. And we said that we ought not to lose our right for the hundred shillings which he privately received each year from the bailifr, and we boldly demanded that we should have such seisin as we had in his day.
But the abbot, as he was in a strait how to answer, wishing to leave us in peace and to go away quietly, ordered that those pence, and the other things which the cellarer demanded, should be sequestrated until he should return. And he promised that on his return he would in all things act with our advice, and would dispose things justly, and render to every man that which was his due. With these words tranquillity was restored, but not for long, since, "Any man may be rich in promises."
NOTES [Still to be integrated into text
870. November 30th. Edmund, king of the East Angles, defeated and slain by Inguar the Dane, at the battle of Hoxne.
870? The remains of Edmund placed in a tomb at Hoxnep the head being laid with the body. A chapel built over them.
90341. Translation of the relics to Beodricsworth. (The date of the translation is variously given ; cp. Mem., I., xxi. it is, however, to be placed somewhere between 903, the year given by the "thirtythree years" of the Curteys Register, and 941, the date of the death of Athelstan, in whose reign Hermannus places the event).
A wooden chapel is built over the shrine.
945. Edmund, son of Edward the Elder, grants the lands round Beodricsworth for the maintenance of the shrine. Four priests and two deacons are appointed as guardians of the shrine, the first six being, " Leofric the deacon, Leofric the priest, Alfrid, Bomfild, Kenelm, and Eilmund."
970 (circa). Abbo of Fleury writes the Passio Sancti Eadmundi, addressed to Dunstan as archbishop.
1010. Thurkill the Dane lands at Ipswich, and Aylwin, chief keeper of the shrine, removes the relics to London.
1013. The relics are brought back from London to Beodricsworth.
1020. The secular clergy, who had been keepers of the shrine, are replaced by twenty Benedictine monks from St. Benet Hulme and Ely. Uvius, prior of Hulme, first abbot.
A stone church built over the shrine by order of Canute, in reparation, it is alleged, for the wrongs done to St. Edmund by his father Sweyn.
1018. Charter of Canute to the monastery of St. Edmund.
1032. Agelnotht archbishop of Canterbury, consecrates the new church.
1044. Visit of Edward the Confessor to the shrine.
Charter of Edward the Confessor,
About this time Beodricsworth becomes known as St. Edmund's.
1050-60. Abbot Leofstan views the corpse of St. Edmund.
1071. Abbot Baldwin defeats the attempt of Arfast, bishop of Thetford, to remove his episcopal seat to St. Edmund's, by appealing to Alexander II., who issues a bull to St. Edmund's.
1095. Translation of the relics by abbot Baldwin.
1095 (circa). Hermannus writes the De Miraculis Sancti Eadmundi.
1097. Abbot Baldwin builds a new church over the shrine.
1102. Abbot Robert I., son of Hugh Lupus, earl of Chester, is deposed for simony by St. Anselm.
1135. Birth of Samson de Tottington.
1156. Hugh I., prior of Westminster, elected abbot.
115963. Journey of Samson to Rome on the matter of the church of Woolpit.
First imprisonment of Samson at Castle Acre.
1166. Samson becomes a monk at St. Edmund's.
1172. Abbot Hugh obtains exemption from legatine authority.
1173. Battle of Fornham.
?Second banishment of Samson to Castle Acre.
Deposition of Prior Hugh ; Robert made prior.
Jocelin de Brakelond becomes a monk at St. Edmund's.
1180. journey of abbot Hugh to Canterbury. He falls from his horse near Rochester (September 9th).
Abbot Hugh returns to the abbey.
(November 15th). Death of abbot Hugh.
11802. Vacancy in the abbacy. Robert the prior rules the house, while Robert de Cokefield and Robert de Flamvill have the wardship of the abbot's lands.
Samson, subsacristan, conducts building and repairs.
1181 (June 10th). Martyrdom of St. Robert.
Residence of the archbishop of Norway in the abbey.
1182. The delegates of the monastery appear before Henry II. to choose a new abbot.
Election of Samson as abbot (February 21st).
Samson received the benediction (February 28th).
Arrival of Samson at St. Edmund's (March 21 st).
Samson made a judge in ecclesiastical causes.
1198. Samson views the corpse of St. Edftiund.
1210. Fall of abbot Samson's tower.
1212 (December 3oth). Death of abbot Samson.
1539. Dissolution of the monastery of St. Edmund.
Jocelin of Brakelond, The Chronicle of Jocelin of Brakelond Monk of St. Edmundsbury: A Picture of Monastic and Social Life on the XIIth Century, newly translated and edited by L.C. Jane, Introduction by Abbot Gasquet, (London: Chatto and Windus, 1907)
2. The index of this edition was not scanned.
This text is part of the Internet Medieval Source Book.
The Sourcebook is a collection of public domain and copy-permitted
texts related to medieval and Byzantine history.